• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 2x01 - "The Star Gazer"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    281
True, but I also thought they have just played her as if she were decisively younger. There's all that banter in season one about him being old, she's often cast in the caregiver role in relation to him, helping him out with stuff he's a little too old to be on top of himself, that whole thing.

That's funny. The way they talk is very similar to how my 80 plus year old parents talk to each other, and there is a 2 years difference between them.
 
So, what's the reason to write out Jamie McShane's character of Zhaban?

Is it to create this love-interest sub-plot between Picard & Laris?

I suspect it's because the actor is committed to CSI:LVegas and Wednesday (the Tim Burton Addams Family series) rather than for any plot reason.

He didn't have a huge role in Season 1, and I'm betting he would have been similarly underused if he'd stayed on. I'm going to bet we only see Laris in the first and last episodes.
 
Let me just say the casting of the younger, early 24th century and circa 2315 version of Picard's mother was inspired. Her wide smile and face remind me so much of the vision we saw of an elderly and deceased Yvette Picard in "Where No One Has Gone Before(TNG)."
 
I didn't get an insectoid vibe. Speaking of the Queen, is it just me or does the intro sequence's rendition of the Queen hew closer to the classic design and not what we've seen of Annie Wersching?
 
I didn't get an insectoid vibe. Speaking of the Queen, is it just me or does the intro sequence's rendition of the Queen hew closer to the classic design and not what we've seen of Annie Wersching?
Annie Wersching is probably the new evil universe's Borg Queen, and thus wouldn't be the same as the Queens we've seen in First Contact/Voyager.
 
on normal circumstances and initially I would agree, however they are facing the borg, a terrible, duplicitous for they have likely been fearing since childhood. They aren’t acting normally here, they are scared.
It's a bit amusing that people keep calling the Borg duplicitous.

Because they aren't.

As odd as it may seem, the Borg have always been trustworthy in any deal's they made or agreements they reached. It's only ever been when the other side turn's on them that they that they respond in kind.
 
It's a bit amusing that people keep calling the Borg duplicitous.

Because they aren't.

As odd as it may seem, the Borg have always been trustworthy in any deal's they made or agreements they reached. It's only ever been when the other side turn's on them that they that they respond in kind.
That isn't really true. They're "trustworthy" in the event that it's still advantageous for them not to engage in their default modality, which is aggression. The "compromises" the Queen offered Janeway in "Unimatrix Zero" were demands founded upon threats, and the Queen took the first opportunity to assimilate future Janeway rather than continue to negotiate in "Endgame." The Borg have a very predictable pattern of belligerence.
 
Last edited:
Didn't the Borg turn on the Voyager crew in Scorpion?
This was a great start to the season.
It was a little surprising how much everybody had spread out, but it was especially cool seeing Rios as captain of the Stargazer, and Seven & the hologram were funny.
The stuff with the Borg was interesting, the new ship and design for the queen were pretty cool.
I couldn't quite make out some of Picard's conversation with Raffi on earth, did she say that he's the Chancellor of the Academy or just that he was working for them?
The way they handled Whoopi Goldburg and John de Lancie aging when their characters shouldn't was pretty good. The de-aged Q actually didn't look to bad.
Not quite sure what to make of the Laris/Picard realtionship. It was unexpected, it worked OK here, but I can't remember what their relationship was like last season to know if it fits what we saw of them before.
 
Yes they did.

Seven (before she was severed from the collective) tried to assimilate Voyager.
Correct. Now it does appear if the status qua hadn't changed they might have stayed true to it (but we won't ever know), but after a massive loss in the latest encounter with Species 8472, the Collective made it clear their need superseded any other issue.
 
I liked it. 8/10.
I was rather amused that they were careful to have in-world explanations for everyone looking older, including characters who technically shouldn't. I dunno that it was necessary, really? But I certainly noticed the opportunity to briefly use a Q deepfake didn't go to waste.

Yet another Borg storyline and yet another Anomaly In Space storyline, but there's clearly a different take going on with at least the first one. Be interesting to see how that ties in with Q's whole thing. Nice to see that Rios is captaining the Stargazer now (his presumably-smokeless stogeys made me laugh). Seven in command of Rios' old ship was cool, complete with the sarcastic holographic crewman. It was nice to see that everyone is happier after the end of Season 1, even if Picard is now ruminating on all the living he lost out on. Glad to see we're getting a season arc that's squarely about fascism in the 21st century, it's only fitting. The time travel plus anomalies stuff is very classic Bermaga-era stuff (and looks like it's being used in that specific way) but has some nostalgia value out of that, so I'm not mad at it. Interested to see where it goes.

I have not had strong feelings about PIC at any point -- DSC is more my jam these days -- but they've done fine work and mainly I'm glad to keep having it so long as Sir Patrick is still with us, however long that is. Looking forward to more.
 
Not quite sure what to make of the Laris/Picard realtionship. It was unexpected, it worked OK here, but I can't remember what their relationship was like last season to know if it fits what we saw of them before.
Well, over a year had passed since then, and I got the impression their "relationship progression" was more from her perspective e.g. she wanted something deeper. Also, it was late at night, a fire, etc.

Oh, and "Earl Tea. Cold." was a great metaphor for the status of their relationship, and he left without saying goodbye.
 
I've seen complaints of Picard going blank and outright admitting he didn't know what to do during the Borg attack, and that it's out of character. I don't think it's out of character since Picard is old, he's lost the edge he once had, and just isn't that grizzled military heavy hitter anymore.

What is out of character is, knowing all that, Picard apparently re-entered Starfleet anyway and Starfleet accepted him and put him back into that position. He just shouldn't be out there anymore in a military setting like that. Even the Ambassador thing hinted at in TNG's finale would have been a better choice.

As chancellor of academy, giving commencement speeches, maybe to odd old man lecture, perfect man for the role.

the anomoly wanted Picard, so makes sense to send him

The problem seems to be they left Rios In charge of the fleet and he froze.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top