I also was not a huge fan of the portrayal of the "Dark One" as a fairly average Joe.
I'm surprised you both find it notable since...But I didn't care for the actor playing the dark one, which hurt the effectivenessof those scenes he is in.
...we know it was actually Ishmael. I thought it made sense within the show to have this "Dark One" be a bit... underwhelming, since he will at some point be revealed to be a poseur. The real thing will be all the more climactic.
Yet again, I agree with you both over all; I felt this would have worked better as two-part or double length episode, which would have allowed it to have a bit more coherence.Same here. It stands to reason that the people in the Age of Legends are aware the 'champion of good' exists and there was one before Lews as well, but not with that particular title...
And here is my traditional review, with episode spoilers above and book spoilers below.
Mmm. Some good character moments but overall... this episode left me feeling a bit deflated. I'll be the first to say that the finale of the first book isn't amazing. Given that the actual Eye is being presented very differently from the books, I am not surprised by the amount of changes to the story but... it felt so uneven in the editing. Again. The cold open being told entirely in the Old Tongue and being all talk of things we're not going to see is a good example of that. It's my least favourite of the teasers so far. And there are so many amazing moments from Lews Therin's life that could have worked well here. It's the start of an episode that for me at least is filled with 'they chose to focus on THAT?' moments.
The episode is split between essentially 3 stories: Rand and Moiraine, Egwene and Nynaeve, and Amalisa and Agelmar. Perrin's role is limited, and is basically just there for setting up season 2 at the end. After the credits, I kind of liked it up to the point where the alarms of Fal Dara go off. Min continues to be great, showing here how her ability is a burden to her, because of all the terrible fates for people she can see. Egwene and Perrin reconnecting after the previous night's spat was welcome and from the way the dialogue went, I'm almost starting to believe that the love triangle is running in a different direction for Perrin here (we'll not starting worrying about the lore until they cast his "falcon" with a man, lol). I think the things we got with Rand and Moiraine were mostly in tone with the original story. The subtle hints of Rand finally beginning to understand Moiraine's actions... the unanswered questions and looks between them told a lot without the need for dialogue, so kudos to the actors for that.
But the rest... I don't know. Battle scenes might look impressive, but they don't do much for the characters here. Nynaeve and Egwene are basically relegated to being storage batteries and oddly it's Perrin in his few short scenes who seems to have the most development. I can't comment much on that without going into book 2 spoilers, so more on that below. The time invested with Amalisa and Agelmar also feels somewhat wasted, as both are apparently unceremoniously killed off. Their actions parallel the earlier story of the fall of Manetheren, but I'm not sure that means much for the ongoing narrative. The addition of the Karene and Stepin storyline I ended up appreciating quite a bit, for it served multiple purposes, mirroring Lan and Moiraine and also telling us about Aes Sedai/Warders in general. I don't feel the same about the new content here. It's not a bad idea per se, and does showcase the mentality of the Borderlands, but there are other things I'd have chosen to focus on. And we also have to ask if 5 untrained / too weak to become Aes Sedai women can save a city by themselves... what do we need Rand for anyway?
Book progress: Book 1 completed + book 2 chapters 1-7 (approx.). Rating: 2 out of 5 surviving women. (Sorry for the lore changes ladies, you should have survived that.)
Book comparisons... well. We have our work cut out for us today, there are SO many changes. Starting with the basics, the journey from Fal Dara to the Eye is shown, but it is much, much shorter and only undertaken by Moiraine, Rand, and later Lan. The Eye itself keeps only its name, as it is not presented as a the ultimate refuge, but as the Dark One's prison. (Talk about changing things...) The fight against 2 of the Forsaken is omitted, and we instead are presented with a battle of wills between Rand and the "Dark One", with the small sa'angreal taking over the role of the actual Eye as the pool of Power for Rand to draw on. This part borrows more from the final confrontation between Rand and Moridin in the last book than it does their meeting in the first book, and we are also denied Rand's actions being presented to the world, as he does not appear over the army fighting in Tarwin's Gap to save it. There are some nods to the books though, as his fictional daughter by Egwene has the same name as she has in the books (when it is Egwene presented with a vision of this future during her testing in the Tower) and there is also the first mention of cuendillar, though it is not immediately recognized as one of the seals on the Dark One's prison. Finally, this plot ends with Rand going off solo, a bit reminiscent of his actions at the start of book 3, and Moiraine being what appears to be permanently shielded (not stilled, as we see Ishamael put the same weave on her as is put on Logain in episode 4). This is a huge departure from the books, but likely will serve to give Moiraine a story arc for season 2, as in book 2 she is largely absent from the proceedings. It is an odd choice, but will go onto the "judge when we get an idea of where they go with it" pile.
The battle at Tarwin's Gap, located much closer to Fal Dara now, starts off mostly identical to the books, with Lord Agelmar rallying his forces for what he believes to be a futile attempt to stop the Trolloc horde. The story then departs from the books, with it being Amalisa and her group of channelers who save the city with the Power instead of Rand, with Agelmar and his troops apparently dying instead of being saved. Neither Agelmar nor Amalisa have large roles in the books, but their deaths here are certainly a departure from the lore. Other departures are visible during the Power battle scene, with Nynaeve seemingly having no problems linking with Amalisa and later apparently being healed from the brink of death by Egwene. Both instances imply a skill that these characters do not learn until much later into the series.
Finally, we have the reveal of the Horn of Valere. With the changes made to the Eye, we do not find it there but instead in storage at Fal Dara, and much like in the books, Fain comes to steal it from its vault. In another departure, possibly to cover Barney Harris's departure, Loial is stabbed with the dagger, likely to serve as a catalyst for Perrin wanting to go and track down Fain and the dagger in season 2.
The episode ends with a teaser for season 2 and the reveal of the Seanchan invasion fleet, with a pair of damane being instructed to create a tidal wave by a pair of sul'dam. Possibly in some sort of ceremony, given that it feels a bit much for ruining the day of a little girl picking seashells. The Seanchan invasion happens off-page in the books, but timing and location are accurate. A lot of fans are speculating Falme will be dropped and we are going straight to Tear in season 2, but the location card - the first of the series - seems to dispell that idea.
ETA: And Merry Christmas to all! I'm still waiting for everyone to wake up.

Last edited: