Why can't Rockstar create Star Trek game for PS3?
- Thread starter steveda19
- Start date
I don't think their style is a good fit for Trek. I'd be down for Bioware, Obsidian, or Telltale doing their own take on it. Even though all 3 are just as incredibly unlikely.
Heck, the new Star Trek Timelines by Disruptor Beam sounds promising to me... at least on paper.
Heck, the new Star Trek Timelines by Disruptor Beam sounds promising to me... at least on paper.
They don't have the licensing, most likely.
Also Rockstar have in many ways become bigger than the license. They already hold the license to the thing they do best, why pay someone else to for theirs? If they were going to do a game set in space/the future, they'd probably generate their own IP.
Your best hope is for a smaller developer to be hired by the licence holder (Paramount) to make an open-world Star Trek game- but this effectively has happened, and that game is Star Trek Online. Get to it.
Your best hope is for a smaller developer to be hired by the licence holder (Paramount) to make an open-world Star Trek game- but this effectively has happened, and that game is Star Trek Online. Get to it.
But Star Trek Online blows.
^By how much?
Now I have visions of stealing a Defiant-class, changing the station to Klingon rock, and then flying around shooting pulse phasers at every ship I see until a six-star warning level sees hero ships trying to blow me up.
This. Licenses are expensive, and I doubt there will be a new Trek game for a long time after what happened to the last one. If I were the license holder, I'd be very reluctant to hand it over.
I think CBS needs to hand it over to someone that knows how to make video games people want to play. Either Rockstar or BioWare would be good choices.
Bioware would have been great- and I think they considered making a Star Trek game in the day, but ultimately realized they would rather make their own IP (Mass Effect, which is basically a Star Trek game) rather than pay to be tied to the existing one. Which is a huge disappointment, but I'm glad we have both Star Trek and ME.
The problem with the Trek franchise will always be getting the balance between combat and non-combat right. Games tend to focus on fighting but often - as with STO when it started - to the exclusion of every other method of problem solving.
I think the best Trek game to date is Away Team - you were forced to use stealth in some missions and had to minimise unnecessary casualties on a few missions. Some just couldn't be beaten by simply pew-pewing through them (Borg cube infiltration to rescue crew).
BTW does Away Team work on Win8? Thinking of tracking down a copy to replay it but not if it won't work on newer systems.
I think the best Trek game to date is Away Team - you were forced to use stealth in some missions and had to minimise unnecessary casualties on a few missions. Some just couldn't be beaten by simply pew-pewing through them (Borg cube infiltration to rescue crew).
BTW does Away Team work on Win8? Thinking of tracking down a copy to replay it but not if it won't work on newer systems.
I never played Away Team but you make it sound cool, I should check it out.
Between the two, Bioware would be the better one. Destructor is right. With the success of KOTOR, I think they started looking at the possibility of making a Star Trek game. I remember hearing some news about that, but that the plans fell through, and in the end, ended up making what we know as Mass Effect. Personally, I think that ended up being better for Bioware, as they had full control of their own property and weren't saddled with restrictions on what they could or couldn't do.
Personally, I don't think Rockstar would have been a great fit. As Jim Gamma points out the balance between combat and non-combat, they've always been known for their violent games and their ideology behind their game design wouldn't sit well with the Trek franchise.
I'd much prefer open-world in the sense of the Elder Scrolls games, playing as an officer in first-person and getting assigned to away-teams on different planets while completing tasks. Sort of like a combination of the gameplay from 25th Anniversary and Elder Scrolls RPGs, and with the choice of being diplomatic in certain situations.
Similar threads
