• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar 2 - Electric Boogaloo-Fanboys gone WILD-too many hyphens

Do you enjoy pie?

  • Yes, sweet, please

    Votes: 85 41.3%
  • Yes, savory, please

    Votes: 43 20.9%
  • Yes, any kind

    Votes: 85 41.3%
  • No, I'm a heathen

    Votes: 38 18.4%

  • Total voters
    206
and now Alec has sent out an email to his mailing list asking people to contact the attorneys for CBS.

And this time I had as Alec asked and told them they were doing a great job and need to keep at it. Always glad to help Alec.

The video that goes with this post....

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
The video that goes with this post....

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
There was an email today as well to his whole axanar mailing list which hilariously still includes terry mcintosh
 
Gotta love how he points out that Prelude to Axanar has a better IMDb score than any Trek movie including Wrath of Khan and expects people to take that as a reliable metric.

Peters says (in the above video):
Why are the petty little lawyers at CBS [...] so insistent on cancelling Axanar? Well, quite simply, in their own words, Axanar is too good. They know that Axanar is more popular than the Star Trek we have been subjected to the last 10 years. In fact, Prelude to Axanar has a higher score on IMDb than any Star Trek movie. [...] Let's face it, Axanar embarrasses them. We made The Gathering Storm and the sequel that will be released later this year, Crucible, on a fraction of what they spend producing what their own people at Paramount think is mediocre. And so CBS is trying to kill Axanar by not letting you, the loyal Star Trek fans who CBS continually treat like crap from seeing better Star Trek than they produce. [...] These two [lawyers] need to understand that Star Trek fans want Axanar, not more mediocre Kurtzman Trek.
He neglects to point out that while Prelude to Axanar is well-rated on IMDb, The Gathering Storm currently boasts a 6.4 out of 24 votes, which only beats out The Final Frontier and Section 31 (and ties The Motion Picture, Insurrection, and Nemesis).
  • Star Trek: The Motion Picture: 6.4
  • Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan: 7.7
  • Star Trek III: The Search for Spock: 6.7
  • Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home: 7.3
  • Star Trek V: The Final Frontier: 5.5
  • Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country: 7.3
  • Star Trek Generations: 6.6
  • Star Trek: First Contact: 7.6
  • Star Trek: Insurrection: 6.4
  • Star Trek Nemesis: 6.4
  • Star Trek (2009): 7.9
  • Star Trek Into Darkness: 7.7
  • Star Trek Beyond: 7.0
  • Star Trek: Section 31: 3.8
It also ranks worse than any of the Kurtzman shows other than Starfleet Academy.
  • Discovery: 6.9
  • Short Treks: 7.1
  • Picard: 6.5
  • Lower Decks: 7.8
  • Prodigy: 7.6
  • Strange New Worlds: 8.2 (edited to add, as I'd skipped this somehow)
  • Khan: 7.0
  • Starfleet Academy: 4.6
I didn't include them above, but The Gathering Storm beat out the promotional very Short Treks and the non-Kurtzman Scouts, so I guess they can declare victory there.
  • very Short Treks:5.5
  • Scouts: 5.4
Here's the IMDb page for The Gathering Storm if anyone wants to give it whatever vote you think it deserves; 24 certainly isn't much of a sample size.

 
Last edited:
I know from looking over Alec's Facebook page that he has no love for Trump, but dear God the parallels...
Axanar's fans have a lot in common with a certain red-hatted cult of rage-aholics. Demographically they're very similar: older white boomers and younger white incels who love weapons and the trappings of the military but wouldn't last two seconds in the actual armed forces. They're passionately devoted to a specific thing to the point that they claim ownership of it. Furthermore, they're mad because more recent custodians of the thing have welcomed more women and brown people into it than it ever had before, and this makes them feel that the thing is being "stolen" from them and "ruined".

They firmly believe that if the founder of their object of devotion were still alive, he would agree with them 100%, and it's incumbent upon them to "take back" this thing and make it "great again", i.e. turn the clock back to a simpler time that never actually existed.

At the same time, Axanar has given these folks a sense of community they never had before because the personality traits mentioned above make them off-putting to most people. Any "attack" on Axanar, whether it's mild criticism or legal intervention from the folks who own the Star Trek IP, is interpreted as a threat to that community and sense of belonging. And as a result they're ride-or-die for Alec Peters. The next "installments" of Axanar could be nothing more than Alec dropping his pants, shoving his bare butt into he camera, and performing all the characters by doing Jim Carrey's "Mr. Butt" routine, and they would hail it as the greatest series of moving images in all history.

Very fortunately for all of us, none of their nonsense has the power to affect our everyday life.
 
He neglects to point out that while Prelude to Axanar is well-rated on IMDb, The Gathering Storm currently boasts a 6.4 out of 24 votes, which only beats out The Final Frontier and Section 31 (and ties The Motion Picture, Insurrection, and Nemesis).
  • Star Trek: The Motion Picture: 6.4 [...]
  • Star Trek III: The Search for Spock: 6.7 [...]
  • Star Trek Generations: 6.6 [...]
  • Star Trek: Insurrection: 6.4
  • Star Trek Nemesis: 6.4 [....]
It also ranks worse than any of the Kurtzman shows other than Starfleet Academy.
  • Picard: 6.5
Well, it's up to 6.7 out of 28, so The Gathering Storm has now passed Picard, the three movies it was tied with, and Generations. It's also tied with The Search for Spock.
 
I left the Axanar bandwagon shortly after the lawsuit because of Alec's actions toward people asking for their money back. I haven't watched Prelude in 8 years, and my blu-ray of it is in a dark place in my closet.

Axanar is not any better than Paramount/CBS produced Star Trek. There was potential, but because of Alec doing what he did after the Indiegogo for the Axanar feature and not using the money the way he was supposed to. I had a feeling something was going on when he sent a financial report out to donors, and I saw salaries, cell phones, and auto expenses being listed. That to me was a big red flag.

The Gathering Storm, I watched it before it was taken out, and I didn't think it was bad, but I didn't think it was good either. I think it needed another screenwriter to polish the script, and another actor playing Garth.

I wish J.J. Abrams had never said anything to put an end to the lawsuit. Twelve years later, and Axanar isn't over because of it. Paramount/CBS/Skydance has every right to keep doing what they're doing as long as he's not fulfilling the terms of the settlement which Alec should be doing.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top