As has been said, it's hard to imagine anybody other than Brooks. And while he is certainly an extraordinary actor who made the role his own... I really would love to see how Todd would have done. I definitely think Todd would have filled the role as well as Brooks did, and I'm left wondering what other side we may have seen from the character had Todd been cast.
If only I could summon up anything in existence with the push of a button on a magic keyboard.
To think... A recording of Todd's audition is probably buried somewhere deep in the halls of Paramount's archives. How I would love to beam in and steal it...
(Why is this poll closed already?)