• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Were Tuvok and Neelix aware Janeway killed Tuvix?

Well, they didn't "murder him", Jadzia finally convinced Curzon to come back to her, which is strange since as "Curzodo" he was indeed alive and able to do a lot of things like beat Quark at his own games but in Jadzia, he's just a memory... Odd, isn't it?
That is a good reason to get the dax part to leave make Odo too good at stopping Quark.
 
Without Tuvok and Neelix, they never would have got off the basics planet?

Tuvix, without the Doctor threatening to restore Neelix and Tuvok constantly, could have lived out a nice life on the basics planet.

That fate was three episodes away.
 
Unless Tuvix would have handled that Kazon prisoner better. They kinda walked right into that situation
 
Without Tuvok and Neelix, they never would have got off the basics planet?

Tuvix, without the Doctor threatening to restore Neelix and Tuvok constantly, could have lived out a nice life on the basics planet.

That fate was three episodes away.
Until Spieces 8472 shows up later that year after beating the Borg and then destroying that planet. Jason
 
But that can only happen in a timeline where Voyager sent the Aeon back to 1969 and schooled the 20th century, otherwise there's a Eugenics War on Muscle Beach.
 
Without Tuvok and Neelix, they never would have got off the basics planet?

Tuvix, without the Doctor threatening to restore Neelix and Tuvok constantly, could have lived out a nice life on the basics planet.

That fate was three episodes away.

Neither Tuvok nor Neelix had any part in getting them off the planet! It's was all Paris' doing! As for their survival on the planet, Neelix got one guy killed right away before the opening credits and then got stupidly captured by the natives adding to their problems. I am guessing that Tuvix would have known better.
 
Tuvix was an upgrade for Neelix, and a downgrade for Tuvok. It was the Neelix side that wanted to keep the new identity.
 
If Tuvok had merged with Janeway, what would have been the name of the "offspring"? Tuway or Janevok?

How about Kim and Paris? Karis or Pim?

Chakotay and Seven? Chakeven or Sotay?

These are important questions that will never be answered!!!
 
Isn't it time to talk about the real Tuvix killer! Benny Russell! His writing could get dark at times. There must have been a Janeway looking nurse Ratchet working at that mental hospital or something. Jason
 
Tuvix was an upgrade for Neelix, and a downgrade for Tuvok. It was the Neelix side that wanted to keep the new identity.

This here was a fidelity loophole.

Tuvok was into Kes.

Sure Tuvok was married, but he wasn't getting at Kes without killing Neelix.

What a pity that Kes wasn't into Tuvix.
 
Half of him had already went there every night for two thirds of her life, and the other half of him had been with the same woman for 80 years.

Mixing familiarity with desperation.
 
It must be nice to be so confident that Tuvix was "only the result of an accident" that you're willing to overlook the possibility that separating him is in fact murder.

What if you're wrong?

Well, If I'm wrong it doesn't matter. Tuvix was hard on the eyes, hard on the ears, the actor sucked, and It doesn't matter one bit if they killed him.... thankfully he wasn't around for the next episode. One more exclaimed "Ahhhhhh!" and I would have phasered him myself.

The point is kinda moot.
 
I think you're preaching to the choir here. :)

But some posters seem to be expressing the viewpoint that Tuvix wasn't ever actually "alive", so separating him isn't "killing" him.

Maybe what they're saying is that he wasn't really "killed", his combined personality was split back into two separate personalities and two separate bodies. There was no "death" involved. "He" meaning the combined personality, just didn't have the right to stay combined.

No one died. Well, no one ever explained what happened to the orchid.
 
Well, If I'm wrong it doesn't matter. Tuvix was hard on the eyes, hard on the ears, the actor sucked, and It doesn't matter one bit if they killed him.... thankfully he wasn't around for the next episode. One more exclaimed "Ahhhhhh!" and I would have phasered him myself.

The point is kinda moot.

So in one post you've not only dodged the point of my question but used ad hominem justifications for why Tuvix had no right to exist.

Well, I'm convinced!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top