• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Would Thundercats work as a Motion Capture CGI movie?

Moodib

Lieutenant
Red Shirt
I think so and probably the best way to do Thundercats justice on the big screen.

WETA should do it as they have done amazing Mocap/CGI for Avatar, King Kong, Rise of the Apes, the upcoming TinTin, Narnia and others. They can do believable Thundercats as if they were fur and blood.
 
Technologically? Sure it could. But whether a movie works isn't a question of the special effects, it's a question of the script, the direction, the acting, etc. The new Thundercats animated series looks gorgeous and has good music and a mostly good voice cast, but the writing has been inconsistent to the point that I lost interest. If the story and characters don't hold up, it doesn't work, no matter how technically superb it is.

Also it would be important not to try too hard to pander to fan nostalgia, not to be afraid to reinvent things. One of the flaws of the new animated series is that it's too faithful to a lot of the very cheesy, silly, '80s-ish, merchandising-driven aspects of the original cartoon (like the character names and the blatantly toyetic vehicles), and that clashes with the attempt to give it a more sophisticated, Avatar: The Last Airbender-like look and feel. And we've seen with this summer's superhero movies that an adaptation that's overly slavish to the details (like Green Lantern) won't necessarily work as an independent story in its own right, while an adaptation that's free to reinvent things to suit the needs of its own story (like X-Men First Class or Captain America) can be much stronger. Adaptations are meant to adapt, to change the source material into something fresh and new, not merely to copy it. Too many fans don't understand that, and when filmmakers don't understand that, or pander too much to misguided fan pressure, the results often aren't pretty.
 
Personally the Thundercats are NOT human beings as they should not try to replicate real human beings on Mocap and of course Thundercats if done by WETA would not bridge the uncanny valley.

These Thundercats can have the same cat-eyes but not dead ones since WETA has conquered Mocap dead eyes plus have regular teeth instead of plastic like some Mocap movies had.

Maybe this could be as good as the upcoming TinTin movie which wasn't as uncanny valley as people expected from the looks of the new TinTin stills as uncanny valley has been defeated
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top