• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers S31: Disavowed by David Mack Review Thread

Rate Disavowed.

  • Outstanding

    Votes: 45 46.4%
  • Above Average

    Votes: 41 42.3%
  • Average

    Votes: 9 9.3%
  • Below Average

    Votes: 2 2.1%
  • Poor

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    97
I like how novels like this build on the tapestry of the novel 'verse story as a whole, with the arcs involving Bashir, Section 31, the mirror universe and the Breen all moving forward here. As ever, Mack is one of the best at incorporating the whole scope of the novel continuity without making any of the references feel laboured or unnecessary. This is precisely how continuity should work - not "look, I referenced such and such story", as nice as that is, but plots that emerge naturally from what's previously occurred. Mack is one of the authors I trust most to handle the "leading edge" of the timeline.

I must say this isn't his most spectacular by any means, but it's solid. There's plenty to enjoy, even if nothing blew me away.

I agree with many of the others that the Mirror Dominion is a highlight, particularly the conversation about the two realities almost seeming to have exchanged Odos. Seeing what an interstellar union controlled by the changelings might look like were it not so destructive was fascinating. The new angle on the changelings, Vorta and Jem'Hadar was convincing, and the mirrored rerun of Taran'atar's journey made me nostalgic. In a universe so torn by destructive chaos, the lure of the Dominion's order and law is undeniable.

I liked how the Galactic Commonwealth is somewhat more informal than the Federation, a consequence, no doubt, of the fact that many of its officials are former rebellion members. The way Eddington, Sevok, Gleer, zh'Faila and Zife interact is as much a party of friends as it is a group of political colleagues.

I find it interesting just how common it is among the Breen to feel tired of their peoples' extreme commitment to concealment and obfuscation. I'm getting the impression that opposition to their societal repression is far more widespread than the Breen themselves realize. Tran and Trom both express their private distaste with many aspects of the Breen way, and they're definitely not the first notable officials to do so. None of them dare speak it, though, or even really entertain that discontent at any length. If there ever is a revolution, though, I can see it avalanching. They're too atomized to realize it, but a great many of them find it wearying. In fact, considering the discussion in Silent Weapons (the one Worf angrily inserted himself into), I'm wondering if Mack doesn't have half-formed plans for a "Breen unmasking" plot at some point in the future...

I look forward to "Control".
 
That was incredible. I blew through Disavowed in a couple of evenings, and I enjoyed it immensely. Nobody writes action and galactic politics like David Mack can.

In a universe so torn by destructive chaos, the lure of the Dominion's order and law is undeniable.

This right here. Can you imagine if this Dominion encountered the Terran Empire of the 2260s? The Empire would have been blown off the map, and justifiably so. I love the fundamental idea of Changeling "order" in a "rule of law" context, rather than the oppression and subjugation of solids that the Founders of "our" universe exercise. And the speculation that the universes swapped Odos at some point? Exquisite.
 
^ I don't remember. If someone with more time and patience than me wants to try to extrapolate from the story's details when, precisely, it occurred, be my guest.
I see. My reason for asking was because I saw the line in the historian's note, "Events in the alternate universe occur approximately seven years after the founding of the Galactic Commonwealth" and thought, "2378 and January 2386? Hooray! No ridiculous rounding up for a change!"

To be clear, though, do you consider the mentioned "founding" to be the attack on SoHcha/liberation of Earth or the signing of the Tripartite Armistice? Or some slightly later date when the Assembly convened for the first time on Deneva?
 
Depending on when Silgov Prime joined the Confederacy, Vanguard's own Manón may have been a Breen citizen. :rommie:
 
Depending on when Silgov Prime joined the Confederacy, Vanguard's own Manón may have been a Breen citizen. :rommie:

I assumed that certain Silgov refugees had joined the Confederacy since their war with the Vekhal...unless the Vekhal are the Breen?

I hadn't thought of that! Yeah, maybe the Vekhal were one of the Breen species.


In other news, we now have an actor portraying Cenn Desca. He's briefly visible when Julian grabs his sidearm in DS9: "Crossover". I can't find a good picture of him, though.
 
I finished it last night, and it was a thoroughly enjoyable read. "Native" knowledge of some Breen words only enhanced the pleasure of reading, and added lots of joy :D

Especially naming one of the Breen ships with such a cuddly, cute, fluffy name as "Rabbit" :guffaw:

I like the Dominion very much...

... that they were what we know Odo to be: loving order, and justice.

I also like the idea of the MU...

... that it once again becomes quite a "mirror" for our universe, as it started in TOS, even though (or maybe especially) it's not a simple black/white - good/evil relation.

:bolian:
 
I finished it last night, and it was a thoroughly enjoyable read. "Native" knowledge of some Breen words only enhanced the pleasure of reading, and added lots of joy :D

Especially naming one of the Breen ships with such a cuddly, cute, fluffy name as "Rabbit" :guffaw:

I was intending to ask you what Breen words we had this time. :lol: Of course, the word in question does refer to a explosive-breeding ecological menace, so perhaps the name is fearsome and threatening after all. :D
 
Can I just say that between Section 31 and The Lost Era, I'm excited all these early 2000s Pocket series are getting revived. Dare I hope for book 8 of Gateways? Book 7 of Double Helix? Book 3 of The Brave and the Bold?
 
