• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Middle-Easterners in "Discovery"

FWIW, I don't recall the major gripe with Saldana's casting being her nationality. From what I remember, the major gripe was that she didn't look like a person whose ancestors were from a central African country, as Nichelle Nichols did. Saldana actually looked more like she could have been from a northern African country, Ethiopia or Egypt maybe.

So they assumed people in Africa don't migrate to other parts of the continent? BTW Ethopia is not in the North, have such folks even met an Eastern African, they come in all shapes, sizes and looks.
To be fair if Earth is as united and global migration is as normal as moving across town, there is no reason why in a reboot Star Trek, white skinned Kirk McCoy and Scotty could not be African born citizens, brown skinned Uhura be born in Australia and Sulu have an English accent. Chekov can stay Russian lol
 
You don't really understand the way things work do you?

The Middle East, Africa, and South America do not survive the economic, environmental, and Sociopolitical effects of WW3. With trade ceased their economies would collapse while also eliminating the food imports that keep their populations from starving. The environmental effects would add to this causing a further reduction in their ability to actually grow food forcing their populations from starvation to "we have to invade others and steal their food to live".

Now if that wasn't bad enough without the US military acting as a Bulwark during all this the Arab nations would go full hog in their attempts to destroy Israel. Which since Israel doesn't have the conventional forces necessary to fight off all of those nations without the US means they will result to a per-emptive nuclear strike against any state that so much as looks at them funny.

So yea, the Middle East, Africa, and South America would be complete and utter write offs after WW3 no matter who fought it.

Very likely China and India would be too due to the whole "Starvation" thing.

Can I see the calculations you ran to come up with that outcome, Hari Seldon?
 
You guys, America is the best and without us the world will descend into chaos and madness. That's how this works! The fact that in FC Montana is a shithole wasteland is fake news.
The way things are going we might all descend into a shithole with only Trump and that North Korea dictator left to populate the Earth with Angela Merkel.

P.S My theory that it was the mentally challenged that left Europe to conquer America grows stronger every day...
 
You guys, America is the best and without us the world will descend into chaos and madness. That's how this works!
Warning: Explicit (R-rated) material
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

EDIT TO ADD: ;)
 
Last edited:
P.S My theory that it was the mentally challenged that left Europe to conquer America grows stronger every day...

Those of our ancestors who left Europe did so, for the most part, for one of two reasons:

  1. Someone didn't want them there; and/or
  2. They didn't want to be there.
Neither motivation is difficult to understand or empathize with.
 
Those off our ancestors who left Europe did so, for the most part, for one of two reasons:

  1. Someone didn't want them there; and/or
  2. They didn't want to be there.
Neither motivation is difficult to understand or empathize with.

Except for the folks who were already living there
 
By the time the Star Trek universe comes along all will be forgiven...Just waiting for you all to blow up the world first with the Eastern Coalition.

You mean, a few years before an American invents the warp drive and makes first contact?

It's a good thing we built all those ICBMs and stashed them around rural America - otherwise Cochrane would have nothing to work with and there would be no Star Trek Future. :p
 
As far as I'm concerned, the credit for the founding of the Federation should go to the people who founded it (Vulcans, Archer and the Earth gov, not to the blunders and happy accidents of people beforehand who blasted the path with bombs and stupidity to clear the way for the Federation. Zefram Cochrane made an impact, but he wasn't really "American" because "America" was but dust by then. And really, Vulcans provided a guiding hand in our time of need. So, yay Vulcans.
 
Vulcans had an ulterior motive, use Earth as cannon fodder to fight the Andorians but it all went pear shaped...(My Star Trek Terra prime conspiracy theory lol)
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top