• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Was Beyond a commentary on how poorly the US govt. treats armed forces veterans?

The argument seems to go that Jaylah achieved incredible things because she got the ship flying when originally the ship wasn't capable of that.
No, it's just a fact of necessity from the plot that Jaylah had moved into the Franklin and was actively repairing it with the intention of eventually leaving the planet; that she was actually pretty close to getting it working, but Scotty, being more familiar with Starfleet technology, filled the gaps in her knowledge.

We are meant to INFER this without having to be spoonfed a heavy-handed "Here's a list of all the things Jaylah repaired and here's a list of everything she didn't." Because Jaylah had found the Franklin, had been living in it for years, had built defenses and camouflage systems around it, and was in the process of trying to get it flight worthy, are all relevant factors here. If we were meant to assume Jaylah hadn't actually done anything to get the process started, she wouldn't have been living in the ship, she would have simply known where the ship was and asked Scotty to fix it.

It is at the conclusion of these considerations that we get to decide whether we should think the Franklin was originally incapable of liftoff, or the opposite.
If it was capable of escape when it first arrived, Edison wouldn't have abandoned it. That, too, is a requirement of the plot: Edison couldn't leave the planet, so he made use of the local technology in order to survive. The theory that the NEBULA was what was keeping him there doesn't really fit, because the nebula would only be a factor once the ship was actually in orbit, which is exactly where Franklin would still have been a hundred years later.

So in the immediate aftermath of the crash, Franklin wasn't going anywhere. The years marched by, rock slides and weather and sediment half buried the ship, and then Jaylah found it and started repairing it. Years later (Five? Ten? Fifteen?) Scotty arrives and finds the repair effort well under way. Jaylah's already patched up the MAJOR damage, so it's just a matter of finishing the job.

And the considerations leave the issue neutral, or at most hanging on the balance of whether Scotty is a polite or an impolite person.
No, it pretty much hangs on whether or not we should choose to interpret a major plot point of Star Trek Beyond in the exact opposite way it was MEANT to be interpreted, for no reason whatsoever.
 
Jaylah's origin is currently being told in the To Boldly Go comic, though I haven't read that issue.

RAMA

I think this is a serious case of putting the cart before the horse, is all.

The argument seems to go that Jaylah achieved incredible things because she got the ship flying when originally the ship wasn't capable of that. But none of that is established in the movie. Nowhere is it stated that the ship would have been incapable of flight, and nowhere is it established that Jaylah was the one to get the ship flying.

So we start from a clean table. And on that table we have Jaylah, who is the child of somebody who flew starships, not an operator or fixer of starships herself. She asks Scotty to fix the ship for her. Beyond that we have Scotty speaking nicely of her vs. herself being childishly ignorant of technology and impressed by the stereo set. That's a case of balancing the evidence, then. And we know how Scotty behaves around women, in at least one timeline ("lass" isn't sexist coming from him, but he has old-fashioned ideas in general).

It's too bad that we can't tell how young Jaylah was when escaping from the clutches of Krall, because the rate of aging for her species is unknown and Krall and Manas are immortal.

It is at the conclusion of these considerations that we get to decide whether we should think the Franklin was originally incapable of liftoff, or the opposite. And the considerations leave the issue neutral, or at most hanging on the balance of whether Scotty is a polite or an impolite person.

Timo Saloniemi
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top