• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 6x23 - "Rightful Heir"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
RightfulHeir.jpg


Worf misses the beginning of his shift and as Riker and Picard investigate into why they discover that Worf is having something of a crisis of faith ever since he spoke of the Klingon writings of Kahless (Klingon Jesus) to the young people he rescued at a Romulan interment camp a few episodes ago. Worf has begun questioning his own "faith" and has tried to summon visions but has been unsuccessful. Picard admonishes Worf for neglecting his duties but seems to otherwise understand Worf's troubles. He recommends Worf seeks his answers at (Klingon Jerusalem) and return to the ship ready to perform his duties.

After spending several days praying and trying to get visions, Word is prepared to leave when one of the Klingon overseers of the temple helps guide Worf in how to get his visions. Worf tries again only to have Kahless return before him.

Only this isn't a Kahless vision and is instead a living being, supposedly Kahless having resurrected in order to help lead the Klingons back onto the path of righteousness, er, honor.

Worf is initially skeptical but is soon convinced after Kahless shows some prowess with a batleth and knows of things from the sacred texts known only to the highest order of the Klingon faith structure. Worf becomes a born-again Kahlesstian and is ready to help Kahless to unite all Klingons onto a new path of glory.

Gowron, the Klingon Chancellor, is not so quick to hand the Empire over and arranges to meet with Kahless before allowing knowledge of his resurrection to become widespread. He intends to test and challenge his claims as he doesn't believe this is truly a resurrected Kahless. He brings with him a knife that supposedly has the "original" Kahless's blood on it (I dunno... the Klingon Shroud of Turin?) Tests performed by Crusher show that the blood on the knife and the blood on the man before them is a perfect match.

Gowron is still not as convinced but Worf's faith is only solidified as he is now ready for this new era and pleas with Gowron to submit. Gowron still refuses saying that the Klingon Religious Right have been trying to thwart him and letting "Kahless" return to the homeworld will disrupt his reign and may inspire a new civil war. He goes so far with his belief that he challenged Kahless to a battle and easily wins. Showing that this Kahless is not the great, unbeatable, warrior he's supposed to be.

Worf confronts the religious leaders and they fess-up that this is not the "real" Kahless. Instead it's a clone created from remaining genetic material they had available and he's been imbibed with the sacred texts so he knows of Kahless's writings and teachings. Unfortunately this couldn't fill stuff they don't have answers to or Kahless' experiences in Sto-vo-kor.

Worf's faith is again crushed and he begins laughing at this, and Gowron is only too happy to reveal this notion to prevent the upset this could cause. But Worf worries that the idea of Kahless is powerful enough to split the Klingon people should Gowron reject him and this could lead to greater problems. Instead it's suggested Gowron give Kahless an honorary position in the Klingon hierarchy, allowing him to teach and inspire people to follow the Empire while Gowron continues to lead. Gowron agrees and life goes on.

------

Eh, it's an okay episode. I actually find the episodes centered around the Klingon mythology/theology to be pretty interesting and it's interesting how "thought out" it all is. More-so the religion or culture of most other Trek races with exception of the Bajorans through DS9.

It is interesting how at one point the Klingon religious leaders ask Worf how does he know if the prophecies of Khaless's return meant a literal resurrection or the artificial one they constructed here.

This episode does show some more of the dents in the armor of the Klingon government that becomes such a big thing in DS9.

Beyond that, not much to really say on this episode. It's interesting but at the same time I'm not too moved or entertained by episodes with religious undertones or themes.
 
I just watched this episode today. I was on the fence whether to watch it at all... I'm kind of glad I did so now I know not to watch it again anytime soon! Really weak... There was barely anything happening on the Enterprise or with the crew, just Klingons this and that...

And what is it with Ron Moore and Klingons? Does he have to create new Klingon mythology in every episode he writes? (in later TNG and through DS9)
 
It was a tired execution. I actually get tired watching it. The premise isn't awful, but it just didn't gel for me, & it's one of those episodes that overworked the Klingon angle. I kind of felt the same way about Birthright 2. It wore thin after a while
 
Some episodes overdue the Klingon sides and this was one of them. Within like thirty minutes I grew tired of it from what I remember.
 
I just watched this episode today. I was on the fence whether to watch it at all... I'm kind of glad I did so now I know not to watch it again anytime soon! Really weak... There was barely anything happening on the Enterprise or with the crew, just Klingons this and that...

And what is it with Ron Moore and Klingons? Does he have to create new Klingon mythology in every episode he writes? (in later TNG and through DS9)

Yeah, I'm not a big fan on the idea of religious things being introduced in Trek which, by-and-large, tried to avoid such notions and when it was introduced it did try and to offer some mundane (in universe) explanation for things. Take the "Edo God" from the first season. We see it's not a god but just a more powerful, non-corporeal, alien entity that'd taken ownership over the Edo. Their naive state just had them take it as being "god."

This episode almost does the same thing with the Klingon theology showing how strong their beliefs are in their ancient texts but also seems to suggest that as "advanced" as they are the Klingons are still beholden to their beliefs. So they have this mission where people go to find spiritual enlightenment because they still have some belief that their ancient texts are factual accounts of past events. Granted, their texts in the 24c are "newer" to them than Jesus is to us today.

While it's possible there's still scraps of religion left in humanity it's hard to believe many are going to Jerusalem, Mecca or wherever on Earth in order to make stronger connections with Jesus, Allah or any other deity, prophet or religious figure. It's suggested -often- in Trek humanity had abandoned religion in favor of just finding enlightenment and "spiritual strength" within themselves.

