• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

A good Wesley Ep? Check out The First Duty

Jefferies

Captain
Captain
Watched this episode a couple of days ago and I must say I was very pleasantly surprised. Its several years since I last saw this ep and it’s the first time I saw it, while going through the entire series, episode by episode. What surprised me was how well this episode seemed to be written, compared to the general blandness and formulaic approach one seems to get with most other episodes. It all came together for me. This might have to do with the fact that for once characterisation was at the forefront. Also, the conflict in the episode was far less of a random sort than what you get with your typical alien or anomaly of the week plots. It was, in fact, rooted in one of the main characters (the normally entirely nerdy and flawless Wesley Crusher, it’s the first time he reminded me of a human being!). As a result, the episode came across as much more serious and believable than many in my recent viewing experience. Once again a good effort by Ronald D. Moore!

On a side note, even though the squad leader was called Nick Locarno he clearly seemed to be the model of the later Tom Paris from Voyager. Maybe he changed his name when he went to the academy to avoid comparisons to his overbearing father (Admiral Owen Paris) and changed it back later after the new name was tainted by involuntary manslaughter. ;)
 
The episode was on EW's top 10 (or was it 20??) TNG episode list. Good episode & I thought Wes looked pretty cute! Of course he should have 'fessed up to Picard earlier as he should have realized that the Enterprise crew would eventually figure everything out! :lol:
 
Tom Paris was originally supposed to be Nic Locarno, but they found out that if they did use the character then they'd have to pay royalties to the original writer(s) for every episode that he was in. Hence, they changed the name, but it's still fairly obvious given that their backgrounds are almost identical.

Re The First Duty, it's a fantastic little episode. It's a toss up for me, whether this one, or Final Mission, is the best Wesley episode.
 
^
Yes. In fact, in 'Caretaker' it's strongly implied that Tom Paris was in a situation similar to Nick Locarno in this episode. The difference is Paris also played the Wesley role by confessing to his crime when he didn't have to. Aside from the legal complications, the writer wanted this version of Locarno to be more redeemable than his predecessor.

I'd consider 'The First Duty' Wesley's best episode, though yes, 'Final Mission' comes close. :)
 
^^ I'd imagine that the royalties issue coupled with the desire to soften the character up probably made up their minds to change the character. Personally, I'd have liked them to keep Locarno. Even when Wesley dropped him in it, he still insisted on carrying the can for all of them. Plus, there's the added little bit of continuity had they kept the character.

Redemption was always going to play a part with the character, whether it was Paris, or Locarno. Locarno did nothing in The First Duty, for me, to say to me that the character was completely irredeemable.
 
Kegek said:
I'd consider 'The First Duty' Wesley's best episode, though yes, 'Final Mission' comes close. :)

I liked that episode the first couple times I saw it, but quickly got tired of it. It does have some touching, tear jerking moments though.
 
"The First Duty" is fairly great, and my favorite Wesley eps.

But I think I enjoy the Locarno aspect even more, considering the angle I once heard described.

Nick Locarno was to be a cadet similar to Jim Kirk, a standout young man with potential to achieve greatness. Boothby even says as much about him.

But whereas Kirk broke the rules (via the Kobayashi Maru scenario) and got a pat on the back when it worked...

Nick Locarno broke the rules and it went horribly wrong.
He lost it all, his future shot.

Interesting take on what could have happened to a hotshot young Kirk but for the twists of fate.
 
^^ Bet he didn't die taking a metal gangway sleighride down the side of a rockface though! :lol:
 
I think Final Mission was Wes's best episode in that it allowed the relationship between him and Picard reach a conclusion and come full circle. First Duty is great though.
 
Safe to say, if we're on about Wesley's best episode, we can pretty much discount Justice (Sentenced to death for trampling on some plants? WTF?), The Dauphin (Pass me the sick bucket!), and Journey's End (Featuring 'Fat Bastard/Bad Attitude Wesley'!). :lol:
 
I like "The Dauphin"...it's not great, but I consider it the first good Wesley episode. The bits when he's getting romantic advice from Worf and Riker are priceless.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top