***The Star Trek Episode Clash!*** The Results!

[Naraht]

Re: July 8 Results (Rematch #4)

Posted by Eddie Roth:
TNG ups its number of wins with Hide & Q securing the top rank in Round 8's rematch.

Great! Hide and Q really deserved it. It was also the first TNG episode that I've voted for in the rematch, despite being first and foremost a TNG fan.

 

[Eddie Roth]

Re: Results Rematch #3

Posted by Computer Voice:
I like the new scoring system, Eddie Roth.

Its interesting to see that ENT is second, where as with the old system it was fourth.

Well, remember that the new scoring system only reflects Rounds 0-9 and 59-74 so far. But I think the difference will be seen too when all the rematches are done. ENT has done well recently, meaning as far as the Clashes go, it has probably been more popular than TNG.

 

[Eddie Roth]

Results Rematch #5

Who would've thought?

Two new winners this time, an interestingly enough, two unlikely ones - at least that's what I thought: DataLore takes the crown from Dear Doctor, and Shadows of P'Jem bests 11001001. Full Results of Rematch #5:

1. The Big Goodbye (18 votes)
2. Silent Enemy (12)
3. Miri (6)
3. Vortex (6)
5. Heroes and Demons (5)

1. DataLore (18)
2. Dear Doctor (12)
3. The Conscience of the King (6)
3. Battle Lines (6)
5. Cathexis (5)

1. The Galileo Seven (29)
2. Faces (9)
3. Sleeping Dogs (6)
4. The Storyteller (3)
5. Angel One (1)

1. Shadows of P'Jem (13)
2. 11001001 (11)
3. Jetrel (9)
4. Progress (8)
5. Court-Martial (7)

TNG takes a win from ENT, and ENT takes one back, so no changes in the (old style) championship ranking this week.

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 14 rematches.

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): TNG DataLore (R)
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): ENT Shadows of P`Jem (R)
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001


All-win Championship Ranking (# of fights won) (% of fights won) (all rounds)

1. DS9 25 won 33.3%
2. TOS 20 won 26.7%
3. TNG 15 won 20.0%
4. ENT 10 won 13.4%
5. VGR 5 won 6.6%

All-ranks Championship Ranking (Rounds 000-013 ; 059-074)

1. DS9 783 points (26.10% average)
2. ENT 640 points (21.33% average)
3. TNG 628 points (20.93% average)
4. TOS 528 points (17.60% average)
5. VGR 319 points (10.63% average)

 

[Eddie Roth]

July 22 Results (Rematch #6)

Balance of Power

TOS wins three, DS9 two in the latest rematch. Only one new winner is among these: The Meangerie Part 1, which narrowly beat out ENT's Shuttlepod One this time. In the new championship ranking, TOS now ascends to third place behind DS9 and ENT.

1. The Menagerie Part 1 (22 votes)
2. Shuttlepod One (21)
3. Learning Curve (3)
4. If Wishes Were Horses (2)
5. Too Short A Season (1)

1. The Menagerie Part 2 (28)
2. The Forsaken (8)
3. Fusion (6)
4. The 37's (5)
5. When The Bough Breaks (2)

1. Shore Leave (21)
2. Dramatis Personae (14)
3. Initiations (6)
4. Home Soil (4)
5. Rogue Planet (3)

1. Duet (38)
2. The Squire of Gothos (4)
3. Projections (3)
3. Acquisition (3)
5. Coming of Age (1)

1. In The Hands of the Prophets (21)
2. Arena (14)
3. Heart of Glory (9)
4. Oasis (5)
5. Elogium (-)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 19 rematches.

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): TNG DataLore (R)
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): ENT Shadows of P`Jem (R)
Round 014 (Ep. #016): TOS The Menagerie Part 1 (R)
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One


All-win Championship Ranking (# of fights won) (% of fights won) (all rounds)

1. DS9 25 won 33.3%
2. TOS 21 won 28.0%
3. TNG 15 won 20.0%
4. ENT 9 won 12.0%
5. VGR 5 won 6.6%

All-ranks Championship Ranking (Rounds 000-018 ; 059-074)

1. DS9 951 points (27.17% average)
2. ENT 716 points (20.46% average)
3. TOS 708 points (20.23% average)
4. TNG 662 points (18.91% average)
5. VGR 353 points (10.08% average)

 

[Eddie Roth]

July 29 Results (Rematch #7)

How close is close?

All four winners were confirmed this week: The entire Circle Trilogy as well as A Taste of Armageddon stay the winners in the latest rematch, but except for Round 22, all were very very close:

1. The Homecoming (15)
2. The Arsenal of Freedom (14)
3. Non Sequitur (11)
4. Detained (5)
5. The Alternative Factor (3)

1. The Circle (16)
2. Tomorrow Is Yesterday (15)
3. Symbiosis (7)
4. Vox Sola (6)
5. Twisted (4)

1. The Siege (15)
2. Skin of Evil (13)
3. The Return of the Archons (10)
4. Fallen Hero (8)
5. Parturition (2)

1. A Taste of Armageddon (20)
2. Invasive Procedures (9)
3. We'll Always Have Paris (8)
3. Persistence of Vision (8)
5. Desert Crossing (3)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 23 rematches.

