I don't understand.....I don't understand. I'm gobsmacked by that trailer, and by the reaction here. I don't understand how anyone can get legitimately excited about a Star Trek movie that looks or feels anything like that. It looks EXACTLY like EVERY OTHER ACTION MOVIE. Is that the idea now? To tone down Star Trek's literary ambitions, thematic ambitions, quality storytelling, everything that made it unique and LESS popular than other action franchises, until it exactly resembles all those other franchises, so that now EVERYONE can love it? Why? Why? What advantage is there in that for anyone? (Aside from the potential economic advantage for Paramount.) What advantage is there in turning Star Trek into exactly the same kind of story as everything else? That's entropic. That's depressing. I'm not saying Star Trek was better than every other franchise. But it was different. It wasn't Star Wars. It wasn't Terminator. It wasn't The Fast and the Furious. It was its own thing, and it was unique, and it was special. And now it's not. Now it's fun and exciting and action-packed...just like THOUSANDS OF OTHER MOVIES. Fun and exciting and action-packed is EASY. Disney and Marvel have cornered the market on that. Maybe Force Awakens will be that. Jurassic World is that. It's fucking EASY to make something fun and exciting. But why is that the exclusive goal? Almost none of the best Star Trek episodes or movies fit that description. They're so much more than that. Kirk used to read Dickens and quote D. H. Lawrence. Now he listens to the Beastie Boys.
It feels to some of you guys like the original TOS? Really? Which episode, City on the Edge of Forever? The Doomsday Machine? Balance of Terror? At its best, the original series was a thoughtful, dramatic, cerebral show. And hell, why stick to just the original? The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine also have their share of brilliant episodes - The Measure of a Man, The Best of Both Worlds, Yesterday's Enterprise, Darmok, The Inner Light, and onto DS9, Duet, The Visitor, In the Pale Moonlight...I can go on and on. But seriously - WTF? How is this new shit good enough? If you're making a movie, a massive Star Trek movie, a thing that only comes out every few years, then you should aim for the sky, aim to be the BEST FUCKING MOVIE you can make. Make it a classic. Compete with the best. Mindless fun? The best of Star Trek, of ANY series, was NEVER mindless fun. I'm not saying it can't have comedy. Trouble with Tribbles is high comedy at its finest. The Voyage Home is great fun. But it's not "mindless fun." Even the comedy of Star Trek can be brilliant. But this? This? I just don't get it. Why? This makes me sad. And that people on a Star Trek message board think this is a promising look at the future of the franchise...? I don't even know what to say. I guess you and I just haven't been watching the same show for the last few decades.