• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Therapists on the bridge

There was room at the command assembly (or whatever it’s called) for five people. It would have been cool to see a visiting dignitary and their aid (or maybe a mission specialist and a department head or something) to also be there, to see Picard holding “full court.”
In the Original Series folks (dignitaries and etc) were always standing behind, by the turbolift doors IIRC. Seemed so dangerous, you know, especially when the camera started to shake! (PS: Dig your avatar Arpy! It's really trippy. :borg:)

This must be the reason why you can't get McCoy off the bridge. Please, give that man a chair. :vulcan:
:guffaw:
 
This must be the reason why you can't get McCoy off the bridge. Please, give that man a chair. :vulcan:

^Somehow, I can see McCoy get into a huge conflict with captain Jellico (with Jellico asking him what his reason for being on the bridge is in the first place ) ;)
 
Deanna's presence on the bridge makes sense because of her empathic abilities. Highly useful skill for a starship captain to have at his disposal during negotiations/conflicts etc. Same could be said for a telepath. As a captain, who wouldn't want to have that resource available?

There would be little reason for a ship's counselor with no such abilities to have a permanent bridge chair.

One of my favorite Deanna moments on the bridge is when Geordi is on the pakled ship. She warns Riker, that something is not right. Riker ignores her and then she doesn't mention anything more about it. Of course, that would have ended the episode right there. :lol: Very lazy writing.
 
I'm just glad they didn't have her holding a healing crystal or have picard sit under a dowel rod pyramid with a soundtrack by Windham Hill. It WAS the late 80s
 
The rapists are on the bridge???????!!!1!!


itenb.jpg

45363808_22d7310e47_o.jpg
 
Guinan runs a holobrothel?
Lol. He listens to people and gives advice. He puts those ears to good use. Ironically, Quark attempts to improve on his "Guinan skills," when he runs into a competitor of Guinan's race in "Rivals."

Deanna's presence on the bridge makes sense because of her empathic abilities. Highly useful skill for a starship captain to have at his disposal during negotiations/conflicts etc. Same could be said for a telepath. As a captain, who wouldn't want to have that resource available?

There would be little reason for a ship's counselor with no such abilities to have a permanent bridge chair.

One of my favorite Deanna moments on the bridge is when Geordi is on the pakled ship. She warns Riker, that something is not right. Riker ignores her and then she doesn't mention anything more about it. Of course, that would have ended the episode right there. :lol: Very lazy writing.
Troi "I sense a deception"
Riker "lol... yeah, right. Have you had a good look at them?"
Geordi "What? Did your rubber band break?"

Audience and Pakleds think to themselves "wow, you are an a-hole"
 
Last edited:
Among the conquered races in the Star Empire, full telepaths might have been useful to the Romulans. It might have been cool to do a story about tele/empaths on Starfleet ships being stationed at least one-per to counter tele-espionage.
 
When we see that episode where the alien boy creates a future for Riker in his holodeck cave, we see Troi left the ship to stay with "Ambassador" Picard as his advisor.
Afraid not. In Future Imperfect, Picard was an Admiral, not an Ambassador. And Deanna was his aide, not his advisor.
Among the conquered races in the Star Empire, full telepaths might have been useful to the Romulans.
Romulans do have a telepathic slave race, the Remans. Just the Romulans prefer to use them as cannon fodder.
 
Afraid not. In Future Imperfect, Picard was an Admiral, not an Ambassador. And Deanna was his aide, not his advisor.
Fine, he's an Admiral, conducting diplomatic negotiations with a Romulan ambassador. In this scenario, Picard has taken Troi with him to stay at his side, doing what she always has, advising him. She's not some jr. officer "aide," nor does any of this make any difference.
 
She's not some jr. officer "aide," nor does any of this make any difference.
Most aides to Admirals are actually high ranking officers. Admiral Nechayev's aide was a Commander, as was Commander Benteen, Admiral Leyton's aide. Sisko was a Captain when he worked as Admiral Ross's aide at the start of season 6. While Deanna might have given advice to Admiral Picard, her official job was his aide, not an advisor.
 
Most aides to Admirals are actually high ranking officers. Admiral Nechayev's aide was a Commander, as was Commander Benteen, Admiral Leyton's aide. Sisko was a Captain when he worked as Admiral Ross's aide at the start of season 6. While Deanna might have given advice to Admiral Picard, her official job was his aide, not an advisor.
Please quote the relevant dialogue where she is called an "aide," then you can explain the difference, how it applies to Troi, and maybe at end whether you have a point or not.
 
Please quote the relevant dialogue where she is called an "aide," then you can explain the difference, how it applies to Troi, and maybe at end whether you have a point or not.
Memory Alpha says she's an aide in Future Imperfect, so that's good enough for me.
 
This must be the reason why you can't get McCoy off the bridge. Please, give that man a chair. :vulcan:
It would probably be Picard's nightmare scenario to have the CMO next to him all the time, whether it would be Crusher or Pulaski. :lol: I can picture Beverly constantly giving Picard that look she gave him at the end of "Allegiance."

Regarding other posts about "Future Imperfect," that episode presents nothing more than an advanced holographic simulation by a kid, and can't be taken as any kind of resource about Picard's future or anyone else's.
 
I believe in the episode itself, Troi just says that Picard offered her a position at Starfleet Command. They don't say exactly what her job title was. Of course, the whole scenario was concocted by an adolescent alien who thought Minuet was a real person.

Kor
 
Please quote the relevant dialogue where Troi gives the Admiral advice.
It's a given, as Troi always advises Picard in diplomatic interactions, unless you think he demoted her to making his morning coffee and taking his phone calls.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top