you and a ton of other people want the Donnerverse to come back, especially with regards to Superman and company.
Nope. And the reception to Superman Returns showed how very not true that was.
BvS script is shit, because it managed the amazing feat of making me want Batman (arguably the protagonist in the theatrical cut) to die in his very first outing. And also made me not really give a shit that Superman
did.
And I didn’t mind MOS. So BvS actually managed to take
away my goodwill
towards the character
. Not because he necessarily does anything terrible, but because he feels like a guest star in his own movie.
It also absolute fizzers of villains. Lex is always irritating, it never rings true that anyone tolerates him, let alone is intimidated by him, his plan is
awful (and relies on the movie forgetting Superman has been established to have x- ray vision in this verse,) whilst Doomsday is just...pixels. In a series with a lot of villains that have ended up looking like something out of Warcraft circa 2003 (but with less colour,) the Big D was far and away the worst.
Which is all the stranger, because MoS had previously done a fair job with Zod and Faora. I wanted to see more of a
henchmen, than I did Lex.
Actually, the transformation of Zod to Doomsday is pretty much a metaphors for how I view the two movies. We went from a character that was pretty well realised despite its flaws, and even his harshest critics would concede had moments of genuinely great execution...to an empty corpse that does what
should be ‘serious’ shit, yet never manages to have any actual weight.
The only Marvel movies that come close to the levels of ‘I don’t give a shit’ and ‘urrrrrgh’ that BvS inspired, were are Iron Man 2 and Avengers 2 respectively. But at least they had the mercy to not be
three hours long.