The Walking Dead
Season 11 - Episode 7 - "Promises Broken"
Daryl & The Reapers: Daryl spots one of the Reapers storing vegetables in a locked shed, and tries to warm up to him, but is distracted by the return of a patrol. Pope chews out the men for failing to find their enemies, and as Leah takes responsibility for recent issues, Pope bitterly sends her off to continue to search with Daryl. Daryl questions why Pope is looking for another potential camp when he's living in one with walls and food; Leah is short with answers, but lets Daryl know that Pope wont be satisfied until the enemies are dead.
They come across a panicking man saying he was hunting for food on behalf of his injured wife; while Daryl plays his part by threatening the man, Leah radios Pope for instructions on how to deal with the survivor, and in no surprise, he tells Leah to kill the man.
Following the man to a building, Leah and Daryl discover the man was being truthful: he has a son and a wife who is dying from a bite. Leah beings to cry as she tells the man to take his son and never return to the area. Saying their goodbyes, the father and son leave, but Leah cannot bring herself to kill the woman, leaving it Daryl to use his crossbow on her. Covering the woman's body, he turns to Leah, saying he needs to tell her something (SEE NOTES), just as Pope radios Leah to return. Leah will give credit for killing "everyone" to Daryl, to bolster his status among the Reapers.
Commonwealth: While Yumiko tries to learn all she can about the Commonwealth, Eugene, Ezekiel, Princess and Fake Stephanie are punished (for using the radio equipment) with clearing out empty buildings full of walkers. Along the way, Ezekiel's cough worsens, under the watchful eye of Mercer and his guards.
While working, a young man and woman decked out in pampered preppie clothes walk by with a picnic basket, complaining to Mercer about the odor of / having to see Eugene and Company.
Yumiko continues to bicker with her brother, incessantly reminding him of the joy he once experienced from being a surgeon (for himself, not an apparently controlling father), but he pleads with her to stop bringing up the past and accept that he's happy with his life. Further, he begs her to never mention his past profession to any Commonwealth resident. He makes a class distinction between himself and his sister, once he learns that she's due for a meeting with Pamela Milton. Before he can continue, soldiers grab Tomi and haul him off, with the man blurting out his innocence...
Later, Yumiko finds and grills Lance Hornsby about the whereabouts of her brother and her friends. Hornsby--ever the manipulator--promises he can help Yumiko's community and set her friends free, but now that she's overstepped his authority by scheduling a meeting with Milton, he suggests that one day, he may need some favors for her, now that she's one of the people in "high places."
A happy, medically treated Ezekiel returns with Hornsby, who asks Fake Stephanie to take Eugene to another area for walker clean-up, while he gives Ezekiel and Princess a new job...
Elsewhere, the preppie couple are too busy kissing to notice a group of walkers approaching; Eugene and Fake Stephanie go into action and kill the walkers, but preppie man is completely ungrateful and insulting; Eugene is having none of that BS, so he punches the preppie--just as Hornsby, Mercer and soldiers show up. The preppie is obviously someone occupying the seat of privilege, as he gets in Mercer's face demanding to know why he was not around to deal with the walkers. Preppie man whines about Eugene's punch, which sends Hornsby into a paranoid fit, Fake Stephanie into an apologetic one, as soldiers surround Eugene...
Yumiko waits for her meeting with Pamela Milton (speaking to Real Stephanie, who asks about her friends), but its cancelled once she learns her son was attacked. Yes, the preppie man is Milton's boy. Locked in a cell, Hornsby makes a one-way offer: Eugene will be released from prison if he reveals Alexandria's location. An anguished Eugene eventually asks Hornsby to wait...
Maggie, Gabriel, Negan and Elijah : Negan argues with Maggie about returning to Alexandria; although Maggie says they do not need him, Negan dismisses her comment (and its telling that Father Gabriel and Elijah did not support her opinion). Negan promises to continue heading toward their stolen compound which is now Reaper territory (for food and revenge) only if Maggie agrees the act will make them "even" & she will bring an end to her plan to kill him. Initially, Maggie rejects this idea, but realizes she needs Negan's help...but not before asking Negan if he really accepts a promise from her.
Maggie kills a walker--identified as a friend of Elijah's sister, which instantly depresses Elijah, then riggers feelings of revenge--aimed squarely at Pope. Father Gabriel performs a funeral ceremony (SEE NOTES) over the burial of this friend-turned-walker, then heads off to spy on the Reapers, with the order to kill any he finds on their own. Meanwhile, Negan teaches Maggie how to make a Whisperer mask from a group of captured walkers (SEE NOTES) for the purpose of leading a herd to the Reapers' compound...
Gabriel spies on the Reaper compound, and tracks Mancea--their "pastor"--to a graveyard. Mancea senses the presence of something and arms himself, while asking God for guidance before walking away. Gabriel listens to the man, but holds his position, not knowing if he has been noticed.
By now, Negan has taught Maggie how to wear a walker mask and blend in, then lead walkers; Elijah wonders if she will keep her promise to Negan, but all she can say is she will try. Later, Maggie and Negan have a heart-to-heart, where Maggie tries to lay all bad behavior on Negan, but he reminds her that the men Rick's group killed at the satellite station had friends and girlfriends who looked to him to explain why they were killed. Maggie argues that there were no families killed, but he points out that he knows who Gracie is (the daughter of one of the killed Saviors).
When she asks if could do it all over again, would he change anything, he says yes...meaning he would have killed all of Rick's group instead of two. Maggie demands to know why he's saying that to her, only for Negan to point out that he's being honest. Gabriel returns, but lies, saying he did not see anyone (SEE NOTES).
Hours later, Maggie's group--all wearing walker masks--cover the woods, and industrial areas, doing the memory of Alpha proud by building a massive walker herd for use against the Reaper compound. As the group is walking to the next destination, Elijah discovers his sister is a walker. Struggling not to break down and expose himself to the walkers is only possible as Maggie holds his hand, leading an ever-growing army of walkers..
NOTES:
Despite Father Gabriel telling a wounded Reaper that "God's not here anymore," he still believes, and apparently, Maggie does too, as she added her "amen" at the end of Gabriel's prayer.
The second Father Gabriel lied about not seeing any Reapers, I imagined he was sympathetic toward Mancea being a religious man. With all of the spoiler talk flying around in social media about who will be one of the big deaths of the season, I hate to admit that Gabriel might be on the chopping block, as I can see him trying to infiltrate the Reaper compound and appeal to Mancea, only to be betrayed and murdered by Pope.
I would really hate to see Gabriel killed off, but his actions in this episode--plus Rosita having dreams about Abraham trying to tell her something...all combined, it paints a bleak picture for Gabriel.
Negan held on to his walker mask for sentimental and practical reasons. As disgusting as the idea of wearing the skin of the dead is, one cannot argue with the practical side of his reasoning.
The teasers for this episode had Negan saying he would do things differently if he had it to do all over again, but I'm sure audiences were not expecting him to say he would have killed all of Rick's group. Rarely is a villain ever given so many faces and range of thought,and brutal, dark honesty (e.g., you will not find that in most modern day superhero movies and TV series), which undoubtedly tracks with the way real people think. Its yet another great character study of Negan and Maggie, but when one thinks of how angry she was that Negan revealed his alternate life plans, the title of this episode might apply to Maggie more than anyone would suspect.
What was Daryl going to say to Leah? Who knows, but there's no way he can trust her enough to tip her off about anything. For all he knows, her tears could have been an act...
GRADE: A+.