• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Who looks more like Chris reeve?

Who looks more like Chris reeve?

  • Brandon Routh

    Votes: 25 96.2%
  • Tom Welling

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Henry cavill

    Votes: 1 3.8%
  • Tyler Hoechlin

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    26
They could've built the DCCU around his Supes.

Tone might have started off a bit lighter, but they could still have gone wherever they wanted...
 
Last edited:
brandon-routh-christopher-reeve.jpg
 
I like Routh in nearly everything I've seen him in, but his performance as Superman just never struck me as quite right and I don't see the resemblance nearly as much as many others. His costume emphasized a sleek and youthful build that made him feel even younger than he was and the film itself was thematically questionable, especially when trying to reboot the most iconic superhero of all time.

That said, I don't see any more of Reeve in him than I do in Cavill. Reeve's square jaw and narrow, delicate features are distinctly different from any other actor to play the part.
 
Routh looks about as much like Reeve as Quinto does Nimoy. That is to say, not nearly as much as "they" claim he does.

That said, he's closer than the others. If nothing else, the other three have not played a Reeve-style Clark, Routh has.
 
Brandon Routh 100%. but it was his performance moreso than his looks that pulled it off. SR had its flaws but it should have been the movie to carry on the franchise. Remember everybody complaining about his son? A sequel would have still been ahead of today's comic plot by seven or eight years.
 
They could've built the DCCU around his Supes.

Tone might have started off a bit lighter, but they could still have gone wherever they wanted...

Yup. With his Superman and Bale's Batman, DC would be a lot closer to where they currently want to be. in terms of world building. Maybe they would have put more work into GL, or, after it failed, they could have juts done the fall of the Corp and introduced Kyle Raynor.
 
I really liked Routh in the role. I wish they had let him be his own man, though, rather than carry on the awkward clumsiness that Reeve captured so perfectly in his movies. I think they tried a little TOO hard to make SR a sequel to the original movies. Routh has shown he has some fine chops when it comes to acting and I think they should have let him make the part his own. Cavill's Clark Kent is refreshing in that it's not a carbon copy of what came before him. I think in many ways, his Kent is more like the Kent we see in the comics. Or at least the Kent I remember from the comics. It's been years since I read SM.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top