DS9 played with the idea of "aliens are gods" notion too, but I think it was a bit more heavy-handed on the "Well.... maybe..." side of things. Voyager touched on it a bit too, though I think it was even more ham-fisted with it and seemed to leave the "Well... maybe..." door even more wide open.

Which, I suppose is fine when we're dealing with a universe with 5th Dimensional beings -like the Q and the countless species encountered in TOS- out there, but it "helps" for me for the show to leave little doubt that "aliens" were involved rather than "gods" or religions being founded in something "real."

But that might be the Agnostic in me talking more than anything else.

This episode sort of does it, but what I think would have helped would be for Kahless to really have been *the* Kahless temporally displaced from that time centuries ago into present-day, and his memory being scrambled due to the time displacement. As time progresses he becomes more and more aware of what and who he is and recalls more of the parts of the ancient texts and stories only he'd be privy to. The episode would still more-or-less end on this "ruler stalemate" with it felt Kahless was better as a spiritual leader to unite the Empire while Gowron continued to run the modern-government which would be beyond Kahless's understanding.

It is interesting that the episode seems to give some suggestion on what the Klingon's inspiration for space-travel was, to get to the location Kahless said he'd return. Likely they had to conquer quite a bit to get to and control that location. With humans we know questions and the desire to explore got them off Earth, until this episode there's often some question on what the Klingons had to drive them into space.

I find the "theology" and belief system established among the Klingons to be interesting. I remember watching this episode not long after the DVDs came out and watching it with a friend who is a Mormon and he was interested in what was presented here in the Klingon mythology regarding their equivalent to Jesus. And I explained other aspects of their religion to him, how the Klingons -in effect- killed their gods in favor of their current belief system.

This episode and "Birthright II" did a good job in that respect, giving us more on the Klingon's "religious foundation." But, interesting as it may be, it sort of makes for lack-luster episodes especially when it's a little heavy-handed as it was here.
 
Been a long time since I've seen this episode, might have to put it on later.
 
An interesting concept that was never revisited. We never saw Kahless again which is strange considering he became the Klingon emperor. The closest we got to an update on him was in DS9's "The Sword Of Kahless" where Kor dismissed him as just a clone.

I didn't find this episode very exciting to be honest. It's always good to see Gowron again and this episode moved him towards the more ruthless, power hungry character he later became.
 
An interesting concept that was never revisited. We never saw Kahless again which is strange considering he became the Klingon emperor.

I think we should've seen Kahless in DS9 during the Dominion war.

DS9 had so many characters I'm really not all that surprised they didn't get around to Kahless but it would have been nice. As a clone maybe he could show the Vorta that clones can be in positions of real power rather than administrators.
 
We see it's not a god but just a more powerful, non-corporeal, alien entity that'd taken ownership over the Edo. Their naive state just had them take it as being "god."

Umm, how's that not being god?

For all we know, the entity also created the Edo. But that's not a requirement for being god - many deities are not creators. The entity has several other criteria down pat. Supernatural control of events: check. Moral judgement over the actions of mortals: check. Exercising aforementioned judgement theoretically in terms of smiting or not smiting, but in practice by allowing the mortals to sort it out: check. General disinterest in revealing one's existence, or offering other handles to the difficult task of establishing whether the entity even exists for real: check.

So they have this mission where people go to find spiritual enlightenment because they still have some belief that their ancient texts are factual accounts of past events. Granted, their texts in the 24c are "newer" to them than Jesus is to us today.

But that's not the only difference, or even a particularly relevant one. The real difference is that Klingons live in a universe where gods assuredly exist, and the supernatural is a verified fact. They would be superstitious fools for not considering possibilities such as
- Kahless being god
- Kahless having access to longevity technology
- Kahless having access to time travel technology
- other entities, organizations or people having powers or access amounting to making all the myths about Kahless rock-solid fact
- etc.

The last possibility actually turns out to be close to the truth...

it's hard to believe many are going to Jerusalem, Mecca or wherever on Earth in order to make stronger connections with Jesus, Allah or any other deity, prophet or religious figure.

How about people making pilgrimage to Greece in hopes of learning more about the old Greek gods which are now known to have existed for real? The pilgrims would come carrying tricorders and phase variance analyzers, but why should that make their pilgrimage any less "religious"?

As for the episode itself, it's nice to see Gowron butt in and offer the skeptical viewpoint with DNA analyses and sharp practical questions and a very, umm, hands-on approach to determining the true level of Kahless' divinity. Half of Gowron's efforts actually fail, showing how "science" can be toothless in face of "faith" - but the important and interesting thing is that absolutes play no role! Gowron ultimately gets what he wants, but Kahless' divinity isn't much endangered by the establishing of his mortality...

Agreed, though, that the episode was a bit dull in execution. But keeping the Enterprise and her circus of characters largely off screen for once isn't a bad idea.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Decent enough episode. I do find it funny that one of the background paintings make Kahless look like a Klingon Jesus. :lol:

The Borath matte paintings look pretty bad in HD though.
 
Decent enough episode. I do find it funny that one of the background paintings make Kahless look like a Klingon Jesus. :lol:

The Borath matte paintings look pretty bad in HD though.

Good afternoon human! Do you accept Our Emperor Kahless as your personal savior?!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top