• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 1x02 - "Maps and Legends"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    303
So we'll change it to "someone dying". Not sure that is any better...

Again, it is biological - like salmon swimming upstream to … you know ... do "it." Not something to get all judgy about, sheesh. You take it all too serious. :lol:
 
After a strong pilot, Picard took a big step backwards with this episode.

Where to begin...there was some outright terrible acting by the guest cast here. The Admiral arguing with Picard was terrible and that whole conversation was cliched. If Picard didn't get along with this admiral, why go to her in the first place? More than fair to point out that after trashing Starfleet, he wasn't likely to get a ship in the first place.

Because she's the CINC of Star Fleet (CINC stands for Commander In Chief) - as was stated in the episode. If Picard wants reinstatement and a ship, she has to approve it, period. He doesn't get to pick who he sees for reinstatement after resigning in protest.

And personally the response was absolutely on point and warranted because Star Fleets DOES get to, and has on many an occasions, made the choice as to whether a Civilization lives or dies. It's a BIG part of the Prime Directive - and especially the TNG era interpretation of the PD.
 
Last edited:
Vulcans being evil, manipulative or just plain condescending pricks isn't really just an Enterprise/nuTrek thing... didn't DS9 have a literal Vulcan serial killer in one episode? And while Captain Solok from the baseball episode wasn't exactly what you'd call duplicitous or manipulative, he was a condescending prick and he did have a really unhealthy fixation on having to prove humans, and specifically, one single human he met at the Academy decades ago, inferior at every single opportunity. Enterprise's Jerk!Vulcans couldn't exist without him.
Even Sarek's assistants in "Sarek" could be a bit abrasive. Let's not pretend this is something new.
 
I cannot recall of any, aside from T'Pring's wonderful conspiracy to have Spock murdered by Stonn's hand or vice versa.

Not a conspiracy as T'Pring invoked a legitimate right within the process of Pon Farr.

Just as an aside … always thought Pon Farr would have been a great name for a punk rock band.
 
And now for something completely different ...

th
 
Not a conspiracy as T'Pring invoked a legitimate right within the process of Pon Farr.
Conspiracy: the action of plotting or conspiring.

T'Pring plotted to either have Stonn either way, either by Kirk stepping up as her champion and dying, or Kirk killing Spock and she would be free to marry Stonn. She states as much to Spock at the end of the episode.

Sounds like a conspiracy to me...:shrug:
 
Did someone already notice the questionable hygiene of these people?

First, they have sex in their underwear but that's not the worst of it. After they get out of bed they put their clothes on and go to work!!! How about a shower, pigs!!!:rolleyes:
 
Nina Hagen and the Pon Farr's...

edit:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I quite enjoyed the episode. It continues to reinforce what we already know about Picard himself - a man of conviction, of morals. I'm immensely curious about what appears to be a group effort regarding the Artefact, and how deep the Romulan agenda goes...
 
Did someone already notice the questionable hygiene of these people?

First, they have sex in their underwear but that's not the worst of it. After they get out of bed they put their clothes on and go to work!!! How about a shower, pigs!!!:rolleyes:

Actually, I thought of that as well. :barf:

Conspiracy: the action of plotting or conspiring.

T'Pring plotted to either have Stonn either way, either by Kirk stepping up as her champion and dying, or Kirk killing Spock and she would be free to marry Stonn. She states as much to Spock at the end of the episode.

Sounds like a conspiracy to me...:shrug:

Wasn't a conspiracy. Nothing illicit about it. As for choosing Kirk as her champion, well, not even Stonn knew she was going to do that. Even, if he had, she was bona fide. If you and a friend go out and start a newspaper to exercise your 1st amendment right of free speech, well, that ain't a conspiracy. It's a matter of intent.
 
I quite enjoyed the episode. It continues to reinforce what we already know about Picard himself - a man of conviction, of morals. I'm immensely curious about what appears to be a group effort regarding the Artefact, and how deep the Romulan agenda goes...
Well, we need to see if Hugh is somehow connected to the Romulan Borg experiments, and if Picard pulled a "Ceti Alpha V" on Hugh and his group after Descent (i.e. never checked up on them)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top