It's all about context. It certainly can be used as a derogatory term in the right contexts. He has another bit he says this on using the word "Jew" saying that word is both the thing you can call the people legitimately as a form of short-hand for a group of people or it can be used as a slur against a group of people.
Context.
You didn't have it in this case. The guy in the line, sure, was having a conversation he should not have been having in front of customers but what he is saying should make no impression on himself, others around him or his beliefs.
The other poster's incident, however was an entirely different context given the language used, near by patrons, the context of the language and having the bulk of the context.
Some guy making in an off-hand comment at the register? Hardly the case to take aggressive action.
Yes, we lack context. I find it interesting, however, that your default is to assume the BEST in people. That you think it's not offensive until proven otherwise.
My mind works backwards. If I saw someone frown and mutter "jew" under their breath while looking at a Jewish person I'd assume it was derogatory until I learned something that made me think I was wrong.
But you'd assume that person is a-ok until you had more context to prove otherwise?
Like I said, I guess my mind just works backwards from yours. You've got a nice 'innocent until proven guilty' thing going on in your mind, which is admirable. I'm not criticizing you, I just find it interesting.
SWC, it's interesting you pointed that out. There's an on-line personality test (IPIP-NEO) that measures or analyzes different aspects of a person's personality, and this goes way beyond the typical introvert-or-extrovert, left-handed or right-handed individual traits. One of the categories (Antagonism/Cooperation?) determines whether a person tends to look at people in a positive or a negative light. Interestingly enough, my latest test revealed that I'm on the positive side of the spectrum, and I can personally say that this is true for me as well. I think pop psychology can be fun, and this particular test appears to be backed by substantial research. Again, this is an on-line personality test, and as such, like so many things on the Internet, should be taken with a grain of salt.
