• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Wish World grade and discussion thread

How do you rate Wish World?


  • Total voters
    26
Omega's Ergons. Boney and birdy
hMqBsU3.png

Is that a hatchet or a fez on its head? Either way it's cool, but make no bones about it, that's got to be a tie-in to the walking dino skeleton image as another botched Rani experiment because of course it is. Also, that costume is pure-dee-gross, but is in a likely better story - which isn't saying too much depending on the scene.
 
Omega's Ergons. Boney and birdy
hMqBsU3.png
Looks a bit like a "Power Rangers" or "Ultraman" adversary!

A bit more seriously, does anyone think the designer was inspired by HR Giger, trying to emulate elements like bone-like exoskeletal surfaces and striated/pleated soft tissues?
 
Looks a bit like a "Power Rangers" or "Ultraman" adversary!

A bit more seriously, does anyone think the designer was inspired by HR Giger, trying to emulate elements like bone-like exoskeletal surfaces and striated/pleated soft tissues?
HR Giger is the Daddy of alien design now. Pun intended.
I saw touches of AT-AT walker in the patrols too.

I shall refrain from further comments until I've seen the rest of the story after next weekend.
 
Looks a bit like a "Power Rangers" or "Ultraman" adversary!

A bit more seriously, does anyone think the designer was inspired by HR Giger, trying to emulate elements like bone-like exoskeletal surfaces and striated/pleated soft tissues?

It was 1982/3 so very much so. Unfortunately they landed on chicken. The biomechanoid in 87 and Dragonfire was a bit more successful.
 
What a bunch of tosh. I wish I gave a flying fuck about the lore of Doctor Who. Oh, my, "Omega", wow...

I've said it before but I can't wait for some showrunner who only knows Who from the new series. Either that or they run out of old series things to reference and explain.

On the positive side, um, Rani has a nice sonic. I don't know, even at its worst I've liked some elements of Who even in at its low points but this season has really lost me. I am glad others have been enjoying it but I just don't "get" the show anymore. I know, I know, just stop watching but it's hard when I have enjoyed it so much in the past, I'd love to reconnect with it.
 
What a bunch of tosh. I wish I gave a flying fuck about the lore of Doctor Who. Oh, my, "Omega", wow...

I've said it before but I can't wait for some showrunner who only knows Who from the new series. Either that or they run out of old series things to reference and explain.
I get where you're coming from with that, but Daleks, Cybermen, the Master, the Great Intelligence, Davros, Rassilon, Sontarans, Silurians, Sea Devils, Ice Warriors, Zygons, Autons and so on are all from the classic series, so reintroducing old enemies is what the modern series does. It's the new viewer who gets reintroduced to the Slitheen and the Abzorbaloff in 20 years time that I feel sorry for!

Anyway, my current opinion about Wish World is that... it has its heart in the right place. We've come a long way from the series I used to enjoy though and I'm about ready to finally give up on it.
 
Is that a hatchet or a fez on its head?
Looks like a brain stuck inside a crest. Could be worse, a brain in a ball on a string ;)
A bit more seriously, does anyone think the designer was inspired by HR Giger, trying to emulate elements like bone-like exoskeletal surfaces and striated/pleated soft tissues?
Here's another Giger inspired design, Omega's helmet
aAyopqd.jpg
I assume it's meant to be solid, but you can see the actor squish in the sides in a scene where he grabs his head. Though the squishyness makes it a tad more creepy. :lol:
 
Personally, I'm beyond thrilled that RTD is mining the classic lore beyond simply the Daleks, the Cybermen and The Master. Maybe that belongs in the controversial opinion thread, but here we are. :shrug:
 
So let me guess, Poppy will turn out to be
Susan’s mother?
I'm not convinced that line of dialogue should be taken so literally.

The Doctor says "I have a daughter. She's real! Do you know what means?" What he doesn't say is "She's mine." Just that she is real.

Recall, Poppy isn't from present day Earth, but space in the future. How the heck is she even ON Earth to be repurposed as the Doctor's false kid?

I think the Rani screwed up. She used the vindicator web to power her experiment. But I think Desiderium's reality altering power is leaking back along the web, rather than staying localized to Earth. Which means if the Rani breaks reality looking for Omega, she's not just destroying Earth but the entire universe across all space and time. Oops.
 
Popular, long running, stories of any flavour — whether it be SF or Soap Opera — will always mine their past as part of their appeal. That can be done well, or it can be done poorly. X-Men was at the height of its popularity while having little notes telling you events were being referenced from twenty years back in its pages, whereas Eastenders has turned into weird thing where most of the cast are returned characters from decades back. For two examples. (Revealing Eastenders is in fact a Matrix simulation of Earth on Gallifrey would be the best way to end that show, given its odd Who links…)

Whilst there’s the argument that it’s unfair to expect a viewer to jump in and deal with a show that has a past (like some kind of weird virginal TV show is required, where everything to know is right in front of you…) and it has some weight, at the same time viewers have been doing *exactly that* for Decades. All the people who do enjoy continuity aren’t seventy year old British folk, who have been watching since sixty-three.

It’s one of the reasons why Who fandom is to a decent extent gatekeeper free — you’re more likely to find even the grumpiest current-iteration-disliking-fans are more likely to be inviting newer people to experience the old stories, than telling them to go away and find something else.
Which, with everything on iPlayer, and reams of info everywhere these days, is exactly what the show itself is doing when it sticks in the Rani, or Omega, or Susan.

The important thing for the show is — don’t get it wrong when you do that. Otherwise you accidentally look worse than something shot on a comparative shoestring in the nineteen seventies, and your high-salaried glossy superstar might look less compelling than a Liverpudlian Builder, or a Scotsman who used to put live animals down his trousers.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top