• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

Everything I've read, it's generally against the regs to Fraternize between Officers & Enlisted service members.

Here's an example.

There are no Starfleet regulations that prohibit fraternization between the ranks.

And to also further the insane notion that officers/enlisted is a caste based thing...

People in a caste system are in that caste by no choice of their own. By birth, society, whatever the reason, people in castes never really chose to be in their caste.

Everyone in Starfleet... everyone... is there BY CHOICE. Tbis is for both officers AND enlisted personnel. That alone completely negates the idea that Starfleet has a caste based system, never mind all other evidence that also shows Starfleet is not caste based.
 
Is Spock a Vulcan, a Human, or a brand new species?
actually an interesting question. there was one of the novels that had it pretty much be the third. because the author approached it from the angle that any hybrid of alien and human would require a LOT of intervention, no matter how close they are, so a great deal of his DNA is from niether and actually completely artificial

but then of course in trek as a whole, it's pretty soft on this and it just kind of happens, with maybe some difference in length of gestation...
 
There are no Starfleet regulations that prohibit fraternization between the ranks.
That's generally a good thing IMO.

And to also further the insane notion that officers/enlisted is a caste based thing...

People in a caste system are in that caste by no choice of their own. By birth, society, whatever the reason, people in castes never really chose to be in their caste.
Yes I know.

Everyone in Starfleet... everyone... is there BY CHOICE. This is for both officers AND enlisted personnel. That alone completely negates the idea that Starfleet has a caste based system, never mind all other evidence that also shows Starfleet is not caste based.
The fact that they adopt the old British Western Military system of Officer/Enlisted is a form of "Caste Divide" IMO.
Even if you volunteer to serve in it, it exists, it has existed for a VERY LONG time.
It's a unnecessary divide that could stand to be torn down.

Most of the Galaxy class interior is unused, per the TNG Technical Manual.
Given how LARGE the Galaxy-class is and how few crew members there are, it's WAY too much un-used empty space.

That could be filled with more personnel & staff.

People are not going to take you seriously when you dismiss basic stuff because it doesn’t conform with your worldview.
We've went on this argument for several pages these past 2 days.

If he really cares, he can go back and read them himself.
 
Given how LARGE the Galaxy-class is and how few crew members there are, it's WAY too much un-used empty space.

That could be filled with more personnel & staff.

Probably the first wave was proof-of-concept, with later waves becoming much more mobile starbases. Then the Borg and Dominion came, and those plans had to be put on hold.
 
That's generally a good thing IMO.


Yes I know.


The fact that they adopt the old British Western Military system of Officer/Enlisted is a form of "Caste Divide" IMO.
Even if you volunteer to serve in it, it exists, it has existed for a VERY LONG time.
It's a unnecessary divide that could stand to be torn down.


Given how LARGE the Galaxy-class is and how few crew members there are, it's WAY too much un-used empty space.

That could be filled with more personnel & staff.


We've went on this argument for several pages these past 2 days.

If he really cares, he can go back and read them himself.
Whatever, dude.

Agree to disagree, because I just can't take this idea seriously at all.
 
it might be a particularly scary nebula. It might have saw you looking at it and said, "listen here, punk, you tell ONE other scientist you discovered me, and its curtains! Curtains I tells ya!"
and then you have to sit along in your space diner trying to get the courage to do it anyway.
to be fair, i am pretty sure the D has run into a least one nebula that tried to sink her.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top