Retro-casting superhero films and shows
- Thread starter JRoss
- Start date
Note that Aquaman was not given the name "Arthur Curry" until Adventure Comics #260 in May 1959. The Golden Age Aquaman was just named Aquaman. (Talk about "woefully lacking in development.")
As JRoss acknowledged up front.
Yes, yes, she would. For the life of me I couldn't remember her name.
"The Manhunter from Mars" (1990)
written & directed by John Carpenter
Music by John Carpenter & Alan Howarth
Special Make-Up Effects by Rob Bottin
Special Visual Effects by ILM
John Jones - Lance Henriksen
J'onn J'onzz - Carel Struycken
Diane Meade - Kim Cattrall
Despero - Keith David
written & directed by John Carpenter
Music by John Carpenter & Alan Howarth
Special Make-Up Effects by Rob Bottin
Special Visual Effects by ILM
John Jones - Lance Henriksen
J'onn J'onzz - Carel Struycken
Diane Meade - Kim Cattrall
Despero - Keith David
Oh, man, this one is so good. I can see it being made, too.
Two-Face: Bill Shatner, Jack Lord, George Hamilton
Harley Quinn: Marta Kristen, Elke Sommer, or Goldie Hawn (Harley's in her twenties, not her thirties or forties)
R'as al-Ghul: Michael Ansara, Omar Sharif, Leonard Nimoy or Henry Silva
Poison Ivy: Tina Louise, Nichelle Nichols, Leslie Uggams
Clayface: Boris Karloff (and I agree with you on this)
Bane: Cal Bolder
Killer Croc: No change
Solomon Grundy: Cal Bolder or any other actor of a similar size, possibily even this guy
Scarecrow: No change
Dr. Hugo Strange: Christopher Lee or Roddy McDowell
Deadshot: No change
My choice: Richard Chamberlain.
Susan Oliver would've been good as Sue.
Swap Denzel's role and put Wesley in there, and it would work (Snipes was to play T'Challa originally in a planned Black Panther movie to be made by Sony back in the '90's.)
Last edited:
I really like Richard Chamberlain as Reed. Oh, and Goldie Hawn as Harley would be AWESOME. I put Mamie Van Doren mainly because I'm a big fan. Jack Lord as Two-Face is brilliant. Very dashing guy. While we're at it with the almost-captains of TOS, why not Jeffrey Hunter?
I had never thought of Nichelle as Ivy before. As I reflect on it, I think she'd have been perfect. Probably would have brought the same energy to the role that she put into Mirror Uhura. I don't recall having heard Leslie Uggam's name before.
Yeah, Leonard Nimoy would have done an amazing job as R'as al-Ghul. an't believe that it never crossed my mind.
That Cal Bolder fellow certainly is imposing. Hmm, ifwe're going the bodybuilder route, I'll suggest Mickey Hargitay. Not quite as big, but I think they might have cast him. Remember how Cliff Robertson, who played Shame, had his wife as Shame's minion? Imagine Mickey Hargitay as Bane, with Jayne Mansfield as his assistant. I know they'd been divorced for years at this point, but she could have conceivably appeared in the first two seasons.
Yeah, Wesley Snipes was the go-to guy for action back in the 90s. Hmm, if we had him as T'Challa, maybe Miguel A Nunez as Killmonger? The guy pulled off DeeJay in Street Fighter back in 94.
EDIT: I also really like Elke Sommer and especially Marta Kristen as Harley.
One actor whom I want to call attention to is Penny Singleton. She was most famous for playing Blondie in the 40s and was also the voice of Jane Jetson. If you look up more pictures of her, she was a stunningly beautiful woman. She also had great comedic chops. I'd really recommend her as Harley in a 1940s-era Batman.
Yeah, I too can now see him as Dent/Two Face. BTW, when I said 'Richard Chamberlain as...' I meant him as Charles Xavier (there are some panels in one of the '60's X-Men comics that (to me) have him resembling Chamberlain without hair.
Uggams played a THRUSH agent in an episode of The Girl From U.N.C.L.E., Natasha Brimstone.
Another actor to play R'as could be....David Carradine!
Other 60's starlets I now just thought of to play Harleen/Harley:
Tuesday Weld
Sue Lyon
Hayley Mills (or her elder sister, Juliet)
Susan Oliver
Carol Lynley
Mia Farrow
Sharon Tate
Inger Stevens
Patty Duke
Oh, yeah. David Carradine as R'as is good. Okay, a bit recent for "retro", but here are my casting wishes for if they had continued on with the Christopher Nolan/ Christian Bale batman series. I'm not recasting, only suggesting the people that I'd like to see in unfilmed roles.
Penguin: PHilip Seymour Hoffman
Riddler: David Tennant
Poison Ivy: Jessica Chastain
Mr. Freeze: Sean Bean
Hugo Strange: David Bowie
Man-Bat: Andy Serkis
Hush: Hugh Jackman
Penguin: PHilip Seymour Hoffman
Riddler: David Tennant
Poison Ivy: Jessica Chastain
Mr. Freeze: Sean Bean
Hugo Strange: David Bowie
Man-Bat: Andy Serkis
Hush: Hugh Jackman
Substitute a young Charles Dance for Sean Bean and I'm for this.
I don't really see Bowie as Hugo Strange, one name I heard a lot in association with the character was Robin Williams, and I think the serious version of him would have been perfect.
Wouldn't Hush just be Christian Bale in a dual role?
Frank Miller pretty much drew him that way in The Dark Knight Returns.