*scratches head*
You can get an infraction for not liking a Doctor Who episode? Whaaaa....
6x05 The Rebel Flesh (Grading/Discussion) (SPOILERS!!)
- Thread starter Neroon
- Start date
You can get an infraction for not liking a Doctor Who episode? Whaaaa....
That was... OK. Wasn't crazy about it but it wasn't awful either. Predictable and a bit bland. I hope part 2 picks up.
Not so long as you keep it to yourself.
I'll say no more on the issue
Of course, it's question obvious, but how did the Flesh copy clothes? I know it's fully-programable matter, but all the Doctor did was touch it with his hand.
I'm almost certain there's a section on TV Tropes for this exact thing. When clones are involved, it nearly always happens.
Same problem with Jenny in The Doctor's Daughter emerging fully-clothed, too. It's almost like they don't want all these naked actors running around.
The same way Odo does.
Because it was before the water shedNot so long as you keep it to yourself.
I'll say no more on the issue
Of course, it's question obvious, but how did the Flesh copy clothes? I know it's fully-programable matter, but all the Doctor did was touch it with his hand.
or it uses the persons memory to make clothes
Very average for me.
The same way Odo made clothes, I guess.
It is a stretch, and something you just have to chock up to the show not being able to portray naked bodies, even if all the naughty, shameful, sinful bits are covered up.
A throwaway line saying it can replicate a jacket or jumper would have been nice, but we can just assume our way past this minor but still nagging detail.
It is a stretch, and something you just have to chock up to the show not being able to portray naked bodies, even if all the naughty, shameful, sinful bits are covered up.
A throwaway line saying it can replicate a jacket or jumper would have been nice, but we can just assume our way past this minor but still nagging detail.
that seems to be a very easy way out of it, I guess its possible, but it would be very easy.
Moving on to the episode itself, Amy feels a bit like a spare part, with Rory getting some really good screentime for a change.
All that said considering some of the known names in the guest cast I was a little under whelmed by the whole episode, this series feels like Moffatt has paid alot of attention to the Arc, but not enough to the invidual episodes.
Very apt. This, right here, is exactly how I feel.
Mmm, I guess that works.
Speaking of which, the Doctor Ganger did look quite like Odo.
i thought that was very good.
although, yet again, i had trouble hearing the dialogue due to the overloud sound FX.
although, yet again, i had trouble hearing the dialogue due to the overloud sound FX.
There was actually a line when the cloning was explained that said "even clothes" so even though prob never be explained how at least it was acknowledged.
I thought it was interesting that Amy seems to have experienced a little of the insecurity that Rory has had in the past.
I'm glad it's not just me who thought that!
I was pretty sure there was a throwaway line about the flesh duplicating clothes, in the beginning when they first examined it.
I felt this did have a 'trad Who' feel - even to the point of being a bit slow and predictable in places. If this is the get-out for the killing in ep one, I shall be seriously disappointed.
I felt this did have a 'trad Who' feel - even to the point of being a bit slow and predictable in places. If this is the get-out for the killing in ep one, I shall be seriously disappointed.
The whole 'war' thing doesn't make any sense...
The Gangers are effectively the ultimate in identity theft - I can imagine some people reacting very negatively to them, causing an equally hostile reaction.
Similar threads
- Poll