Okay, so I'm on page 166 so far, and I have to say (no spoilers), this is easily so far one of the most exciting, action-packed Star Trek novels yet. A worth entry.

Also...

Awww...a Breen with a crush. ;)
 
Can I just say that between Section 31 and The Lost Era, I'm excited all these early 2000s Pocket series are getting revived. Dare I hope for book 8 of Gateways? Book 7 of Double Helix? Book 3 of The Brave and the Bold?

I doubt it, given that Gateways and Double Helix all tied into one event that was concluded. All of the four original Section 31 novels had no real link, other than featuring Section 31.
 
I will say this about the book: I love, love, LOVE that it doesn't seem to be going with the "Section 31's a bunch of incompetent dolts that didn't see what was obvious enough for Our Heroes to find out" trope that marred the old miniseries. (Caveat--I've just given it a quick read-through, though....)

Namely...the fact that:
L'Haan and company figure without batting an eye that Sarina's "big reveal" to Julian is a big pile of tribble crap. They know that Sarina's been a double.

In short--L'Haan and Zeitsev are NOT STUPID!!!

I'm still trying to figure when, exactly, Sarina first told Julian the truth.

Now...the little thing about the very end. I love it. A lot. :evil:

And I can't wait to see if my suspicions regarding such are confirmed.

"Control" indeed. And of course they don't know his identity. Could he be...possibly...?

PLEASE, let it be so!
 
Now...the little thing about the very end. I love it. A lot. :evil:

And I can't wait to see if my suspicions regarding such are confirmed.

"Control" indeed. And of course they don't know his identity. Could he be...possibly...?

PLEASE, let it be so!

Care to elaborate as to who you think Control might be?
 
I thought this was pretty good even given that I think thhe Mirror Universe idea is completely played out and uninteresting. Oh and I know it's canon and simply follows what is on screen but I always find the idea of the super-secret Section 31 having a uniform one of the stupidest things ever...
 
Solid.

My favorite work of David Mack's has been when he tends towards bigger ideas and long-form stories - Hernandez's story in Destiny, Soong's story in Cold Equations, etc. I haven’t always been sold on Mack’s shorter, action-oriented novels. I thought Typhon Pact: Zero Sum Game was pretty weak, and Silent Weapons was the weakest of the Cold Equations trilogy for me too. I also think I was probably the only person that didn't like Rise Like Lions much.

Thankfully, this one works for me better than any of those, despite drawing on similar thematic territory. For one thing, continuing and building on stories is almost always more satisfying to me than establishing new conflicts – I like watching things grow and change. This pulls in stories from all those books, continuing to tie everything together, and it’s fun to see that. This is a great example of a uniquely tie-in novel: establishing this many different and new organizations with complex motives in a standalone novel would break the thriller pacing completely, but here all of that is already done, so the action works immediately.

Another major plus for me: this book has a couple of really atypical storylines. I adore the Breen with the crush. It’s a minor thing, only a couple of scenes, but it’s just delightful. And then what totally sold this book for me was the moment Bashir was acquitted. The Mirror Dominion seems for most of the story to be exactly the same as ours, but that little twist reframes them completely, is totally surprising, and makes complete sense. Lovely.

I also like seeing inside Section 31 a bit, things like Bashir and Sarina riding their inaudible transporters and a bunch of the gear that Cole uses to spy on Memory Omega (yes, he fails, but the tech is still fantastic). Technological development is sometimes a bit wonky in Trek, as major advancements stay in bad-guy-of-the-week stories condemned as too dangerous or whatever and never show up again; it’s kind of neat to see a bunch of previously established stuff be in S31’s arsenal (and for that matter, in the Breen commandos’ arsenal as well), to see how the covert ops people actually are following up on those advancements. The Breen using the dimensional shift transporter that slowly kills you, for instance, was neat.

That all said, I remain spectacularly uninterested in Sarina Douglas, so there wasn’t much emotional heart to this one. I mean, Bashir’s character arc, divorced from her, is totally working for me. I love his description of wanting to belong, feeling like he did the right thing but still aching to be a part of something bigger. But Sarina just spent so long in this vague place between honest and lying that I just never got sold on their relationship, and I still feel like she’s sketchy and problematic. I can’t figure out at which point she decided to be against S31, if she always was, if Bashir convinced her… no idea. That hasn’t been handled well and is basically incoherent now, and without any other quirks or noticeable personality traits, I’m just not sold.

So for me this is a tale mostly about the continuity and mechanics of the wider Star Trek universe, at this point, and Bashir and Sarina are just viewpoints; the plot is driving this around, not the characters. But that’s fine, because the plot this time has some nice quirk, some surprising twists, and pulls a bunch of interesting threads together. While perhaps a mediocre character study, this is a pretty awesome tie-in novel.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top