• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Who is the scariest Star Trek villian?

Who is the scariest villian?


  • Total voters
    52
The Borg - early TNG version.

I'd say Borg, so long as we stick to pre-Deus Ex Machina TNG (so right up to and including BOBW part 1.)

But I think the Romulans in TNG, although they were one-note like the Klingons, were intringuing and menacing because of their shady activities.

Also props for Dukat. He and his actor both have a commanding presence.
 
Groups
Q Continuum
The Borg
The Dominion
Species 8472
Vidiians
"Schism" aliens
"Silent Enemy" aliens
Pagh Wraiths
The Xindi

Individuals
Founder Leader
Khan
Gul Dukat
Gul Madred
Lore
 
TOS:
Khan (original Khan)

TNG:
Klingons
Those Bug things in "Conspiracy"
The Borg

DS9:
The Dominion

Voy:
The Vidiians
 
While not "evil" per se, rather so desperate that they've lost all perspective, but the Vidiians are uber creepy. Although similar to the Borg in that they're going to USE you, somehow losing you individuality is a few degrees less scary than knowing you're about to be dissected and your organs harvested.
 
You know, at first I saw "The Holodeck" and started to chuckle, but then I thought more about it and no matter how much the rest of the villains on that list get dumbed down over and over till they are nothing more than a minor annoyance.. On the other hand the holodeck proved to be a foe they could never fully dumb down, even until the last season of DS9 (they) held crew members in the grip of peril on at least a season by season basis since the early days of TNG.. And we all know that no matter how much holotechnology evolves it will probably always be able to be zapped by some plasma storm, power overload, emerging AI, so on and so on. Just the sheer amount of what seemed like insignificant things that could suddenly cause the holodeck safetys to vanish like clothes at a betazoid wedding and the characters to all suddenly turn to homicidal maniacs.

Truly such longevity of unstoppable threat must make them, the holodecks, the greatest ST villains ever!


And to those who say Q.. Remember he is the savior of the Federation* after all, and the one who truly brought Picard's abilities as a Captain and a human being to heights above and beyond any that he would have achieved with out him.

*You know, since they conveniently forgot about the Borg coming
 
I'd definitely say the TNG Borg tied with the Vidiians. On an individual level, I'd say Gul Dukat, simply because of his body count...

Section 31 is also pretty damn scary.
 
Last edited:
Admiral Cartwright and Admiral Marcus.

That the end of the world will come not because we have soldiers who think they're doing evil but because they think pushing the big red button will be our salvation from darkness.
 
Admiral Cartwright and Admiral Marcus.

That the end of the world will come not because we have soldiers who think they're doing evil but because they think pushing the big red button will be our salvation from darkness.

Don't forget Admiral Leyton from Homefront/Paradise Lost. :techman:
 
The Vidiians brought a level of visceral body horror that I hadn't seen before in Trek, so I vote for them.

Not really a villain at all, but how about Kevin Uxbridge? One stray thought, and an entire species is wiped out. That's got to be the record for mass murder in Trek.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top