Which is the stronger ship, Disco or Enterprise?
- Thread starter B. L.
- Start date
Definitely Enterprise. It's a Constitution class heavy cruiser designed to counter the Klingon D-7 and built to take and administer an asswhipping.
Apparently D-7s weren’t a thing when Enterprise was designed. Well there was a de’sevghn ship, but we don’t talk about it
Miranda is hardly a science vessel. It’s a heavy destroyer to Enterprise heavy cruiser. Sure, all things being equal Enterprise would have kicked it’s ass, but if it wasn’t for one stubborn Vulcan they fight would have ended a draw.
Games these days suck:We need more Star Trek video games out there so we can find out ourselves. Having played Star Trek 25th Anniversary and Judgment Rites you'll be surprised at how weak the Enterprise actually is.
“Raise shields!” - that would a dollar please or please wait for 1 hour...
“Fire photon torpedoes!” - you will need to find the torpedoes in these storage boxes, but you can only open them once a day...
“But he is firing at me continuously?!” - ah the kid must have stolen his parent’s credit card...
Well, apparently the general hull shape was already a thing in Archer's time: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Vorok's_battle_cruiserApparently D-7s weren’t a thing when Enterprise was designed. Well there was a de’sevghn ship, but we don’t talk about it
The older Trek games did try to preserve a genuine feel--the 25th Anniversary and Judgment Rites games I played, and A Final Unity.
Now... let's just say I tried the new "Fleet Command" mobile game, and Kelvin timeline Scotty was gleefully ordering me to attack some Nausicaans who, as far as I could tell, hadn't even done anything to me...
Sssh... we don’t talk about such things under penalty of treason
Yup. It's important to find out tactical flaws before going out to fight an enemy, not during.
We’ll sure, that’s why “what if” scenarios and wargames are very important and valid
My ol Lawn Dart kicked some F-35 ass.
In Discovery, the Klingon D7 didn't come along until decades after the Enterprise was launched in 2245.
But did it cost $1.5T (T is for Trillion)?
How old is Enterprise in Discovery? I keep getting mixed up with canon they synced up...
Discovery season 2 takes place in 2257. Assuming Robert April's command of Enterprise was a 5 year mission, the Enterprise launched in 2245, making it 12 years old in Discovery.How old is Enterprise in Discovery? I keep getting mixed up with canon they synced up...
How old is Enterprise in Discovery? I keep getting mixed up with canon they synced up...
Pretty sure the 2245 launch date is visible on Pike's service record (which also includes the Enterprise's) if you freezeframe it.
FWIW, the idea that the Constitution-class is a reaction to the D7 is from the old FASA Four Years War RPG booklet, which a certain clusterfuck of a never-happened fan film was based upon.
Depends which ship can magic the most fighters and shuttles out of its hull that we've never seen before, and probably never see again...
Similar threads
