Who would win in a Fight? Shatner or Pine?

[chi]

On another forum, one guy said that Chris Pine wasn't tuff enough or macho. He was more like a college kid with a heat seeking missile between his legs. This made me wonder, who is more of a tuff guy? A younger Shatner from TOS or Chris Pine from Star Trek XI? I'm not talking about Kirk, I'm talking about the actors themselves.

 

[ed629]

We only saw Shatner\Kirk from his early 30's until his death at 60. We saw Pine\Kirk in his early 20's and growing up without his father.... Shatner\Kirk in his 30's held up longer against Spock (Immunity Syndrome) than Pine\Kirk in his 20's.

And who is the same person in their 30's as they are in their 20's? We're talking a 10 year difference in Kirk's life growing in a totally different environment.

 

[Herkimer Jitty]

If they were fighting on a platform over an abyss, Pine would find himself hanging onto the ledge by nothing but his fingers while the Shat kicks him repeadetly saying "I. HAVE HAD. ENOGUH. OF YOU!"

It'd be like an unstoppable force hitting an immovable object over and over.

 

[T'Paul]

Shatner is old as shit these days. Pine in the 1st round.

 

[tauzo]

We only saw Shatner\Kirk from his early 30's until his death at 60. We saw Pine\Kirk in his early 20's and growing up without his father.... Shatner\Kirk in his 30's held up longer against Spock (Immunity Syndrome) than Pine\Kirk in his 20's.

And who is the same person in their 30's as they are in their 20's? We're talking a 10 year difference in Kirk's life growing in a totally different environment.

He can keep from going over the cliff/ledge/platform better than anyone, but Mr Pine didn't seem to fare too well in the mano a mano. Shat was a brawler through and through.

Celebrity Deathmatch anyone?

 

[Penhall99]

Shatner is old as shit these days. Pine in the 1st round.

The topic said YOUNG Shatner....

Anyway, I dont know why people have to make it a competition between these two guys.

Having said that....SHATNER!!!!!!!

 

[Alexis]

Pine would best the Shat in a man-to-man fist-fight, but other than that, were it a fight of any other kind, Shatner would kick the living daylights out of Pine any day.

 

[RoJoHen]

Perhaps one day Pine could win, but not yet. That kid's got a lot to learn.

Shatner all the way.