• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

USS Enterprise (eventually) on Discovery?

As long as the Enterprise bridge looks a lot more like the TOS bridge from "The Cage" than it does anything on the Discovery or other starships in the series then I'll be glad. We know it won't be a faithful recreation and completely changing it to the point of being unrecognizable would only set off a storm of bile even the changes to the external appearance of the Enterprise didn't trigger. I'm expecting different but not so different that you can't sort of squint and imagine that's what you saw in "The Cage(TOS)."
 
As long as the Enterprise bridge looks a lot more like the TOS bridge from "The Cage" than it does anything on the Discovery or other starships in the series then I'll be glad. We know it won't be a faithful recreation and completely changing it to the point of being unrecognizable would only set off a storm of bile even the changes to the external appearance of the Enterprise didn't trigger. I'm expecting different but not so different that you can't sort of squint and imagine that's what you saw in "The Cage(TOS)."

I hope they don't go retro. There's no reason why it shouldn't look far closer to the Discovery's bridge than what was cool for 1964. At its clunkiest it should look like a movie era setup, IMO.
 
As long as the basic layout is the same along with many of the colors and the flatscreen computer displays sort of resemble the original backlit displays that'll be close enough. I hope they stick to just one turbolift with smooth doors and a graphic of the ship displayed in the alcove.
 
I'm expecting different but not so different that you can't sort of squint and imagine that's what you saw in "The Cage(TOS)."

Well, let's be honest: most people know the TOS bridge, and not The Cage bridge. The former is colourful (red red red), the latter isn't. That's what the majority associates with the Enterprise, so that's what we're going to get.

Personally, I find the canon adherence to what we saw in The Cage to be too rigid. One has to accept that a pilot is flawed and should never be taken as gospel canon. We've seen this time and time again in Trek: the time barrier, United Earth Space Ship Enterprise, James R. Kirk, Sulu as a Mathematician, Data -- class of '78, etc....

I think writers should be free to retcon anything ridiculous that comes out of a pilot (even the first season of a show).
 
TNG should have been set 122 years after TOS. It would have continued to match the airdate/years and Data's line would have made sense!
 
I don't know why the Discoprise having a window / viewscreen combo is such a problem. There is precedent.

As we move in....

BridgeDome5.jpg


BridgeDome4.jpg


BridgeDome7.jpg


BridgeDome3.jpg


BridgeDome6.jpg


BridgeDome2.jpg
Last time I mentioned that I was lectured to about how the proportions don't exactly match the window on set and so it was clearly a sensor array... :rolleyes:

Of course, the Kelvin universe Enterprise window never looked the same twice:
L0880vI.jpg
 
The thing is, trying to make that bump align with the turbolift takes more effort than any other bit of fitting the sets inside the model. Why bother?

The few glimpses we get in through this skylight ("real" or for-the-benefit-of-audience, take your pick) fail to suggest either the proper orientation ("The Cage") or the proper dimensions ("The Cage"-R) for plopping the lift inside the bump. Which isn't much of a wonder, because the scenes wouldn't strive to show the crew flying sidesaddle - indeed, avoiding showing this would be the foremost concern with the shot, everything else being slave to this.

Then there's the overall need to give a bit of room for extras around the bridge. There are explicit alternate means of entry in TAS, and implicit in TOS; there's the curvature of the outer hull, the great effort put into concealing ceiling height, whatnot. A bridge sitting well below some sort of a futuro-radar dome solves all our problems, and Jeffries', and is absolutely required for making the movie era bridges fit, and is the choice made for the Kelvin movies, and is explicit in DSC, and... Well, the only parts of Trek that would support a bridge flush with the top dome would be TNG and ENT, from different centuries altogether.

Timo Saloniemi
 
In a properly forward-facing bridge, it would be more or less behind Uhura's station. Which is the one folks can explicitly crawl under. The perfect secret route to the mancave / saucertop house of Kirk and boys?

Actually, it's the Ready Room, left unused by two skippers in a row. But that's where you install one if you feel the urge, as per DSC. (It has windows, too, only they are seamlessly shuttered on those seasons when the space is left to fallow.)

Timo Saloniemi
 
It could be the bridge bathroom. Nicknamed the "battle bridge" for those really hard days.
In a properly forward-facing bridge, it would be more or less behind Uhura's station. Which is the one folks can explicitly crawl under. The perfect secret route to the mancave / saucertop house of Kirk and boys?

Actually, it's the Ready Room, left unused by two skippers in a row. But that's where you install one if you feel the urge, as per DSC. (It has windows, too, only they are seamlessly shuttered on those seasons when the space is left to fallow.)

Timo Saloniemi
I've combined these two into a bathroom you can only reach by crawling through the circuitry under Uhura's station.
 
I don't know why the Discoprise having a window / viewscreen combo is such a problem. There is precedent.

As we move in....

BridgeDome5.jpg


BridgeDome4.jpg


BridgeDome7.jpg


BridgeDome3.jpg


BridgeDome6.jpg


BridgeDome2.jpg

I keep saying, one of the refits involved a new paintjob and they forgot to mask that damn window. Kinda like a cheap at-home car repainting job.

But clearly the bridge was replaced with one that didn't have a window.
 
Replace backlit displays with actual dynamic computer readouts with changing graphics. Have blinky lights in there but mix them in with printed text and graphics-in-motion.
 
I'd be happy with touch panels similar to the late TOS movies, but with TOS colours, and with some physical buttons thrown in.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top