• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Voyager fans.. are you disappointed about Discovery?

This is so fascinating.. I'm getting a real catch up on their appearances. Memory Alpha.. I will not plagiarise.. Memory Alpha..

*The official First Contact between Vulcans and Humans came on April 5, 2063, when a Vulcan survey ship, the T'Plana-Hath, detected the warp flight of Zefram Cochrane's Phoenix. The Vulcans met with Cochrane at his launch site on the day following the flight. (Star Trek: First Contact)*

(So far Vulcans seem to be curious, a little controlling but still after order..)

*By the 21st and 22nd centuries, the Vulcans had also made contact with the Cardassians, Trill, Tholians, Klingons, and scores of other races. (DS9: "Destiny"; )*

This is ALL from Memory Alpha just want to reference that:

*As of the 23rd century, Vulcan had never been conquered in its collective memory. That memory went so far back that Vulcans could not conceive of a conqueror. (TOS: "The Immunity Syndrome")

In TOS: "The Conscience of the King", Spock declines to have a drink with McCoy by saying that his people were "spared the dubious benefits of alcohol"; McCoy scorns Spock's refusal by stating that he now knows why Vulcan was conquered. This would seem to contradict the above. A possible solution could be he is referring to the Romulan infiltration in 2154, which could be considered to be a conquest.*

(Again a sense of control and order but a nice little bit of dialogue too).

*By the 24th century, Vulcan remained one of the principal Federation members, and was deeply involved at all levels of that society.

By 2369, the Vulcans had a saying known to the Federation: "We're here to serve." (DS9: "Captive Pursuit")*

I know I could go on, especially ploughing through Spock and Tuvok stuff, but I tire of this. My memories of TOS DO reflect that Spock was made to feel lesser, diluted and emotional, and he was taunted and tormented. However I also remember Spock wanting to attain what it was to be a Vulcan. I remember the dignity of other Vulcans when they were portrayed. Spock was a good.. entity. His Vulcan people may have had roots like Human ones of warring and competition, but you don't draw a line in the sand just because it makes a better argument. Define a culture at one point ignoring other references to when it was not just this one point. Their homeworld and colonies evolved. TOS and beyond colored Vulcans as having a sophisticated culture, capable of philosophy and advancement, albet with longstanding rites and rituals. Mind you in reading all the ENT entries they do paint a grubbier picture..
 
Point out the 'word games.' I want quotes.

Otherwise, cut the accusatory bullshit and address or acquiesce my actual fucking points.



Where is that established? What 'honourable principles' exactly? Quotes and episodes.
You get so demanding and have to swear. It's a little offensive.
 
Being accused of deliberately employing 'word games' when using simple English, is a little offensive.

But enough about me. Any actual fucking answers to the questions asked? Any examples that back up your claims of ENT contradicting the 'original' intent in depicting Vulcans?
 
Last edited:
It was there in simple English. Hela, I don't want to engage in an argument with someone who swears all the time. It's rather beneath me..
 
Where's the 'word games'? Quote them
Also Me said:
Any actual fucking answers to the questions asked? Any examples that back up your claims of ENT contradicting the 'original' intent in depicting Vulcans?

It was there in simple English. Hela, I don't want to engage in an argument with someone who swears all the time. It's rather beneath me..

So that'd be a 'no' then. To both.

Oh well. Claims presented without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.
 
Last edited:
You can try all the word games you like, Spock embodies Vulcan culture. You cannot remove that from him, it is in him. It is how he has been identified and what he aspired to. He is, in all his mixed race DNA still a product of that culture whether others like it or not.

As for my list..oh God it is tedious. Memory Alpha is my friend. All the bloody ENT refs ..

Homeworld. - founding member of Federation of Planets TOS.

The homeworld aspired to order, to rules and the upholding of honorable principles and directives . Led the way.. In one of our earliest insights to Vulcans that is a first impression.
I would distinguish Spock as embodying the ideal of Vulcan culture, rather than a perfect presentation of it. Spock chose not live among his people, and is kind of a similar position to Worf in that he gets a reflection of his culture from an outside perspective.

Yes, Spock is a product of that culture, but, at the same time, he moved past that culture. He ended up not receiving their cultures highest honor in Kohlinar, nor did he decide to return to Vulcan after retirement. He embodies an ideal, but he also moves past it.

"Logic...logic is the beginning of wisdom, not the end."
 
It's almost like...the Worf/Klingons and Seven/Borg relationships were based heavily on Spock/Vulcans.

Or hell, Garek broadly had the same arc when it came to the Cardassians.

But that'd be some crazy talk. Those species typically were presented as having a lot of negative traits.
 
Last edited:
It's almost like...the Worf/Klingons and Seven/Borg relationships were based heavily on Spock/Vulcans.

But that'd be some crazy talk.
Now you take that back!

Also, I want you to look very carefully at the following pictures:
:vulcan::klingon::borg:

Do you see any similarities? I thought not. Moving on...
 
Now you take that back!

Also, I want you to look very carefully at the following pictures:
:vulcan::klingon::borg:

Do you see any similarities? I thought not. .

They all look like a little bunch of miserable bastards?

No really. Why does that Borg always look so pitifully sad?
 
They all look like a little bunch of miserable bastards?

No really. Why does that Borg always look so pitifully sad?
That's a dollar ;)
uysSfRY.jpg
 
I never thought Spock was ideal.. but Tuvok is =)
I should clarify that I don't mean Spock is the ideal Vulcan but very much idealizes the Vulcan ideals. He views them as Worf views Klingon honor, an aspiration to live out.

The interesting thing about Spock, though, is that he bridge the two cultures in a very interesting way.
 
I should clarify that I don't mean Spock is the ideal Vulcan but very much idealizes the Vulcan ideals. He views them as Worf views Klingon honor, an aspiration to live out.

The interesting thing about Spock, though, is that he bridge the two cultures in a very interesting way.
I suppose but often when you straddle mixed race it is the one you look like that overrides everything. Not always though. Spock didn't aspire to be human but often challenged human ideals.

You know there is something else that seems weird about Discovery and it's the main character. Why isn't it the Captain? In this case I DO prefer the way it has always been done from past shows..
 
I suppose but often when you straddle mixed race it is the one you look like that overrides everything. Not always though. Spock didn't aspire to be human but often challenged human ideals.
No, but he ended up making peace with both sides of himself. That is one facet of Abrams Trek that I absolutely thought was amazingly well done-Sarek's speech to Spock after Amanda's death. Just fantastic exposition about the nature of Vulcans.
You know there is something else that seems weird about Discovery and it's the main character. Why isn't it the Captain? In this case I DO prefer the way it has always been done from past shows..
Possibly because they realized that a ship's captain heading out to an alien planet and possibly dying was a stupid plan. It is a bit of a hold-over from TNG, in which Riker was a bit more of the "action hero" mold, rather than the full leader. Also, now the captain can die ;)
 
Michael Dorn has been pushing for a series about Worf. He has funding and support but the powers that be are only interested in the JJ Abrams universe

Maybe he can tool around the universe with Captain Sulu. It's not about an actor's ego or a character's popularity, but science fiction ideas and drama.
======
I don't obsess on the details of Discovery, when it will probably be another step downward, that misses the point and "updates" Trek so it's like all the bad TV around now.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top