• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Supergirl - Season 1

Loved hearing "Girls Just Want To have Fun" and I hope to see more of Kara's personal life explored.

Oh yeah and they used stock footage for Supergirl flying. ...I think.

supergirl_flying1.jpg


May as well reuse that stuff I suppose. It's just that I don't think I've seen a show do that in a while. Does The Flash do it with the running shots?
I noticed the (possible) reuse too, but I think it's a great shot.

Why are people unsure about this? Of course it's reused footage.

Did anybody else find themselves agreeing with Cat's article? As for Cat, I see she is about to dive into J Jonah Grant territory after all. How long before she needs to be saved by Supergirl, I wonder.
 
Loved hearing "Girls Just Want To have Fun" and I hope to see more of Kara's personal life explored.

Oh yeah and they used stock footage for Supergirl flying. ...I think.

supergirl_flying1.jpg


May as well reuse that stuff I suppose. It's just that I don't think I've seen a show do that in a while. Does The Flash do it with the running shots?
I noticed the (possible) reuse too, but I think it's a great shot.

Why are people unsure about this? Of course it's reused footage.

Perhaps because I didn't do a side-by-side frame-by-frame comparison? :rolleyes:
 
I don't mind the romcom bits some mention as I don't watch many such shows so it's kind of refreshing for me to see a show where everyone is so pretty with fabulous apartments and flashy trendy workplaces. The show looks like a glossy magazine come to life. :)

Speaking of flying, I wish they'd explained why she didn't just fly after Reactron at the end of their first fight. They should've established that there was another motorist in need of rescue or something.

Thought that was a bit odd myself. Especially when the scenario made it so easy to show some distractions.

Of course, sometimes it's hard trying to deal with such superpowered types. Like they can dodge speeding bullets but will still get smacked with a haymaker. Or they'll deal with a hostage situation where they could grab the guy's gun before he could ever pull the trigger.

However, wounded guy slowly fluttering away was hard to ignore.

Anyone else getting a Tom Cruise vibe from the way the actor is portraying Maxwell Lord?

I did.
 
yeah, annoying plot contrivance. After the fight, his weapon isn't working, and he slowly flies away. if only Supergirl could fly! His weapon is broken, just follow him and end it? Nope, let him get away, recharge, and fight again later. Yeah...
 
yeah, annoying plot contrivance. After the fight, his weapon isn't working, and he slowly flies away. if only Supergirl could fly! His weapon is broken, just follow him and end it? Nope, let him get away, recharge, and fight again later. Yeah...
And this was my problem - some of you are too busy defending Girl Power or whatever (unnecessarily and ridiculously, when it's to me) to notice that the other stuff I was complaining about earlier was just as badly written as that.

I have no problem at all with well-written romantic plots or coming of age stories, but soooo much of what we saw last night was forced, shoe-horned, and just otherwise horribly handled. The first two episodes set up these two guys (James and Winn) as Kara's buds - and now all of a sudden there's not just one of them interested in her but boom - instant love triangle. Feh.
 
Agreed.. best episode yet and a pretty great one too.

Yes, she fights a goofy villain but then again it's a superhero show but the core of the episode was about her, why she needs to do it and how she does it.

I guess she really earned the respect of everybody and it was very nice to see her being both the dork and the superhero and this is an aspect of the show i like the most.

Best scene though was her instant messaging with Superman.. that just put a wide smile on my face because it was just plain cool. I don't know if we'll ever see Superman full frontal played by an actor (would be so kickass awesome if Henry Cavill would play that role on TV too) but here he was just human chatting with his family.

3 episodes in and from the soso pilot they manage to deliver a rocksolid episode that i may rewatch from time to time (which i do not do often).
 
I have no problem at all with well-written romantic plots or coming of age stories, but soooo much of what we saw last night was forced, shoe-horned, and just otherwise horribly handled. The first two episodes set up these two guys (James and Winn) as Kara's buds - and now all of a sudden there's not just one of them interested in her but boom - instant love triangle. Feh.

Actually I think it's been hinted pretty strongly since the beginning that they both had an interest in Kara.

And like others were saying earlier, the romantic storylines on this show aren't really any more contrived or soapy than those on Flash and Arrow. And at least here it fits the tone and style of the show a lot more naturally, unlike on Arrow where it's always felt a bit forced to me (as if the writers feel obligated to squeeze in some kind of relationship drama every episode to balance out the darker action stuff, whether it's really necessary or not).
 
I thought it was stalker-ish to see Kara eavesdropping on the conversation between James and Lucy. That's personal stuff!

Yeah the eavesdropping might have crossed the line a bit, but I wouldn't really call it stalking.

And there's the question of how much she can really control it. I mean, TV and film adaptations tend to assume that Clark or Kara has normal senses until they choose to turn on their super-senses, but is that realistic? I mean, they're senses. Do you have a gain knob on your own hearing (assuming you don't use a hearing aid)? I think Smallville explained once that Clark's super-hearing is on all the time, but he's trained himself to ignore most of it.

So Kara probably can't help hearing all sorts of conversations around the office; she just generally tries not to pay conscious attention to them. But in some cases, that's easier said than done.



I'm wondering if they're going to be using Lord basically as their version of Lex Luthor. I was already kind of starting to get that impression a bit here.

Well, uh...

Supergirl's Facinelli Explains Why Maxwell Lord Isn't the Show's Lex Luthor


USS Triumphant said:
Well, okay, not necessarily them... but *someone* who knows how to write female characters. Which the Gotham writers seem to do well.
I don't know if I'd say they write female characters particularly well. Most of the women on the show have been totally nuts, and the couple we have gotten aren't really aren't much more than just a love interest for the men.

Comic Book Resources certainly doesn't think Gotham handles women well:

"Gotham" Recap: Batty Babs Highlights the Show's Women Problems
 
Well I'm officially worried now after the ratings declined again. It's still holding steady in viewers but it's obviously the demo that matters most, and that doesn't seem like it's nearly as high as it should be for a show this expensive. And I suspect it still hasn't even fully settled yet.

With the ratings drop, do you think Supergirl will be a one season wonder at best?
 
You could probably generate a random number, go to that channel, and find a show that writes women (or anything else) better than Gotham.
 
Well I'm officially worried now after the ratings declined again. It's still holding steady in viewers but it's obviously the demo that matters most, and that doesn't seem like it's nearly as high as it should be for a show this expensive. And I suspect it still hasn't even fully settled yet.

With the ratings drop, do you think Supergirl will be a one season wonder at best?

TV Grim Reaper said on twitter it's still out of his grasp at this point.
 
Comic Book Resources certainly doesn't think Gotham handles women well:

"Gotham" Recap: Batty Babs Highlights the Show's Women Problems
They've never met my mom, either, apparently - which is good for them. Seriously, I understand why anyone who hasn't been exposed to someone like that might think the writing is bad or unrealistic, but in last night's episode they were freakin' *channeling* my mom.

I think maybe people who don't actually *have* crazy-ass borderline-supervillain people in their life might want to chill out a little on trying to judge whether or not the characterization is right. ;)
 
And there's the question of how much she can really control it. I mean, TV and film adaptations tend to assume that Clark or Kara has normal senses until they choose to turn on their super-senses, but is that realistic?
People usually filter things out if they're not paying attention. So maybe Clark and Kara do have normal senses (which they probably trained themselves to have) until they use their highly focused attention to tune in.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top