I finished the series yesterday and I have to say it had some fun stories and characters but it *really* lacked consistency imo.
Some characters felt pitch perfect (like Death, Rose, Jed, Gault, Lucienne, Fiddlers Green) others just were not convincing at all (Lucifer, several of the serial killers, the pumpkin guy, Despair and, sad to say, Dream himself). A few more (like Corinthian and Desire) seemed to pull off what they were going for pretty well but what they were going for just felt incredibly generic and not very interesting. This is not just about actors, either. I think I would definitely have preferred a different actor for Dream and maybe a few others but a lot of them, especially Lucifer, were just let down by the writing and visuals. (In particular, the show's costuming was fantastic for all the modern dress characters and totally lame in regards to pretty much all the more fantasy/historical dress characters.)
Tonally it was super weird to have the show spend ninety percent of its time following a standard pg-13 style of violence where we're constantly pulling back or cutting away before you see too much but then in 24/7 suddenly there's a muli-minute long lovingly shot self-torture and mutilation montage. (My wife refused to watch anything else after that.) And then again in The Collectors, though thankfully not nearly as much screentime then.
Story wise it was an interesting experiment in a different form of serialized/episodic hybrid but the pacing really felt poor overall. There's a massive prologue followed by the opening story which spends more time setting up Constatine and Lucifer than it does setting up the actual villain of this story. He basically springs up fully formed in episode 3 and is never really fully explained in terms of what his theories and actions are really supposed to accomplish. And he is then *very* perfunctorily defeated literally minutes after his first confrontation with the hero in episode 5.
Then comes an episode long intermission, which was honestly probably the best single episode but feels really awkward as a transition from one four episode arc to the next, followed immediately by the second story. That one is much better written and paced but is also constantly interrupted with vague scenes about Desire's evil plan. A plan that ultimately doesn't even figure into the season except as a completely unexplained near miss. And its weighed down by a whole sub-plot about Dream suddenly being a dictator which just doesn't feel entirely in line with the way the previous episodes were written. Plus there's a tacked on coda where Lucifer declares war on Dream because... well, honestly, the show gives absolutely no logical reason why this got tacked onto the end of the season beyond the obvious. Ie, that if it had happened at the more logical point in the story (at the end of A Hope in Hell) it would've derailed the rest of the season. So they just held Lucifer in a bubble from episode 4 to episode 10 so they could use her as a season end cliffhanger instead.
And on top of that, the fact that 8 out of the 10 episodes were full on serialized arcs made it feel really weird how often they introduced a seemingly major character only for them to have no real role in the arc (Constantine, Hobb, Lucifer and her, uh, queen, I guess, Despair, all that talk about the other missing Endless sibling, etc).
I'm generally a fan of Gaiman's writing, though not always as much as others seem to be, and maybe I'd feel differently about some of this if I had read the comics already and knew where the ideas were heading. But as a general fan of genre tv, this was a little bit disappointing for me overall.
Some characters felt pitch perfect (like Death, Rose, Jed, Gault, Lucienne, Fiddlers Green) others just were not convincing at all (Lucifer, several of the serial killers, the pumpkin guy, Despair and, sad to say, Dream himself). A few more (like Corinthian and Desire) seemed to pull off what they were going for pretty well but what they were going for just felt incredibly generic and not very interesting. This is not just about actors, either. I think I would definitely have preferred a different actor for Dream and maybe a few others but a lot of them, especially Lucifer, were just let down by the writing and visuals. (In particular, the show's costuming was fantastic for all the modern dress characters and totally lame in regards to pretty much all the more fantasy/historical dress characters.)
Tonally it was super weird to have the show spend ninety percent of its time following a standard pg-13 style of violence where we're constantly pulling back or cutting away before you see too much but then in 24/7 suddenly there's a muli-minute long lovingly shot self-torture and mutilation montage. (My wife refused to watch anything else after that.) And then again in The Collectors, though thankfully not nearly as much screentime then.
Story wise it was an interesting experiment in a different form of serialized/episodic hybrid but the pacing really felt poor overall. There's a massive prologue followed by the opening story which spends more time setting up Constatine and Lucifer than it does setting up the actual villain of this story. He basically springs up fully formed in episode 3 and is never really fully explained in terms of what his theories and actions are really supposed to accomplish. And he is then *very* perfunctorily defeated literally minutes after his first confrontation with the hero in episode 5.
Then comes an episode long intermission, which was honestly probably the best single episode but feels really awkward as a transition from one four episode arc to the next, followed immediately by the second story. That one is much better written and paced but is also constantly interrupted with vague scenes about Desire's evil plan. A plan that ultimately doesn't even figure into the season except as a completely unexplained near miss. And its weighed down by a whole sub-plot about Dream suddenly being a dictator which just doesn't feel entirely in line with the way the previous episodes were written. Plus there's a tacked on coda where Lucifer declares war on Dream because... well, honestly, the show gives absolutely no logical reason why this got tacked onto the end of the season beyond the obvious. Ie, that if it had happened at the more logical point in the story (at the end of A Hope in Hell) it would've derailed the rest of the season. So they just held Lucifer in a bubble from episode 4 to episode 10 so they could use her as a season end cliffhanger instead.
And on top of that, the fact that 8 out of the 10 episodes were full on serialized arcs made it feel really weird how often they introduced a seemingly major character only for them to have no real role in the arc (Constantine, Hobb, Lucifer and her, uh, queen, I guess, Despair, all that talk about the other missing Endless sibling, etc).
I'm generally a fan of Gaiman's writing, though not always as much as others seem to be, and maybe I'd feel differently about some of this if I had read the comics already and knew where the ideas were heading. But as a general fan of genre tv, this was a little bit disappointing for me overall.
Last edited: