Who is the worst character in all of Star Trek main cast?
- Thread starter Danoz
- Start date
You missed one I would have voted for: Ensign Ro.
About as regular as Pulaski.
I missed the initial post, so I voted "all good". Because they are all very good characters.
But considering writing, it's a no-brainer: the absolute worst writing was for Wesley Crusher.
But considering writing, it's a no-brainer: the absolute worst writing was for Wesley Crusher.
Ack I knew I was going to miss one (I was going by memory). I don't know how anybody could choose Ro, though
.Anyway I voted for Chakotay for the stale acting and poor character development... and "The Fight." At least with Wesley Crusher the acting was pretty much there and there was lot of character development (as annoying a little bastard as he was in the first episodes).
Rom, just an annoying character who made any scene he was in that much more unbearable.
No ENT? Archer and T'Pol would be my top two, not sure who would "win."
So I voted for Neelix. But like most of the bad characters, he was also unimportant. I'd rather vote for a character who really helped screw up a show.
So I voted for Neelix. But like most of the bad characters, he was also unimportant. I'd rather vote for a character who really helped screw up a show.
I voted Seven. Star Trek + sex appeal very rarely works out into a good, enjoyable character.
Agreed. That's who I voted for. Runners-up are, IMO, Rand, Neelix, Kim, and Mayweather.
-- RR
Well, there were a few characters I thought were kind of boring, but the only one that actually bothered me was Wesley Crusher (that's right -- I don't mind Neelix. Go ahead, do your worst ).
Oh yeah, and leaving aside the obvious error of the Enterprise-omission, why are Garak, Rom, Nog, Dukat, and Weyoun on the list? They were recurring characters, not regulars. I could understand if you wanted to include recurring characters, but why limit it to these ones? Why not include Guinan, Ro, Winn, Damar, Martok, Seska, etc.? Not trying to criticize, I just don't really get it.
).Oh yeah, and leaving aside the obvious error of the Enterprise-omission, why are Garak, Rom, Nog, Dukat, and Weyoun on the list? They were recurring characters, not regulars. I could understand if you wanted to include recurring characters, but why limit it to these ones? Why not include Guinan, Ro, Winn, Damar, Martok, Seska, etc.? Not trying to criticize, I just don't really get it.
I voted Kes, a great actress, a poor character.
Well, there were a few characters I thought were kind of boring, but the only one that actually bothered me was Wesley Crusher (that's right -- I don't mind Neelix. Go ahead, do your worst
Oh yeah, and leaving aside the obvious error of the Enterprise-omission, why are Garak, Rom, Nog, Dukat, and Weyoun on the list? They were recurring characters, not regulars. I could understand if you wanted to include recurring characters, but why limit it to these ones? Why not include Guinan, Ro, Winn, Damar, Martok, Seska, etc.? Not trying to criticize, I just don't really get it.
Haha, no like I said I screwed up the poll because I was going by memory... I should have used memory-alpha or something.
Just ask the mod to close this one, do another one, include Enterprise, and try to spell the names right.Well, there were a few characters I thought were kind of boring, but the only one that actually bothered me was Wesley Crusher (that's right -- I don't mind Neelix. Go ahead, do your worst
Oh yeah, and leaving aside the obvious error of the Enterprise-omission, why are Garak, Rom, Nog, Dukat, and Weyoun on the list? They were recurring characters, not regulars. I could understand if you wanted to include recurring characters, but why limit it to these ones? Why not include Guinan, Ro, Winn, Damar, Martok, Seska, etc.? Not trying to criticize, I just don't really get it.
Haha, no like I said I screwed up the poll because I was going by memory... I should have used memory-alpha or something.
Your mileage may vary. As far as I am concerned, it works out for Spock, Kira, Dukat, Sarek, Ro Laren, K'Ehleyr, Picard, Data (I'd rather describe it as lovable cuteness, but many girls find him hot), Damar, and I would argue, maybe even Jadzia Dax, among others. But then anyone can disagree with both who they consider a good character, and who they find sexy. Quite a few people find Seven an interesting character.
Harry Kim. He lacked personality, yet was always around and seen as very important. While I agree Neelix was annoying, I think he did have his moments and was sometimes redeemed by Ethan Phillips's acting. As for Wesley, well he was rubbish too, but he was a bit better once he became a recurring character.
There's a difference between an attractive character and a character designed to boost ratings with their chest. For example, Saavik was an attractive character, but she wasn't really sexy, per se.
