• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Working my way through the series, again

Roboturner913

Commander
Red Shirt
DS9 is my favorite TV series ever. I missed season 1 and about half of season 2 during the original run, I guess because I was 14 when the show started and didn't have much of an attention span. Caught all of the episodes (except for just a couple) on Spike a few years back and catch a random episode on a local TV station from time to time. Anyway, I let my wife know exactly what I wanted from Santa this year and she (oops, i mean he) delivered with all seven season box sets!

I pretty much tore through the first and second seasons in two weeks and I'm in the middle of season 3 right now. I know, I need to pace myself.

Anyway, thoughts so far:

1. I'm surprised at how good the early episodes truly are. I always hear people say how the show didn't pick up steam until season 3 and 4, but I enjoyed many episodes in the first two seasons immensely. Yes, there are some clunkers (The Storyteller sticks out as being particularly awful) but overall the series is solid, complex and thoughtful even this early on.

2. I dearly love Avery Brooks and the character of Sisko, but he is so lost early on. I don't really think he understood the character. Lots of strange mannerisms and facial expressions that struck me as silly in moments that shouldn't have been. His little "head tilt and chuckle" maneuver seemed like a go-to when he didn't know how the character was supposed to react.
I think he may have finally figured it out early in season 2 with the Circle episodes. I really enjoyed that story. Sisko seemed much more at ease with himself by then.

3. It's funny how long it took them to develop the lesser characters. Even midway through season 3, Garak, Quark, Rom and especially Dukat haven't been explored very much. Even Jake is used very sparingly. It strikes me as amazing that the writers were able to up the ante in later seasons with the war arc and still find time to establish such a great group of peripheral characters.

4. Again, so many underrated episodes in the early seasons. How freaking good was Progress? Awesome acting in that one. "Dramatis Personnae" - great change of pace. Sisko's role was great there. Great moral dilemmas in both "Cardassians" and "Sanctuary". And great character studies in "The Wire", "Blood Oath", "Duet", etc.

Of course, I know how everything ends. There's not quite the suspense of waiting until 10:30 the next Sunday night, but I'm happy to say that the show has lost none of its appeal since it ended. It may even be more socially relevant than it was when it first aired. You have to appreciate everyone involved for making such an enduring quality program.
 
overall the series is solid, complex and thoughtful even this early on.

I think that's a fair assessment. The sci-fi action/adventure side of things doesn't get going until seasons 3 and 4, but the show has a lot to offer from early on as far as themes and characters are concerned.

I dearly love Avery Brooks and the character of Sisko, but he is so lost early on.

The writers also did not give him much to work with after the pilot for whatever reason. Avery Brooks just seemed bored in the early going. It's really in season 3 that Sisko becomes a great character imo.

Again, so many underrated episodes in the early seasons. How freaking good was Progress? Awesome acting in that one. "Dramatis Personnae" - great change of pace. Sisko's role was great there. Great moral dilemmas in both "Cardassians" and "Sanctuary". And great character studies in "The Wire", "Blood Oath", "Duet", etc.

You'll get some debate on the quality of some of those eps, particularly Sanctuary, but you list quite a few of early classics. I'm a big fan of Progress, Cardassians, The Wire, Blood Oath and Duet in particular among those you mention.

It may even be more socially relevant than it was when it first aired. You have to appreciate everyone involved for making such an enduring quality program.

Yep :techman:
 
I felt Sisko really came into his own in Season 3. He became a more dynamic character and they started to explore the Emissary idea more. Plus, of course, he finally got a romance.
 
It's only S1 where you have to struggle to find decent episodes. S2 onwards, there's plenty of great stuff.

The series is complex from the start, what with all the Prophets/timeshifting/hallucinations/whatever stuff in the pilot, and the Feds having to deal with some angry Bajoran chick right off the bat. And Dukat may not have been explored fully till later on, but Alaimo gave him a fully complex performance from the very first.
 
You'll get some debate on the quality of some of those eps, particularly Sanctuary, but you list quite a few of early classics. I'm a big fan of Progress, Cardassians, The Wire, Blood Oath and Duet in particular among those you mention.

Oh, don't get me wrong. Sanctuary wasn't great by any means. I would say in the grand scheme of things it was a below-average episode. But you have to appreciate the questions it asks when it comes to topics like immigration and the welfare state. Those are things we struggle to answer now. It's a nice allegory.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top