• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

A female Doctor, your candidates please!

Starkers

Admiral
Premium Member
I’ll just preface this thread by saying that I really enjoy Capaldi in the role, especially this series, and I hope he gets to do at least one more season but…the talk of a female Doctor has been increasing in recent years, and in the last season and a bit we’ve had two instances of male Timelords regenerating into women (though to be fair in one of those instances it seems the male incarnation was the anomalous one because she’d been a woman in her nine previous lives.)

Given the positive reaction of Michelle Gomez as Missy, a show that may be in need of a shot in the arm, and the increasing calls for it, whilst a female Doctor is by no means certain, it’s probably more likely now than it’s ever been.

So, with that in mind, let’s assume 12 regenerates at the end of series 10 into a woman. The question is Who?

This is just a bit of fun, and whilst I’m sure it won’t stop the “The Bible says thou shalt not have a female Doctor Who” brigade hopefully this will be just that, a bit of fun.

I have two actresses primarily in mind myself.

nic_zps9h8buq14.jpg


Nicola Walker (Spooks, Last Tango in Halifax, River) has been my number one choice as a female Doctor for a long time. This of course means that she’ll never get the job (Ask Patterson Joseph for further details ;) ) but I think she’d be perfect. As an actress she can do comedy and drama, she can play scatty, she can be playful and she can play dangerous. Plus she has a smile that could light up a small city. She also has a curious alien quality reminiscent of Tom or Matt, and she’s had some experience with Who with Big Finnish where (I believe?) she was a companion to the Eighth Doctor.


liv_zps54aqf8y7.jpg


[FONT=Calibri] If they can’t get Nicola then it has to be Olivia Colman, for pretty much similar reasons as Nicola Walker. Colman has pretty much done it all role wise and is equally adept at broad comedy as she is at grim drama. She’s a triple BAFTA winner and I’ve seen her play lovely a scatty, and vicious and nasty with equal aplomb. In terms of Who she was, of course, one of the manifestations of Prisoner Zero in The Eleventh Hour. Last seen in the Whoniverse chatting to Sean Pertwee at the beginning of The Fiveish Doctors bemoaning the fact that she hadn’t been asked to do the fiftieth. [/FONT]
[FONT=Calibri][/FONT]
[FONT=Calibri]Anyone else got some names they'd like to throw into the pot? :techman:[/FONT]
[FONT=Calibri][/FONT]
 
Damn it! For some reason the BBS won't let me edit the post (I just get a blank box)!

Here's what I said about Olivia Colman in an easier to read format!

If they can’t get Nicola then it has to be Olivia Colman, for pretty much similar reasons as Nicola Walker. Colman has pretty much done it all role wise and is equally adept at broad comedy as she is at grim drama. She’s a triple BAFTA winner and I’ve seen her play lovely a scatty, and vicious and nasty with equal aplomb. In terms of Who she was, of course, one of the manifestations of Prisoner Zero in The Eleventh Hour. Last seen in the Whoniverse chatting to Sean Pertwee at the beginning of The Fiveish Doctors bemoaning the fact that she hadn’t been asked to do the fiftieth.
 
One series of Helen Mirren as the Doctor would be fantastic. Yes, she's 70, but I think the show could work with that. Probably not a realistic choice, but I can dream. :)

My realistic choices right now are Romola Garai (The Hour) and Laura Carmichael (Downton Abbey). I sort of see them as being Matt Smith-esque, Garai especially.
 
All good choices. :) Olivia Colman would be amazing. I mean, she always is, so why not? And I can't believe I'm the first to mention Tilda Swinton....
 
Daniela Nardini, once of This Life, might be interesting but she doesn't seem to be very active in recent years.

At least her accent would provide continuity with Capaldi.
 
i was about to name Tilda Swinton.

I could also imagine Lena Heady in the role.

Always had in my head that Tilda was European but didn't think she was British, that just puts her even higher on the list.

Lena is an interesting choice.

People always bring up Joanna Lumley but I could imagine a crazy Jennifer Saunders Doctor. :lol:
 
One series of Helen Mirren as the Doctor would be fantastic. Yes, she's 70, but I think the show could work with that. Probably not a realistic choice, but I can dream. :)

That would probably be interesting to watch.

Were she not already established on the show, I could see Jemma Redgrave doing a good Doctor, though in a more serious, Pertwee-esque vein.

Michelle Dockery

No way! If it's going to be a Downton girl, it's going to be Laura Carmichael! Team Edith all the way!

Although, Amy Nuttall had this nice sense of comic timing in her physical performance that I really liked when she played Ethel on Downton Abbey.

Ever since I heard that Rachel Weisz was a fan, I kept hoping that they would bring her in as either a female Doctor or as the new Romana. Her character in The Mummy especially shows of her comedic skills.

Tilda Swinton could probably do it. After seeing her in Snowpiercer, I'm starting to think she could do anything!

However, I never ever EVER want Peter Capaldi to leave. (At least not right now. Ask me again in a year or 2. I'm starting to wonder if Doctors naturally have a 3-4 year shelf life anyway. I was pretty ready for Tennant & Smith to leave when they did.)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top