Not unless RTD acknowledged it in the story, which he didn't.
Spoilers The Star Beast grade and discussion thread
- Thread starter The Nth Doctor
- Start date
Not unless RTD acknowledged it in the story, which he didn't.
By that logic, the Doctor has experienced Shada, the episode Dalek and Human Nature twice.
Which, granted, the audio drama adaptation of Shada does make a meta joke about.
Question for the Lower Decks fans-- The Meep vs Moopsie. Who wins?
Well the Meep has a gun.
I'd been pretty excited for this episode, and it didn't disappoint.
David Tennant jumped right back into the role perfectly, he didn't miss a step.
I have to admit, I kind of found Donna annoying during some of her original time on the show, but I liked her here.
The twist with The Meep was pretty fun, I had no idea until I came on to this thread just now that The Meep was a preexisting character, so I was not expecting that.
This really felt like RTD at his best, and it really has me optimistic for how his new run on the series is gonna go.
David Tennant jumped right back into the role perfectly, he didn't miss a step.
I have to admit, I kind of found Donna annoying during some of her original time on the show, but I liked her here.
The twist with The Meep was pretty fun, I had no idea until I came on to this thread just now that The Meep was a preexisting character, so I was not expecting that.
This really felt like RTD at his best, and it really has me optimistic for how his new run on the series is gonna go.
Drama? Comedy?
You've just described the ultimate showdown between two titans. I don't know who would win, but the fight between the two is certainly something very frightening to contemplate.
Really?
Obviously. She just has certain opinions on some aspects. She doesn’t hate them. It’s not like she’s anti trans or anything.
Really?
What aspects?
Is Rose still Trans?
Why would she stop?
Her penis is gone.
Nostalgia and FUN get an A+.
Tennant and Tate have such an awesome chemistry together.
The plot twist involving the Meep was pretty apparent. Its a trope that has been used before and you could see the bleeding obvious from space. However i can forgive it because everything about the episode was FUN and I don't think RTD was thinking of anything deep with it either.
It was good to see old faces and the new UNIT person automatically being aware of who the Doctor was nice, because at this point I can only say his face should be drilled into every person with a high enough level of clearance. Would it of been nice to have seen Kate or Osgood instead? Yes, but the new lady wasn't bad at all either.
But I just love the fact that the Chibnal era already feels like a rapidly fading nightmare, the Cousin Oliver of Doctors and ready to be assigned to the dustbins of history along with the Salamanders/warp 10 plot in Star Trek, Roseanne winning the lottery, Nikki & Paolo in LOST or BSG 1980.
Loved how they handled Rose's storyline and love the fact they choose Rose as their new name. I wish we could keep the Noble-Temple family for more then these three specials!
And I love LOVE the fact they acknowledged Wilf and not killing him of either. Letting him go living in our memories like Sarah Jane was sweet.
Tennant and Tate have such an awesome chemistry together.
The plot twist involving the Meep was pretty apparent. Its a trope that has been used before and you could see the bleeding obvious from space. However i can forgive it because everything about the episode was FUN and I don't think RTD was thinking of anything deep with it either.
It was good to see old faces and the new UNIT person automatically being aware of who the Doctor was nice, because at this point I can only say his face should be drilled into every person with a high enough level of clearance. Would it of been nice to have seen Kate or Osgood instead? Yes, but the new lady wasn't bad at all either.
But I just love the fact that the Chibnal era already feels like a rapidly fading nightmare, the Cousin Oliver of Doctors and ready to be assigned to the dustbins of history along with the Salamanders/warp 10 plot in Star Trek, Roseanne winning the lottery, Nikki & Paolo in LOST or BSG 1980.
Loved how they handled Rose's storyline and love the fact they choose Rose as their new name. I wish we could keep the Noble-Temple family for more then these three specials!
And I love LOVE the fact they acknowledged Wilf and not killing him of either. Letting him go living in our memories like Sarah Jane was sweet.
Last edited:
