What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy)"?

[Poltargyst]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I'm thinking there are some kind of underlying aspects to Trek and Wars that cause certain personalities to love one and hate the other.

 

[BillJ]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I'm thinking there are some kind of underlying aspects to Trek and Wars that cause certain personalities to love one and hate the other.

I love Star Trek and also find Star Wars massively entertaining. The universe is big enough for both to exist.

 

[martok2112]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I'm thinking there are some kind of underlying aspects to Trek and Wars that cause certain personalities to love one and hate the other.

I love Star Trek and also find Star Wars massively entertaining. The universe is big enough for both to exist.

+1, Amen, So Say Me All, and Bi-La Kaifa!

 

[Greg Cox]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I'm thinking there are some kind of underlying aspects to Trek and Wars that cause certain personalities to love one and hate the other.

I love Star Trek and also find Star Wars massively entertaining. The universe is big enough for both to exist.

Exactly. They're not rival sports teams. You can root for them both.

 

[Nerys Myk]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I'm thinking there are some kind of underlying aspects to Trek and Wars that cause certain personalities to love one and hate the other.

I love Star Trek and also find Star Wars massively entertaining. The universe is big enough for both to exist.

Exactly. They're not rival sports teams. You can root for them both.

What? WHAT? WHAT?

Blasphemy!!!

Guards Seize the unbeliever!

 

[Poltargyst]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I like both too. That's why I said "certain personalities". I don't know if it's the quasi-religious aspects of Star Wars that attract some people to it and those people then hate Trek for not being religious. Or people who love hard science and appreciate Trek for trying to be real science fiction who resent Wars for being a space opera. Something's going on there.

 

[Nerys Myk]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I like both too. That's why I said "certain personalities". I don't know if it's the quasi-religious aspects of Star Wars that attract some people to it and those people then hate Trek for not being religious. Or people who love hard science and appreciate Trek for trying to be real science fiction who resent Wars for being a space opera. Something's going on there.

Star Trek is pure Space Opera. Though there is/was a faction of Hard SF fans who dismissed Trek because it wasn't "hard" enough. All a matter of perspective I guess.

 

[Marsden]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

I'm thinking there are some kind of underlying aspects to Trek and Wars that cause certain personalities to love one and hate the other.

I love Star Trek and also find Star Wars massively entertaining. The universe is big enough for both to exist.

I also agree with BillJ again, well I would change massive to mildly, but I will certainly agree with the sentiment. I certainly have watched both and like both, but I prefer the Treks that I like most.

Ironically, BillJ and are about polar opposites on the 2 new Trek movies. But we agree to disagree. We like what we like and don't what we don't. I don't see any need to tell people that hate those two movies how wrong they are, but I also don't pretend that they aren't "real Star Trek" (whatever the hell that is), either.

 

[Therin of Andor]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

What it was missing was a twenty-minute conference room scene where they explain the entire plot to the audience!

"... the rescue of the Andorian ambassador from the surface of Sylax IV..."

http://www.theonion.com/video/trekkies-bash-new-star-trek-film-as-fun-watchable-14333

 

[F. King Daniel]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

There's a new version of the page back up. "Fred Archer"/"Bob Trekfan" is claiming that the original was taken down by Bad Robot plants.

Of course it was.

 

[fireproof78]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

There's a new version of the page back up. "Fred Archer"/"Bob Trekfan" is claiming that the original was taken down by Bad Robot plants.

Of course it was.

It was you, wasn't it?

Well, I was just hoping it was a phase, but I guess the rebellion continues

 

[F. King Daniel]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

Shhhhh! JJ won't pay me if people find out

 

[BeatleJWOL]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

See if you can drag it out till the Star Wars money starts rolling in ;D

 

[Mudd]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

"Fred Archer" is a fucking moron.

 

[BillJ]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

"Fred Archer" is a fucking moron.

Yup.

 

[Campe]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

"Fred Archer" is a fucking moron.

Yup.

He's Jake on Disqus. He's even more of a fucking moron over there.

And by fucking moron, I mean an apparent 65-year old insider who claims to have been fired from Paramount's legal staff as an attorney following the "epic failure" of Star Trek Into Darkness and now works for Universal. But CBS is producing a series, according to Jake. Yup, it's going to be announced in October now. (For those of you playing at home, it was going to be December 30th, 2014, January 1st, 2015, January 31st, End of Q1, whenever "the Bad Robot mess got cleaned up" and now October.) And one day Star Trek 3 was 99% surely to be cancelled and two days later Paramount and Bad Robot were "arbitrating" the budget.

I don't think arbitration is the right word there.

Have fun!

 

[fireproof78]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

"Fred Archer" is a fucking moron.

Yup.

He's Jake on Disqus. He's even more of a fucking moron over there.

And by fucking moron, I mean an apparent 65-year old insider who claims to have been fired from Paramount's legal staff as an attorney following the "epic failure" of Star Trek Into Darkness and now works for Universal. But CBS is producing a series, according to Jake. Yup, it's going to be announced in October now. (For those of you playing at home, it was going to be December 30th, 2014, January 1st, 2015, January 31st, End of Q1, whenever "the Bad Robot mess got cleaned up" and now October.) And one day Star Trek 3 was 99% surely to be cancelled and two days later Paramount and Bad Robot were "arbitrating" the budget.

I don't think arbitration is the right word there.

Have fun!

What in the world did I just read?

 

[F. King Daniel]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

"Fred Archer" is a fucking moron.

Yup.

He's Jake on Disqus. He's even more of a fucking moron over there.

And by fucking moron, I mean an apparent 65-year old insider who claims to have been fired from Paramount's legal staff as an attorney following the "epic failure" of Star Trek Into Darkness and now works for Universal. But CBS is producing a series, according to Jake. Yup, it's going to be announced in October now. (For those of you playing at home, it was going to be December 30th, 2014, January 1st, 2015, January 31st, End of Q1, whenever "the Bad Robot mess got cleaned up" and now October.) And one day Star Trek 3 was 99% surely to be cancelled and two days later Paramount and Bad Robot were "arbitrating" the budget.

I don't think arbitration is the right word there.

Have fun!

 

[MANT!]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

"Fred Archer" is a fucking moron.

Yup.

He's Jake on Disqus. He's even more of a fucking moron over there.

And by fucking moron, I mean an apparent 65-year old insider who claims to have been fired from Paramount's legal staff as an attorney following the "epic failure" of Star Trek Into Darkness and now works for Universal. But CBS is producing a series, according to Jake. Yup, it's going to be announced in October now. (For those of you playing at home, it was going to be December 30th, 2014, January 1st, 2015, January 31st, End of Q1, whenever "the Bad Robot mess got cleaned up" and now October.) And one day Star Trek 3 was 99% surely to be cancelled and two days later Paramount and Bad Robot were "arbitrating" the budget.

I don't think arbitration is the right word there.

Have fun!

Commander Kor doesn't like this..

 

[Starborn Dragon]

Re: What happened to "Our Star Trek Page (The 2009 Movie Was Blasphemy

If all people were doing were insulting and berating that movie just because their feelings got hurt, especially if they haven't seen the movie, without any valid criticism, then I'm glad that asinine page got shut down.

Wizard's first rule.