• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Time's Arrow: why was Worf a member of the away team in the cave on Devidia II?

at Quark's

Vice Admiral
Admiral
I mean, let's look at what they know at this point:

1) Data's head somehow ends up on 19th century Earth, in a cave
2) There's evidence of signatures of triolic energy in that cave, which you normally won't find on either 19th or 24th century earth, and that no-one has been in this cave for 500 years, so alien intervention must have taken place around the 19th century.
3) There are clues pointing to Devidia 2, where they also find triolic energy signatures and temporal distortions
4) Data finds out that the triolic signatures and the temporal distortions are highly correlated
5) Data disappears in one such temporal disturbance.

So I'd say that even when a direct temporal gateway to 19th century earth hadn't been proved yet, they should have had pretty strong indications at this point that if they tried to replicate what Data did, they might end up on 19th century earth. Yet, Worf is part of the away team without any disguise. Why didn't they put a security officer there that could have passed for a human?

(And yes, Picard replaces Worf at the last instant, but that's only after Guinan has convinced him to do so. And Picard initially even had objections to Data going to Devidia 2 to avoid having him end up on 19th century earth , so it's not as if that link wasn't made).
 
Last edited:
Because not everyone on the Trek writing team pays as much attention to painfully obvious facts as you do.

What I want to know is where did all of the crew get their 19th century clothes, once they were over? Did Riker mug a cop for his uniform? Did Beverly phaser-stun a nurse? Or did they just find those cardsharks and have Riker take them to the cleaners this time?
 
Because not everyone on the Trek writing team pays as much attention to painfully obvious facts as you do.

What I want to know is where did all of the crew get their 19th century clothes, once they were over? Did Riker mug a cop for his uniform? Did Beverly phaser-stun a nurse? Or did they just find those cardsharks and have Riker take them to the cleaners this time?

Fizzbin?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top