• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

V: the series

I only had two real problems with the series:

- The cool echoing effect was gone from the Visitors' voices.

Which was a symptom of the lower budget of the series as opposed to the miniseries. Though it also created the story opportunity for having Visitors pass for human on occasion.


- Martin/Philip. Unless the look of a Visitor's human disguise is somehow 'tied' to his/her actual reptilian appearance (which is not a bad idea, really), there is no way that anyone could immediately recognize Philip as Martin's twin brother. Any Visitor could be the one under that mask.

Ahh, but only a twin would have the same voice, right?
 
- Martin/Philip. Unless the look of a Visitor's human disguise is somehow 'tied' to his/her actual reptilian appearance (which is not a bad idea, really), there is no way that anyone could immediately recognize Philip as Martin's twin brother. Any Visitor could be the one under that mask.

Ahh, but only a twin would have the same voice, right?

AFAIK, Diana immediately recognizes Philip before he even says a word.

And the (few) sets of twins I have seen, have had much the same voices. Anyone remember the Sklar brothers (comedy) or the Laurances (acting)?
 
After buying and watching the original mini a while back, what upset me most about the The Final Battle and the series was the fact that one of the Visitor resistance members in the original mini mentioned a force that was against Diana and the Visitors and that at the end of the mini, the blonde scientist had some SETI type array set up to try to find that foe in the deep reaches of space and once TFB aired, there was no mention of that foe at all. I guess if the new series used that, fans would be making comparisons to SG1's Tok'ra. But it still would have been nice to know who that foe was and if they would have helped against the visitors.
 
It's true that the Final Battle and weekly series essentially ignored this point in favor of more action-driven fare. Plus, I suspect the cost of integrating a decidedly alien-looking race into the show would have been prohibitive. If you're wondering where V creator Kenneth Johnson was heading with the idea, there's always the book: V: The Second Generation, in which he introduces the Zedti -- a human-looking-but-insectoid race who are mortal enemies with the Vs. Be warned, though -- the book isn't very good and its essential plot is almost entirely a mirror of The Final Battle.
 
It won't be any good unless it has the line: "Don't you wave your fookin tentacles at me!"
 
A District 9 reference, perhaps?

Indeed.

In fact, I have a hypothesis about what their real purpose is, but this isn't the place to discuss it.

Oh, c'mon, you can't just drop something like that and then not follow up on it. :lol:

Given the reference to the Vs/whatever they really call themselves in the new series all being hooked on some drug, my mind went straight away to a "Children of Earth"-type scenario.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top