I wont even dignify this with a vote.
Which Kirk is more badass?
- Thread starter Enterprise1981
- Start date
Pine Kirk is doubtlessly badass.
Shat Kirk, on the other hand, is BAD…ASSSSSSS…
to the max. And would drop kick Pine Kirk right in the kisser before he ever knew what hit him. It also seems to me that Shat Kirk would have the slight edge on a phaser draw. If set to vaporize, Pine Kirk would be toast.
But probably still too early to know for sure sure about these matters.
Shat Kirk, on the other hand, is BAD…ASSSSSSS…
to the max. And would drop kick Pine Kirk right in the kisser before he ever knew what hit him. It also seems to me that Shat Kirk would have the slight edge on a phaser draw. If set to vaporize, Pine Kirk would be toast.
But probably still too early to know for sure sure about these matters.
The first point is unfair, the second point is puzzling. "Bad ass" is something one admires, finds cool or great. Do you admire people that take unneccessary risks, leap without looking?
The model of badass is Sisko...he's the only one in existence to have socked a Q in the face.
Now back to the original discussion...the Shat Kirk is the higher form of badass...he beat Soran's ass while Picard was getting slapped around like a...well, you know. Pine-Kirk just seems like he gets beat on way too much to be labeled a badass at this point...he is sturdy though, I'll give him that. If he applies Kirk-Fu in the next film, he'll be the new king of Kirk-badassery...but you need the obligatory Kirk-judo-chop and flying Kirk-kick.
Now back to the original discussion...the Shat Kirk is the higher form of badass...he beat Soran's ass while Picard was getting slapped around like a...well, you know. Pine-Kirk just seems like he gets beat on way too much to be labeled a badass at this point...he is sturdy though, I'll give him that. If he applies Kirk-Fu in the next film, he'll be the new king of Kirk-badassery...but you need the obligatory Kirk-judo-chop and flying Kirk-kick.
Shatner had 3 series and a bunch of movies to solidify his personality.
Pine has had 2 movies.
Not a fair vote.
Shatner's Kirk was written as a cowboy in wild, wild space. He could always get the girl and every plan he had worked. He had no dimension at all until there were a couple of movies under his belt. Pine's Kirk automatically has a troubled past and hard decisions to make, and he isn't always confident. His plans don't always work, and he's left trying to pick up the pieces. I like Pine's Kirk better.
Pine has had 2 movies.
Not a fair vote.
Shatner's Kirk was written as a cowboy in wild, wild space. He could always get the girl and every plan he had worked. He had no dimension at all until there were a couple of movies under his belt. Pine's Kirk automatically has a troubled past and hard decisions to make, and he isn't always confident. His plans don't always work, and he's left trying to pick up the pieces. I like Pine's Kirk better.
You know what?
I'm really fucking bored with William Shatner.
Check, please.
I'm really fucking bored with William Shatner.
Check, please.
oldKirk (ca. Season 3 and especially the films). I mean, by then, his ass was really pretty bad to look at.
nuKirk, OTH?
nuKirk, OTH?
The correct answer is Kirk Cameron. Neither Shat nor Pine dabble in banana wizardry, and banana wizardry is the most badass thing since the harpsichord.
[yt]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZhRS51sFiZY[/yt]
Shatner
But pine is coming into his own
Shatkirk would never get visibly winded hitting khan a few times in fact he whipped his ass
And Shatner could pretty much knock anyone out with one punch and a drop kick
But pine is coming into his own
Shatkirk would never get visibly winded hitting khan a few times in fact he whipped his ass
And Shatner could pretty much knock anyone out with one punch and a drop kick
shatner is a legend but i have to go with pine since he is my generations captain kirk 
.
.
You mean, after fighting a bunch of klingons while running for your life to avoid ship-breaking weapons fire ?