Was Majel ever in ST XI? (spoilers)

[Zeppster]

I'm still positive that it's only her during the Chekov scene and the water turbine scene.

All other computer voices sound different.

And I think she's in the scene on the planet and the Jellyfish also. The Kelvin one is the only one that to me sounds nothing like her at all.

 

[Captain Fine]

It would be nice to get a final answer from JJ or someone about this, since clearly Majel herself can't tell us now

 

[Squiggy]

Of note. On Majel Barrett-Roddenberry's page on Memory-Alpha, her Star Trek credit is listed as "Enterprise computer voice".

 

[ST-One]

Of note. On Majel Barrett-Roddenberry's page on Memory-Alpha, her Star Trek credit is listed as "Enterprise computer voice".

Yeah... though her (much more compelling) movie credit lists her as 'Starfleet Computer Voice'.

 

[Squiggy]

Then wouldn't logic dictate that if she was also the computer voice of the Jellyfish and since we never heard any other voice (outside of the other Starfleet ship that we know isn't her) she would just be listed as "Computer Voice"?

 

[Zeppster]

Then wouldn't logic dictate that if she was also the computer voice of the Jellyfish and since we never heard any other voice (outside of the other Starfleet ship that we know isn't her) she would just be listed as "Computer Voice"?

All the computer voices we heard were Starfleet computers. Starfleet helped build the Jellyfish.

 

[Squiggy]

Then wouldn't logic dictate that if she was also the computer voice of the Jellyfish and since we never heard any other voice (outside of the other Starfleet ship that we know isn't her) she would just be listed as "Computer Voice"?

All the computer voices we heard were Starfleet computers. Starfleet helped build the Jellyfish.

And we know she wasn't the voice of the Kelvin, so she didn't even voice all the Starfleet comps.

 

[ST-One]

Then wouldn't logic dictate that if she was also the computer voice of the Jellyfish and since we never heard any other voice (outside of the other Starfleet ship that we know isn't her) she would just be listed as "Computer Voice"?

All the computer voices we heard were Starfleet computers. Starfleet helped build the Jellyfish.

And we know she wasn't the voice of the Kelvin, so she didn't even voice all the Starfleet comps.

Yes, the Kelvin was someone else. But the rest is her.

 

[Squiggy]

So she was the "Starfleet Computer voice" even though she didn't voice all the Starfleet computers? How does that work out?

 

[Squiggy]

So she was the "Starfleet Computer voice" even though she didn't voice all the Starfleet computers? How does that work out?

 

[ST-One]

So she was the "Starfleet Computer voice" even though she didn't voice all the Starfleet computers? How does that work out?

Her's was the voice after the timeline changed...?
I don't know. It's just that the Enterprise, Pod and Jellyfish sound like her to me.

 

[CoveTom]

^ But this is all opinion, because the Jellyfish and pod sound absolutely nothing like her to me.

 

[ST-One]

^ But this is all opinion, because the Jellyfish and pod sound absolutely nothing like her to me.

They do to me.

 

[cooleddie74]

Majel was the computer voice in a couple of scenes, most notably when Kirk is trying to rescue Scotty from the water tubes and turbines in engineering.

 

[Mr. Laser Beam]

Then wouldn't logic dictate that if she was also the computer voice of the Jellyfish and since we never heard any other voice (outside of the other Starfleet ship that we know isn't her) she would just be listed as "Computer Voice"?

All the computer voices we heard were Starfleet computers. Starfleet helped build the Jellyfish.

The Jellyfish was a Vulcan-built ship.

 

[cooleddie74]

Then wouldn't logic dictate that if she was also the computer voice of the Jellyfish and since we never heard any other voice (outside of the other Starfleet ship that we know isn't her) she would just be listed as "Computer Voice"?

All the computer voices we heard were Starfleet computers. Starfleet helped build the Jellyfish.

The Jellyfish was a Vulcan-built ship.

True. Maybe some Starfleet technology was involved in putting it together, but it was an all-Vulcan spacecraft.

 

[MvRojo]

^ But this is all opinion, because the Jellyfish and pod sound absolutely nothing like her to me.

They do to me.

They don't to me either.

I think this is a situation where we'll need some independent confirmation.

 

[James Bond]

Its worth pointing out that when you have a sound man as talaneted as Star Wars and Wall-E's Ben Burtt on board its not a stretch to think that her voice was toned up and augmented a little bit in preperation for the movie....especially if she was ill at the time she recorded it.

Ya but how come she sounds like herself in the Chekov scene then? Why only change the sound of her voice in some of the scenes but not all?

Not to mention, we have an actual NASA sound engineer in this very thread telling us that it is indeed her only on the Enterprise.

 

[Sector 7]

Listen.

Different cadence, different tone, different timbre.

I agree. When I close my eyes and listen to your clips, I hear Majel's voice only when responding to Chekhov. It was nice to hear her voice again.

 

[cooleddie74]

Listen.

Different cadence, different tone, different timbre.

I agree. When I close my eyes and listen to your clips, I hear Majel's voice only when responding to Chekhov. It was nice to hear her voice again.

Maybe they can get a close Majel soundalike to voice the Enterprise and Starfleet computers in the next movie or two.