Voyager Face-Off: Tuvok vs. Tom

[Tachyon]

Another Voyager survey - this time it's the face-off of two excellent men. And the question is...


Who do you like better - Tuvok or Tom?


(Or who do you dislike less, if you rather want us to believe that you dislike things about Voyager more than actually like (i.e. still being in the closet with your love of Voyager, even though being on this very forum is actually your quilty pleasure visible to anyone here).)

 

[es!]

Tom is great for comedy in ff, but aside from that he's...well...just a flyboy.

Tuvok is a sore spot of J/Cers (lol) but I like Tim Russ' Vulcan very much. He always managed to steal the show from the others! hehe

 

[Piper]

I think Tom, at least in the first couple of seasons, is a more interesting character than Tuvok so I voted for him, but I can't say either are particular favourites of mine.

 

[voyagerfan]

I like them both so I can't vote

 

[Gorf]

Definitely Tom for me.

 

[KimMH]

Tuvok has the advantage of being twice as old/experienced/interesting as Tom - this may not be a quite fair fight! That said as fun as these polls are; do they encourage some people (who may already have an axe to grind w/ Voy) an opening best left shut?

Last, in Tom's defense he turns into a flyboy who is also a great human being!

 

[TMara]

Tuvie rules!

 

[Gates]

Tuvok

 

[Tachyon]

Ouch. Tuvok is kicking some flyboy's hiny here. Lol.

 

[trilbymonkey]

i prefer Tuvok

 

[kimc]

I like them both but had to vote for Tuvie.

 

[The Sneeze Police]

I liked Tuvok right out of the gate, but Tom grew on me.

 

[Praetor]

I like Tuvok more, but I think Tom was more compellingly written, so I vote Tom.

 

[leola]

I voted Tom, though I like them both. To me, Tuvok didn't change much over the run of the show. Tom was allowed to show more aspects of his personality and changed from Season one to seven. Not sure that really means I like him more, but I thought he was more interesting of the two, so he got my vote.

 

[Tachyon]

I like them both too. Tom is great. But I have a soft spot for Tuvie.

 

[Michael]

I, too, voted Tuvok. Tim Russ was awesome in this role. I don't dislike Tom, but most of the time I really got the feeling his character wasn't flashed out as much as it could have been.

 

[jgdst]

Another vote for Tuvok. I get the impression that Tim Russ gave us the most "Vulcan" Vulcan we've seen, and although he was rarely given the limelight, he did an amazing job in conveying emotions of a character who keeps them very well hidden.

I like Tom, but Tuvok just edges him out.

Also - Tom only had a food fight with Neelix. Tuvok did the sensible thing and strangled him (repeatedly I imagine) in the holodeck. Bonus points for him

 

[Jeyl]

I dislike Tom Paris with a flaming vengeance that can only be matched by a million Ragnaroses. He doesn't have a single redeeming quality that I like and his voice is so cringe worthy. He's not awesome, he's just annoying.

Ya, definitely put me on the Tuvok wagon!

 

[PKTrekGirl]

I voted for Tuvok, although I like both characters very much - at least during the first 4-5 seasons of the show.

I felt that Tuvok was one of the characters whose development suffered most due to B&B's fixation with Seven and the EMH in later seasons. However, I still really love Tuvok. And Tim Russ's portrayal was flawless. IMO, he gave us the best Vulcan in Trek, outside of Nimoy himself.

On the Tom Paris side, I actually prefered him in the earlier seaons, when he still had some rebel in him. He was not as interesting once he'd been domesticated. And we got screwed out of a resolution of his father issues in the finale, which annoyed me. But I really liked him in the early seasons...and I quite enjoyed RDM's portrayal as well...although it was not quite up to the level of Tim Russ.

 

[Miss Chicken]

I voted for Tuvok. He was intereresting some of the time while Paris was rather bland.