• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

THE ORVILLE S2, E3: "HOME"

I was hoping Bob Picardo would be a somewhat-recurring character, but now w/ Alara jumping ship, I fear we won't see him anymore (or at least significantly less).
 
I'm hoping that the loss of Alara doesn't negatively impact the show. Seems odd that the actress would make a decision to leave the series after only a dozen episodes. Even if she did break up with Seth, can't they just be professionals and get over it?
 
If a friend of yours said something similar, wouldn't you give him an odd look?
The point wasn't the odd look, the point was that it happened and that it may foreshadow a future storyline for Gordon.
 
I'm hoping that the loss of Alara doesn't negatively impact the show. Seems odd that the actress would make a decision to leave the series after only a dozen episodes. Even if she did break up with Seth, can't they just be professionals and get over it?

Apparently, it is actual policy of the TV network that any romantic relationship between cast members is strictly forbidden so if it happens, the character must be written off the show.
 
I'm hoping that the loss of Alara doesn't negatively impact the show. Seems odd that the actress would make a decision to leave the series after only a dozen episodes. Even if she did break up with Seth, can't they just be professionals and get over it?

My understanding in a nutshell.....she had an chance to be the lead in a Netflix drama that could further her career. Seth, being a nice guy and her bf at the time was supportive even though it would require her to miss several episodes of The Orville, but the door is left open for a return. At some point they broke up and she started dating Charlie Puth in September.....

Now if her career takes off, I say she's gone for good. If career stalls or you hear her and Seth have been spotted together again, then a return could happen. It did feel pretty final though, it was handled well I thought. A lot can happen before cameras roll on season 3.
 
I'm curious what the backstory for the new Xelayan character is going to be. Wasn't it a pretty big deal that Alara was one of very few Xelayans in the Union Fleet? If there are that few of them, it seems a bit surprising we'd end up with another one in the same place so quickly. I'm wondering if she ends on The Orville specifically because of Alara, either because she knew her or because Mercer specifically requests one of the other Xelayans as a replacement.

I guess we'll find out in two weeks' time ---
as the first contact episode where Talla is first featured as Security Chief is scheduled in two weekss

But my theory is that they have problems with whoever is the Security Chief of the Week (Lt Tharl or whoever's in that position next week), they're incompetent and didn't have the same problem-solving skills like Alara did (esp. when it comes to heavy-lifting stuffs) so finally Ed decided to find another Xelayan to fill the shoes.

Since the new security chief is also a Xelayan female, I assume Mercer has so much affinity with Alara that he requests a new replacement identical to her. Whether the fans will quickly warm up to her or will start making comparisons bw her to the person she replaces remains to be seen...

There's definitely an opening for her to return as a guest if not a regular

Definitely. Alara wasn't given the Tasha Yar exit. We know where she is spending her time know so I guess whenever Halston wants to return to the show, the door is open for her....
 
Must be wrong then, or we wouldn’t have had 6 awesome seasons of The Americans
 
Last edited:
The rule is mentioned on the IMDB page for the episode. Maybe IMDB is wrong but that's where it comes from. I did not just make it up on my own.
As pointed out up the thread, like Wikipedia, just about anyone can add things to IMDb.......so take it all with a huge grain of salt.

Edit: I just submitted a deletion request for this. The "trivia" even stated it was rumor.........smh
 
For a moment there I was thinking this Episode was going to turn into the movie; Funny Games.
When a solution for her gravity was found, I had this idea in my mind she's wear these pieces of Armor to make her daily life heavier. She'd look more warriror like, guess the simulation solution is a better one to keep the aesthetic and converse character style.

I definitely see opportunities to revisit her character. She could get a job as a local law enforcement officer on her planet. - All that would be needed is to visit the planet or if an investigation sends her off world.
 
The rule is mentioned on the IMDB page for the episode. Maybe IMDB is wrong but that's where it comes from. I did not just make it up on my own.
As several people have mentioned, IMDB doesn't really fact check their stuff because most of it is user submitted. It's best to take it with a grain of salt at all times. :)
Still, it's a common enough mistake because you'd think "Internet Movie Database" with all of its official looking branding, and premium/pro subscriptions wouldn't be so prone to error, but yeah, it's a lot more like Wikipedia than, say, Variety.
 
I'm hoping that the loss of Alara doesn't negatively impact the show. Seems odd that the actress would make a decision to leave the series after only a dozen episodes. Even if she did break up with Seth, can't they just be professionals and get over it?
She left because she's filming a movie. A person can't be in two places at once you know.
Apparently, it is actual policy of the TV network that any romantic relationship between cast members is strictly forbidden so if it happens, the character must be written off the show.
As I mentioned when this was brought up in another thread, if there were such a rule, then why are both Adrianne Palicki and Scott Grimes both still on the show when they are in fact dating each other?
 
She left because she's filming a movie. A person can't be in two places at once you know.
Pfft. says you.

*continues work on clone ray*

As I mentioned when this was brought up in another thread, if there were such a rule, then why are both Adrianne Palicki and Scott Grimes both still on the show when they are in fact dating each other?
Aw. ♥
My heart melts a little every time Adrianne Palicki shows up on screen.
 
That was very good episode, very sweet and well done. And I liked the visual with Alara on the riding animal on the beach. Yeah, it looked like the cover of a romance novel, but it was just a nice visual. I don't think Star Trek ever really managed to make an alien planet and world somehow feel so "real" and appealing.

But... Alara is gone. :( That's just... Sigh. I really hope to see her come back somewhere down the road but the "drama" of this episode and just her good byes all felt too final. (Though it probably did that as a just in case where she doesn't come back.)

Alara was my favorite character, beyond the obvious, I'm not sure why but Halston Sage just really seemed to bring the character to life with her acting. It just somehow really, really worked. I don't see that easily being replaced with the eventual Xelayan female replacement.

Good episode. Well done. Goodbye Alara. :(
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top