Well, after watching them all I observed a few things.
Firstly, the remastered live-action footage along with the gorgeous colour and rich sound are wonderful to experience. We also see that TOS had a lot more texture and detail than I think many people give it credit for.
The new space and ship f/x were a mixed bag. Generally they were competently done and some of them were quite nice in of themselves, but mostly I felt something was off. Many of them seemed kind of flat rather than the image of an actual three dimensional object.
In particular I thought some shots, particularly those of the Tholian ships, the Romulan D7s and the remade doomsday machine, looked too contemporary in aesthetic and rather cartoony, too obviously cgi. In the planet killer's case I still prefer the original design much better--its asymetrical shape looked more alien and its colouring was more subtle.
Who the hell voted for "A Piece Of The Action"? Not me. "Mirror, Mirror" at No. 1 was a bit of a surprise, but certainly not a disappointment. And, yes, I too would like to have seen "The Ultimate Computer." When I voted I didn't necessarily go with my absolute favourites but for those episodes with a good amount of redone f/x to see what had been done. I also really wanted to see "Where No Man Has Gone Before," but it will be in syndication very soon.
I was impressed again with "The Cage" and that Space aired the whole thing uncut and ran it with ads out to an hour and a half to make sure they got everything in there. Good for them, but then again Space has always treated TOS respectfully ever since the station first began broadcasting over a decade ago. I did appreciate some of the new f/x for "The Cage" because here they really were needed, especially since so little of the ship was seen in the original version. I wonder, though, whether they should have done something about that transparent effect sequence when the ship goes to warp--it's obviously rotoscoped and seems totally out of place.
The new f/x in TOS-R's version of "The Trouble With Tribbles" were much better than DS9's "Trials And Tribble-ations." I'm still bugged by the notion of why does the ship have to orbit the station. It doesn't make sense since the station is far too small to have any real gravity effect on the ship. It might make more sense just to have the station itself rotating, not for gravity of course but to offer a changing view out the windows perhaps.
Another thing I note after not seeing some of these episodes for awhile: the performances. There is a lot of subtle and non-verbal acting going on from everyone that is a joy to experience as it really adds nuance and insight into what characters may be thinking without uttering a word. I still think the acting in TOS generally far outstrips what we got in later series. Shatner in particularly is much better than he's often given credit for and not once did he speak in that caricatured style so exaggerated by everyone particularly standup comics. It was wonderful to see.
The only time I recall Shatner speaking in that caricatured way is in "The Lights Of Zetar" and the rest of that episode ain't any great stuff either.
