Rogue One was actually decent. Liked it a lot better than Solo.
Simon Pegg Calls Out 'Star Wars' For Having Most 'Toxic' Fandom—While Praising 'Star Trek' Fans
- Thread starter Skipper
- Start date
For me Rogue one is the best Disney Star Wars movie
Ok, controversial opinion time (and it's sad that I have to couch it that way): I like all of the Star Wars Disney output to one degree or another, including Rogue 1 and Solo. The absolute weakest for me was Book of Boba Fett, but it still had a lot of good in it. I am MUCH more likely to watch something from the Sequel trilogy than anything in the Prequel Trilogy. YMMV.
YMMV indeed. Honestly, I almost bailed on Boba until I found out that Mando and The Baby were going to show up. They appeared, Boba basically disappeared, and the show was better (for me) because of it.
Last edited:
Resistance was the weakest link. That’s why nobody talks about it. 
Resistance really doesn't seem like a show anyone really put much effort into. It's like the Suits wanted something that could fill the gap between the end of Rebels and the launch of Disney+ and Resistance was the solution to that request.
I liked "Rogue One" slightly more than "Solo".
Those two episodes about Din Djarin and Grogu were the worst aspects of "Book of Boba Fett" for me. Not only did I loathe them, but I also found those two episodes incredibly boring.
They were the show's only saving grace for me. Otherwise the whole season was boredom. The Book basically solidified Boba's position as a firmly mediocre character who, up to that point had done nothing but follow Han to Bespin and ship the Han-cicle to Jabba before falling into a Venus Flytrap. I don't know where this notion of Boba as a badass ever came from because it's never been on screen.
The only real question has ever been how he got out of the pit, but he doesn't even MacGyver his way out. It's nothing particularly clever. Then he gets into town and it's basically him sounding like a bored middle management who, when push comes to shove, really isn't all that badass because other people do most of his fighting for him. He's not particularly fierce and his greatest gift seems to be the middle management talent of being able to spot and hire good people.
I have no doubt there's gonna be a S2 because Disney has to make that $4B back, but, lesson learned for me.
Books. One of the "Tales of..." anthologies had Fett take out an entire Imperial base single handedly to get a target.
It's funny to see the positive reaction to Din because Boba started out the same way. A cipher who looked cool and occasionally did cool things. His notoriety became established in novels as this cool killer bounty hunter and people built up the image in their minds of super badass. I know a lot of people who just like the way Fett looked, talked, that extremely cool exterior with a certain presence.
Why I like BoBF is because it made him more than a cipher. He became a person with a difficult history, a damaged sense of purpose and finding new purpose. The show may not be for everyone but I love it, and actually like Fett now. I used to hate him.
Definitely the low point for me of the series. Especially the first episode which ground the story to a halt to catch up with Din...ugh. I don't loath them, but I find them quite misplaced.
Yes. And that's great, but also sad.
Sad for who...?
Many of the SW fans I know have a greater affinity for the books over some of the films or series.
Sad for people who primarily or exclusively get their Star Wars from what's on screen and don't invest overmuch in the books.
Maybe, maybe not. I enjoy the books but had no investment in Fett as a character. I quite actively disliked him in books, ignored his stories in comics, and didn't play as him in video games, like Battlefront. Yet, BoBF is one of my favorite series, and touch me quite deeply.
So, who is it sad for again...? Because on screen Fett is far more what I want from a character than book Fett.
That's the difference, I guess. I would have liked a guy who was a little more book version and to see him become something else, but, as it is, I feel like he started out as nothing and pretty much stayed nothing to the end of the season.
If I want a badass cipher suit of armor I'll watch Mandalorian or play a Fett video game. Fett in the films has little to draw me to him. Fett as a character showed more growth and interest to me in this series.
Mileage will vary, and obviously does.
I liked the Sarlacc/Tusken flashbacks significantly more than the 'present day' Boba material.
Last edited:
It did add some depth to him and in a way I wasn't expecting.