• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Who had the worst romance subplot

Who had the worst romance subplot?


  • Total voters
    73
I don't like Beltran, not even a little. But to say he's "aged badly" is just fucking stupid. The guy still probably looks younger than 90% of all the 60 year old men on the planet. :rolleyes:

My apologies to you...I meant no offense...I enjoy your posts, and look forward to more of them... :)
 
This is not really a "romance" but the subplot of T'Pol's marriage to Kos, I always found hateful. He's following tradition, the Vulcan way of life and finds he's in an arranged marriage with someone who happens to look a hell of a lot like Jolene Blalock - how isn't he going to fall for her? Loving T'Pol is easy for him, because she's beautiful and he's understandably reluctant to cut her loose. Especially when everybody else on Vulcan is saying, "this is the way we roll." And when you have got The Brass to try to get out of it, you just might find yourself fighting to the death ... out of tradition, if nothing else. It's a screwed up situation, however you want to look at it. And yes, Kos could find a piece of fluff on the side. I don't know ... maybe it's just because T'Pol is so beautiful. But whatever the reason, yeah, I kind of feel sorry for the guy. Maybe in the 24th Century, Vulcans eventually re-examined the whole "arranged marriage" thing and finally admitted to themselves and to eachother that, you know what? It's just not Logical.
 
I wonder if the arranged marriages was mostly for upper class families or familes with status like Sarek's family, who married a princess of some sort first before Amanda Grayson. And then Spock's wedding has one of the most important people on Vulcan attending (T'Pau of all people, probably with Surak's katra still inside).
 
I think the showrunners likely thought that Seven had to be shown as being nearing the end of her individuation process as they were approaching home. Rather than doing this by having her raucously join in on karaoke night on the holodeck or becoming B'Elanna's parrises squares playing best buddy, they chose to emphasize a conventional marker, pursuing romance.

Now, I'm of the opinion that Seven's choice of object didn't really come out of left field. I have the sense that Chakotay made a, well maybe not positive, but firm impression on her going all the way back to Scorpion II, in the cargo bay and the conference room a little later on. Here was someone that was forceful, straightforward, and understood how the alliance would play out from the Borg's perspective a bit more realistically than his CO. Not that Seven appreciated that perspective at the time, of course.

But I think that a resonance of the early encounters may very well have remained with her as time went on. He was solid, substantial, with a strong cast of mind, and, perhaps in line with tropes present in the socialization holo-programs the Doctor was feeding her, he had the requisite dark, hunky good looks. Most importantly, she didn't have the opportunity to have her view of any of these positive attributes dispelled by virtue of never being in the ready room during those tense situation when Janeway made short work of her hero. :techman: Also, who knows what subconscious bond was indelibly forged when they were linked at the end of Scorpion. While left unremarked upon, such an impact may have loomed large down the road.

When it came time to punch her "fully human" ticket by forming a significant attachment, who else could have fit the bill? Okay, okay I know, Harren is the obvious answer. But I just dont think Seven could have maintained respect for him after pointing out that he was going down the wrong track with his cosmological noodlings. The Doctor? Huh. Every now and then I have to get my fill of seeing Seven's expression when he's down on his knee, pouring his heart out in Renaissance Man. Might very well be my favorite screen capture of her face of the entire series, and it says it all!!! :lol:
 
^ But in the season 5 episode "Someone to Watch Over Me", Chakotay isn't even one of the people Seven selected as a potential companion. Curse you continuity! You are VOY worst enemy!

How can be THIS the worst romance :) ?



Chuckles looks like Adama in those photos.
tumblr_n7bnkybFwy1ri74e4o1_500.jpg
 
^ But in the season 5 episode "Someone to Watch Over Me", Chakotay isn't even one of the people Seven selected as a potential companion. Curse you continuity! You are VOY worst enemy!

Season 5!!! Oh, come on!!! What did she know then, she was a mere stripling. So many miles yet to travel down the Voyagerway of life. Besides, as I mentioned, there's no telling when the latent jolt, sparks flying from her head remember, of their meld would truly make itself manifest.
Just think of it as Seven's analogous experience to what Teero Anaydis pulled on Tuvok, only in this instance we don't know, nor ever will know, what the trigger was!!!! :rofl:
 
I thought Tom Riker was in a Cardassian jail, likely for life.

He's probably dead, though. Didn't the Cardassians kill all the Maquis?

Back on topic - maybe I'm the only one, but I thought Seven and Chakotay was hot in Human Error (holodeck not withstanding).
 
Last edited:
I was never big on Worf and Troi. Just didn't see a lot of on screen chemistry there. By then I think everybody was getting tired of being jerked around on the whole Riker/Troi relationship. Throwing Worf in there was the death knell for that concept. By the time Riker and Troi were married in Nemesis, noboby really cared about them anymore.

I was glad that Troi and Riker finally got married, but their story was dragged out too long. I was rooting for Tom Riker, out of disgust that Will kept running away from love for so long.
Imzadi II: Triangle did give resolution to Worf and Troi and continued developing Will and Troi.

I thought Tom Riker was in a Cardassian jail, likely for life.

Not in the novels . . . .
 
No one touches my Chakotay! lol

I will go on a side route here and say that in ENT yes i likes Trip and Archer but it was Captain Shran ( damn hot andorian) who stole my heart ! When poor Talas got killed i was soooo mad ! Jhamel wasn't half of Talas lol
 
I've never understood how people can just let their hair go gray/white. I intend to die with my hair the same colour as it is now.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top