• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Would Anakin be able to defeat Sidious?

As I recall, Anakin did defeat Sidious. He picked him up like a rag doll and tossed him down a ventilation shaft. This assumes that -- at that moment -- Vader went back to being Anakin (which I think is reasonable).

Anakin twice decided the fate of the galaxy by intervening in situations where beings more powerful than himself were fighting and tipping the balance.

He was the difference in preventing Mace Windu overpowering and killing Palpatine, then again he was the difference in preventing Palpatine overpowering and killing Luke. In both instances a hand was lost, in both instances the weaker combatant was being tortured and in both instances the would be victor falls to a presumed death. Crucially in both instances he is faced with a clear choice of where his loyalties and his conscience lie.

That's no coincidence.
 
No way. Yoda couldn't defeat Sidious and he was the best swordsman of all the Jedi.
Yoda was a miserable little green failure in almost every way imaginable. All of his powers did not allow him to see what was plain before him, and apparently at 900 years, he had ample time to undercover the machinations of the Sith. He could have listened to others like Qui Gon but he waited until it was too late, and this lack of leadership must have certainly spread like a cancer among the other moribund masters. It is easy to see a living force rejecting that dead wood in favor or some new form of balance, the harbinger of a new order.

Rather than take Anakin under his tutelage, realizing the danger of either letting him go or letting an inexperienced new knight like Obi Wan train him, he opted for the latter. He got embroiled in republic politics, despite whatever moral code he espoused, perfectly willing to use sentient clones like cannon fodder (how is he any different from Palpy, in that regard?) His continual blunders may have helped cost billions, even trillions of lives. That he failed in his last ditch fight with Palpatine is just a cherry on the top of a sundae of loss. Of course by then he could only instill upon Luke a certain amount of training, leaving him ill prepared to teach students of his own, which is obvious by the fact that Luke nearly murdered one of them.
,
 
Yoda was a miserable little green failure in almost every way imaginable. All of his powers did not allow him to see what was plain before him, and apparently at 900 years, he had ample time to undercover the machinations of the Sith. He could have listened to others like Qui Gon but he waited until it was too late, and this lack of leadership must have certainly spread like a cancer among the other moribund masters. It is easy to see a living force rejecting that dead wood in favor or some new form of balance, the harbinger of a new order.

Rather than take Anakin under his tutelage, realizing the danger of either letting him go or letting an inexperienced new knight like Obi Wan train him, he opted for the latter. He got embroiled in republic politics, despite whatever moral code he espoused, perfectly willing to use sentient clones like cannon fodder (how is he any different from Palpy, in that regard?) His continual blunders may have helped cost billions, even trillions of lives. That he failed in his last ditch fight with Palpatine is just a cherry on the top of a sundae of loss. Of course by then he could only instill upon Luke a certain amount of training, leaving him ill prepared to teach students of his own, which is obvious by the fact that Luke nearly murdered one of them.
,
And this is why the Jedi returning sits more and more uncomfortable with me. The Jedi haven't demonstrated anything to necessitate their return or their return being a good thing.
 
And this is why the Jedi returning sits more and more uncomfortable with me. The Jedi haven't demonstrated anything to necessitate their return or their return being a good thing.
One of the things that struck me deeply from the PT is that the Jedi, whatever good they once accomplished have become a kind of corrupt self-appointed shadow government, with powers of judge, jury, executioner all wrapped up in a brown cloak of diplomatic immunity. And yet despite these extraordinary powers given to them by a representative government for MILLENNIA, they have shown no interest whatsoever in improving the lives of persons oppressed in the outer rim. Instead they simply plunk their asses down on their couches atop their zigurrat in the most choicest real estate on the navel of the Galaxy. They really did do it to themselves,
 
One of the things that struck me deeply from the PT is that the Jedi, whatever good they once accomplished have become a kind of corrupt self-appointed shadow government, with powers of judge, jury, executioner all wrapped up in a brown cloak of diplomatic immunity. And yet despite these extraordinary powers given to them by a representative government for MILLENNIA, they have shown no interest whatsoever in improving the lives of persons oppressed in the outer rim. Instead they simply plunk their asses down on their couches atop their zigurrat in the most choicest real estate on the navel of the Galaxy. They really did do it to themselves,
That's been my growing feeling as well, which is super frustrating to go from the OT to the PT and see that Jedi didn't do a whole heck of a lot in terms of recent history. Those 1000 years seemed to be erased pretty quickly, which makes whatever good the Jedi did seem rather vapid.

Despite myself wanting the Jedi to be those good guys that can make things right the PT doesn't inspire any reasons to celebrate their return. Unfortunately.
 
I think it was also a big mistake to have a grand master for live.
Anakin should have had a expierenced master, like maybe Windu or other council master
 
Remember, the Council was granting Qui-Gon's dying request that Obi-wan train Anakin. Yoda disagreed with the idea, but was overruled.

Yoda did attempt to help Anakin's path, both by offering him counciling, (though Anakin never opened up to Yoda like he would to Palpatine), and by giving him an apprentice, Ahsoka, to teach him responsibility and learn that someday he would have to let her go. but Anakin still had trouble letting go when the time came. Plus by then Palpatine was working overtime to set the Jedi up in a bad light for Anakin and the Republic in general, while leaving his hands clean.
 
XXHEEpG.jpg

OTp3COs.jpg

dY58kZ9.jpg

ZhrEwjQ.jpg

EqRNXmf.jpg
 
Eventually yes.

Had he not lost so much of his body, and his connection to the force been weakened, he would have outclassed Palpatine and been at least doubly strong as him.
 
The more important question: if Anakin kills Sidious, does that make Anakin a Mary Sue?
 
To go back to the original question, I think he probably could have in a one on one lightsaber duel. The only times we saw him fight was against Mace and the other Masters, and against Yoda. In the fight with Mace and the other Masters, he only killed other Masters because he caught them off guard and Mace pretty much had him until Anakin showed up. He put up a pretty good fight against Yoda, but I'm not really sure how Yoda's lightsaber skills compare to people like Mace or even Anakin. I always got the impression he was known more for his wisdom than his fighting skills.
 
How's he not perfect? He's the most powerful, has the hot babe, is the best pilot...
He has attitude issues. Plus he has made a few mistakes. also, shouldn’t it be Mary Poppins and not Mary Sue? She was the one that was perfect in every way.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top