• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Your Favorite TV Show That Was Cancelled

I've gotta throw in Dead Like Me. Another painful cancellation for me was Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip--a much better show than "30 Rock."

I've only seen a couple of 30 Rock episodes, but I did enjoy Studio 60. I agree that it should have carried on.

Another that come to mind are Sports Night.

Life
4400 (Though the novels did a good job on that)
Farscape (at least we got Peacekeeper wars)
Dead Like Me (Haven't seen the film, but have heard it's a disappointment)

@Mistral - I too thought Over There was decent:)

:techman: and :techman::techman: for LIFE-I really didn't understand why they killed it. Great show.
 
I hope we can name more than one, because I have several:

Firefly
Better Off Ted
Father Ted
God, the Devil & Bob
Dead Like Me
Dinosaurs

And though it had 5 great seasons: Boston Legal
 
In rough order of how much I loved them:

1. Farscape
2. Wonderfalls
3. Firefly
4. Jericho
5. Dirty Sexy Money - the only non-scifi-ish show on the list. Scifi shows, I'm never really shocked about when they are canceled because they appeal to a niche audience to begin with. But I will never understand why this show did not take off. Brilliant and extremely talented cast, and one of the most bizarre and hilarious storylines ever!
6. The Dresden Files
7. The 4400
8. Life on Mars (US version)
 
8. Life on Mars (US version)

This.

I thought I was the only one on this board who liked that show! (I've never seen the UK version, nor do I particularly care to)

To my mind, Harvey Keitel is Gene Hunt, and I will accept no substitutes. Also I absolutely loved the period specific New York City setting. And Jason O'Mara was really cool as Sam Tyler. Plus the supporting cast were all excellent as well.

True, the final scene really bit the big one, but they can always The Good That Men Do-ize it out of existence just like with TATV. ;) Plus I don't think the finale was "real" anyway. Look at the decorations on the wall of the lunar module, plus whose boot it was seen stepping onto the Martian surface... ;)
 
Last edited:
[Wonderfalls] really got a raw deal (as did Drive). A show need more than 3 episodes to find an audience, especially if it's moved or pre-empted right after it starts.

Well, Wonderfalls got 4 episodes, but I still agree with your point. In particular, Wonderfalls was such a peculiar show that was so difficult to advertise. It really needed some time to build up word-of-mouth viewers. And considering they already had all 13 episodes in the can, I don't know why they didn't just go for it and see what happens.

Wonderfalls was one of the funniest TV shows ever and I still consider it the gold standard of TV comedy. Only on its best days is Glee ever this good. And then the other 2 Bryan Fuller series both at least got 2 seasons apiece. (I like Pushing Daisies but it's a little too syrupy & cloying for my taste. I still haven't seen the whole series. Meanwhile, I've only seen a couple random episodes of Dead Like Me here & there. I bought the complete series DVD set on a blind buy but I haven't watched it yet.) For my money, no great series has ever been more poorly treated than Wonderfalls.

Even though I loved the finale of Angel, I still would have liked to have seen it continue for another season or two.

I'm ambivalent about the ending of Angel. Going in to Season 5, I had a sense that this was probably the end. I couldn't really see the Wolfram & Hart storyline lasting more than a year. And most of the characters had pretty much run their course by the end of the season. The only things that I think showed promise and might have made Season 6 worth watching would have been Illyria and the Angel/Spike dynamic. Perhaps it's best described by a conversation I recently had with James Marsters at the 2010 Phoenix ComicCon.
Me: "I could have watched Spike & Angel bicker for another 5 years."
James Marsters: "I have kids. I could have watched that for another 15 years."

I would have LOVED to have seen more Arrested Development, but it's one of those rare shows that was so consistently good and funny that if continuing meant a decline in quality then I'm glad it ended when it did. However, if they would have been able to sustain the type of quality they were producing with each episode, it was a true loss for that show to end when it did.

Frankly, I think that Season 3 was already showing signs of deterioration. It was still good but just not nearly as good as Seasons 1 & 2. However, I think that the people who made the show are all still razor-sharp comedians. I'm a huge fan of their most recent series-- Sit Down Shut Up. Sadly, FOX also cancelled that one, replacing it with reruns of Brothers.:wtf:

I was sad when Roswell was cancelled, but in all fairness, I think that the show kinda lost its way and didn't know what to do with itself after Tess left at the end of Season 2. Season 3 was mostly treading water, although that season did provide a few fun episodes ("Secrets & Lies," "Samuel Rising," "A Tale of Two Parties," "I Married an Alien," and the whole "Ch-ch-changes" through "Who Died and Made You King" arc).

I would have been sad that NewsRadio ended except that the 5th season was so bad. It's a show that would have had many more years left in it had Phil Hartman not been murdered.:(

Although I didn't watch it when it was on and only caught up with it through the DVDs years later, I'm really pissed that Odyssey 5 ended on a cliffhanger.

I'm not a huge Firefly fan but it was a fun series that deserved to last longer. (It's just not the 2nd coming the way that a lot of Browncoats would have you believe. And while it did get screwed over by FOX, it didn't get nearly as screwed over as Wonderfalls did.)

I wanted more Veronica Mars, although I didn't like the idea for Season 4 of putting Veronica in the FBI. I didn't mind jumping ahead. I just feel that being in the FBI would be too establishment for Veronica. I would have preferred her taking over her dad's P.I. firm.

It lasted for 20 seasons, so I suppose lamenting its cancellation is in bad taste, but I still miss the original Law & Order. I want more Michael Cutter, dagnabbit! And speaking of that, my favorite Law & Order spin-offs are the 2 that didn't last very long-- Conviction and Law & Order: Trial by Jury.

