• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

First-Timer's Impressions of Deep Space Nine

Status
Not open for further replies.
Arguably: Shakespeare was the potboiler author of his day; churning out hackwork to run a two horse household. Would he be on the pedestal he occupies to day if his counterpart, Kit Marlowe, hadn't taken a severe case of steel poisoning . . . doubtful.
OMG! Ben Johnson is alive and well! :eek:
 
Flemm, if you want to nitpick, I'll suggest that the idea of the Founders abandoning their home planet just to destroy 25 or so spaceships seems a bit far-fetched to me. ;)

That said, I'm sure that, subjected to close scrutiny, a lot of DS9, and indeed many other shows, doesn't entirely make sense!
 
Flemm, if you want to nitpick, I'll suggest that the idea of the Founders abandoning their home planet just to destroy 25 or so spaceships seems a bit far-fetched to me. ;)

I don't know, a change of scenery on occasion can do a body good. Even a huge composite puddle of bodies ;)

Interestingly, I believe this corresponded with the producers' desire to revamp the appearance of the Founders' homeworld, which they found to be too pedestrian in The Search, not alien enough.

Thus the planet-wide link of later seasons was born.

That said, I'm sure that, subjected to close scrutiny, a lot of DS9, and indeed many other shows, doesn't entirely make sense!

Yeah. Nitpickability has little to do with quality, in fact that is how I would distinguish a nitpick from a substantial criticism :)
 
Last edited:
Interestingly, I believe this corresponded with the producers' desire to revamp the appearance of the Founders' homeworld, which they found to be too pedestrian in The Search, not alien enough.

Thus the planet-wide link of later seasons was born.

I believe that was their original idea, they just did not have the time or budget to do it that way in The Search.
 
But would an Irishman really sing Jerusalem? Maybe TheGodBen can tell us?
I've never heard it sung, but I am 24 and therefore not in the demographic that goes to those sorts of parties. Whenever a family gathering has broken out in song it tends to be songs like Whiskey in the Jar, Gershwin's Summertime, or Living Next Door to Alice, they never go for the choral stuff.

*tries to erase the memory of the drunk priest singing "Alice? Who the f@#% is Alice?!" very loudly into his beer bottle"


That being said, Jerusalem was chosen by Colm Meaney himself after they couldn't get the rights to Space Oddity or Rocket Man, and since Colm Meaney has been Irish longer than me I'm going to defer to his judgement in this area.

Irish, from Kilarney and the fringes of the Gaeltacht . . . you're lucky he talks English; but his backstory puts him through the Aldebaran Music Academy so you've got a justification there.
I think O'Brien mentioned Dublin being his home once, and since Meaney is from Dublin that makes sense, so it's very unlikely that he would have spoken Irish as a first language. Not that such things matter in the age of the universal translator (which also magically translates text into your native language).

BTW does the Gaeltacht survive into the Trek centuries? If it didn't the Republic wouldn't be the Republic.
Indeed not, because we have two constitutions and the Irish language version takes precedence, so if nobody spoke Irish we'd be screwed. But at least we'd get rid of that stupid blasphemy law.

Anyway, it's Star Trek, there is no Republic of Ireland because by then we'll all be living in a happy United Earth that's ruled over by the French. :)
 
That being said, Jerusalem was chosen by Colm Meaney himself after they couldn't get the rights to Space Oddity or Rocket Man, and since Colm Meaney has been Irish longer than me I'm going to defer to his judgement in this area.

Although I love the scene as it is, how awesome would it have been to see them drunkenly singing Rocket Man together? :)
 
Wouldn't they need doob for that?
By the way, folks, I introduced a baseball fan to "Take Me Out to the Holosuite" today. He loved it! "What were you doing? Regenerating?!" That episode is one of my comedic favorites!
And Chase, did everyone actually play the game?
 
No, he got banned.
AFAIK, Jimmy Bob got banned, but his resurrected self Billy Stein is alive and well and in an Internet rural zone where he has to hike to a local wifi, and has posted just one review since his rebirth...
 
No, he got banned.

A ban I'd be quite keen to see lifted seeing as his reviews are the primary reason I visit as regularly as I do.

I agree.

Free JimmyBob!

Join the movement ;)

Guys, 'freeing' JimmyBob is not a topic for this forum.

The warning I gave him last week bumped him into a temporary ban only - it was Bonz's decision to make that a permanent state and it is her decision to unban him, should that be something she elects to do.

Therefore, if you have any issues with this, please talk to Bonz about it. Because there is nothing that can be done about it by anyone else - and most certainly not me.

Thanks.
 
Well, I'd like to see the thread continued under one alias or another, so I guess if "Bonz" is the proper channel, then so be it.
 
Mods work in mysterious ways. :vulcan: I have absolutely no idea why Jimmy Bob should be permanently banned. If T'Bonz or anyone would be so kind to explain...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top