What is your opinion of season 3 as a whole?

[Michael]

As much as I liked Firefly and Whedon’s writing, as a series I would take Strange New Worlds over it any day of the week.

 

[Detached Nacelle]

I never understood the love for Firefly personally, I found it bland and forgettable but I can most certainly empathise with those that mourn it. We have all lost cherished shows.

 

[MarcKyle1964]

not to derail further, but yes you are right that he mostly used his mouth to say harmful things which can be even more emotionally painful, but there is no record or accusation of him assaulting women both violently or sexually.

the rumour about whedon been a terrible person has been there for years, more than 15 years but it was Charisma Carpenter open letter or op-ed that did the final damage to the point of no return for Whedon.

that been said his geek tv filmography is nothing short of near excellent. remember he also did Firefly that was very critical acclaimed and is a cult classic. the firefly fandom could have been what star trek become after 1969

now imagine if SNW had the quality of Firefly? we are talking the best of TNG , DS9 and TOS level because that is how acclaimed Firefly was in terms of writing and depth. we cannot even put SNW S1 and S2 there. Firefly was that well received across the board.

At least he didn't do what John K (Ren & Stimpy) was rumored to do.

 

[Firebird]

I liked Firefly better when it was Outlaw Star.