And does anyone else remember the short-lived FOX series The Jury? I suppose its problem is that it didn't really have a main cast you could latch on to. It was more like a mini-version of 12 Angry Men every week. But what I liked about it was the unique approach that you only saw what the jury saw, which often obscured many of the facts of the case because of bits of evidence that got thrown out. Only at the end of the episode did you get to see the crime in omniscient mode, and the jury was just as often wrong as they were right. Guilty men went free & innocent men were convicted on a regular basis. It was a new twist on exploring the criminal justice system and I would have liked to see more. For that matter, I wish the DVDs were easier to find.
 
I have only 2.

Jericho
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

I feel both of these had more stories to tell when they ended.
Many series like DS9 wrap things up nicely at the end. These 2 really didn't.
 
Babylon 5
Dollhouse
Farscape
Firefly
Roughnecks: Starship Trooper Chronicles
Star Trek: Enterprise
Terminator: The Sarah Conor Chronicles

...at least some of them had adequate conclusions though.
 
Last edited:
The first show I think of when these threads appear: Now and Again.

Complete and utter brilliance that got one season and ended on one hell of a cliffhanger. :scream:

I don't really think of Farscape when these threads show up because although it was superlative and was technically cancelled, I was pretty happy (to say the least) with what we got.
 
5. Dirty Sexy Money - the only non-scifi-ish show on the list. Scifi shows, I'm never really shocked about when they are canceled because they appeal to a niche audience to begin with. But I will never understand why this show did not take off. Brilliant and extremely talented cast, and one of the most bizarre and hilarious storylines ever!

I don't know if it ever "took off" (I never saw the show) but I do know that it was cancelled mainly because it was a super-expensive show to produce.
 
Damn, can't believe I forgot Carnivale. That was a great show

Admiral2
: Yes, Michelle Ryan is quite good in Merlin, but I think she was better in Jekyll (though it was a secondary role) and the Dr Who Special 'Planet of the Dead'.

MLB: No, Gene Hunt is Phillip Glenister. Harvey Keitel was an okay copy. Seriously. Just watch the first ep of either LoM UK or Ashes to Ashes, you'll change your mind.
 
My choices:

  • Firefly
  • My So-Called Life
  • Freaks and Geeks
  • Deadwood

Even though I loved the finale of Angel, I still would have liked to have seen it continue for another season or two.

I'm ambivalent about the ending of Angel. Going in to Season 5, I had a sense that this was probably the end. I couldn't really see the Wolfram & Hart storyline lasting more than a year. And most of the characters had pretty much run their course by the end of the season. The only things that I think showed promise and might have made Season 6 worth watching would have been Illyria and the Angel/Spike dynamic. Perhaps it's best described by a conversation I recently had with James Marsters at the 2010 Phoenix ComicCon.
Me: "I could have watched Spike & Angel bicker for another 5 years."
James Marsters: "I have kids. I could have watched that for another 15 years."
I just finished watching the entire five-year run of Angel for the first time, and I kind of had the same feelings you did regarding the characters. Certainly Gunn, Lorne, and even Wesley were a bit played out (although more of the Wes/Illyria dynamic in S6 might have been good). Have you read the After the Fall comics? Do they do a decent job of picking up from the cliffhanger ending?

Father Ted
If Dermot Morgan hadn't died, yeah. Otherwise, I'm happy with what we got.
 
Angel. I mean, the show got five solid seasons in, but I know the plan was to keep going and not end it like that.

The real pisser was the half-hearted "Thank you for watching for the last 5 years" message we got after the end of the finale. That, to me, was like the WB network collectively kicking us (the fans) while we were down!

Angel for me, as well.
 
Arrested Development is the main one for me, "brilliant" is not a strong enough word to describe it. In fairness to FOX, the ratings were bad and they did give the show an extra season and a half, but I think David Cross' rant summed up that problem well.

Frankly, I think that Season 3 was already showing signs of deterioration. It was still good but just not nearly as good as Seasons 1 & 2.
I don't think the deterioration was the fault of the showrunners, I think it was the fact that they were desperate to keep the show on the air and resorted to various different stunts to attract a new audience, including casting Charlize Theron as Rita. I wasn't a fan of Rita, I think that arc was drawn out and that it only became funny in hindsight, but once she left the show was right back to season 2 levels.

More recently, the way that NBC cancelled Kings pissed me off. That show had tonnes of potential but it was poorly supported, pulled from its timeslot after only a few episodes, then pulled from the air completely for weeks. I only watched the first 5 or 6 episodes, once it became clear that it was going to be cancelled I didn't have the heart to watch any more.

Going back a bit, The Critic. I watched it as a child and forgot about it but I had a chance to rewatch it last year and I was surprised by how good it was. It's like a more intelligent version of Family Guy.

Another painful cancellation for me was Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip--a much better show than "30 Rock."
Studio 60 was a show I was absolutely certain I was going to love, but I dropped out before the end of the season. It had Aaron Sorkin writing it, a lot of the crew from The West Wing moved to the show, it had a great cast, the pilot was fantastic... it seemed like a perfect storm. Unfortunately, the show got caught up with the Matt/Harriet non-relationship and I just couldn't bring myself to give a damn about it any more. It's a pity because I really wanted to love the show.

Father Ted
Father Ted wasn't cancelled, Graham Linehan and Arthur Mathews decided that the third series would be the last as they were writing it, Dermot Morgan's death only pushed the airdate for the final series back a week out of respect. It was always supposed to end with Going to America.
 
Millennium, Twin Peeks, Back to You, Help Me Help You, George and Leo, Firefly, Enterprise, Freaks and Geeks, Wonderfalls.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top