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): TNG DataLore (R)
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): ENT Shadows of P`Jem (R)
Round 014 (Ep. #016): TOS The Menagerie Part 1 (R)
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One


All-win Championship Ranking (# of fights won) (% of fights won) (all rounds)

1. DS9 25 won 33.3%
2. TOS 21 won 28.0%
3. TNG 15 won 20.0%
4. ENT 9 won 12.0%
5. VGR 5 won 6.6%

All-ranks Championship Ranking (Rounds 000-022 ; 059-074)

1. DS9 1064 points (27.28% average)
2. TOS 806 points (20.67% average)
3. ENT 760 points (19.48% average)
4. TNG 738 points (18.92% average)
5. VGR 403 points (10.33% average)

 

[Eddie Roth]

August 5 Results (Rematch #8)

Head to Head

Three out of four rematches ended predictably: Space Seed, The Neutral Zone and The Devil in the Dark are the old and new winners.

Round 23

1. Space Seed (18)
2. Conspiracy (14)
3. Cardassians (12)
4. Two Days and Two Nights (3)
5. Tattoo (0)

Round 24

1. The Neutral Zone (16)
2. Shockwave (13)
3. This Side of Paradise (11)
4. Cold Fire (5)
5. Melora (2)

Round 25

1. The Devil in the Dark (24)
2. Shockwave, Part II (10)
3. Maneuvers (8)
4. Rules of Acquisition (5)
5. The Child (0)

Round 26 however ended with a tie, which is why next round will have the necessary tiebreaker attached.

1. Errand of Mercy (169
1. Necessary Evil (16)
3. Where Silence Has Lease (8)
4. Carbon Creek (5)
5. Resistance (2)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 26 rematches.

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): TNG DataLore (R)
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): ENT Shadows of P'Jem (R)
Round 014 (Ep. #016): TOS The Menagerie Part 1 (R)
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): TBD TBD
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One


All-win Championship Ranking (# of fights won) (% of fights won) (all rounds)

1. DS9 25 won 33.3%
2. TOS 21 won 28.0%
3. TNG 15 won 20.0%
4. ENT 9 won 12.0%
5. VGR 5 won 6.6%

All-ranks Championship Ranking (Rounds 000-018 ; 059-074)

1. DS9 1137 points (26.44% average)
2. TOS 952 points (22.14% average)
3. ENT 824 points (19.16% average)
4. TNG 808 points (18.79% average)
5. VGR 434 points (10.09% average)

 

[Eddie Roth]

August 12 Results (Rematch #9)

Where is everybody?

A weird round of rematches indeed. Only 30 people participated - is everybody on holiday? The tiebreaker ended in a tie, and so did Round 28.

So for now, I'll enter both Errand of Mercy and Necessary Evil into the winners list. I think we should do another tiebreaker later, but not now. The other winners were the old ones: The City on the Edge of Forever won Round 27...

1. The City on the Edge of Forever (22)
2. Elementary Dear Data (3)
2. Minefield (3)
4. Second Sight (1)
4. Prototype (1)

...and Round 29:

1. Rivals (11)
2. Loud As A Whisper (10)
3. A Night In Sickbay (5)
4. Catspaw (3)
5. Threshold (1)

Round 28 ended in a tie:

1. Operation Annhilate/Dead Stop (9)
3. Sanctuary (6)
4. Alliances (3)
5. The Outrageous Okona (2)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 28 rematches.

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): TNG DataLore (R)
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): ENT Shadows of P'Jem (R)
Round 014 (Ep. #016): TOS The Menagerie Part 1 (R)
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): TOS/DS9 Errand of Mercy/Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One


All-win Championship Ranking (# of fights won) (% of fights won) (all rounds)

1. DS9 25 won 33.3%
2. TOS 21 won 28.0%
3. TNG 15 won 20.0%
4. ENT 9 won 12.0%
5. VGR 5 won 6.6%

All-ranks Championship Ranking (Rounds 000-018 ; 059-074)

1. DS9 1196 points (26.00% average)
2. TOS 1066 points (23.17% average)
3. ENT 881 points (19.15% average)
4. TNG 857 points (18.63% average)
5. VGR 450 points ( 9.78% average)

 

[Computer Voice]

Re: August 12 Results (Rematch #9)

Ooooh TOS is catching up with DS9.

 

[Eddie Roth]

Re: August 12 Results (Rematch #9)

Yes, if slowly. TOS would be #1 right now, but the more recent rounds (where TOS is in its third season) lower its average a lot. Still, it should get a lot closer soon.

 

[MacLeod]

Re: August 12 Results (Rematch #9)

Posted by Computer Voice:
Ooooh TOS is catching up with DS9.

what's even more worrying is that ENT is in 3rd place ahead of TNG

 

[Eddie Roth]

August 19 Results (Rematch #10)

Good Day for Voyager

In Rematch #10, VGR scored its best results so far. While DS9's Whispers dethroned Death Wish (by a hair) as champion of Round 32, Meld relieved the previous winner Metamorphosis in Round 30.

Tiebreaker
1. Operation Annihilate (23 votes)
2. Dead Stop (18)

Round 30

1. Meld (13)
2. Metamorphosis (12)
3. The Schizoid Man (7)
4. The Alternate (6)
5. Marauders (4)

Round 31

1. Armageddon Game (15)
2. Dreadnought (12)
3. Friday's Child (7)
4. Unnatural Selection (5)
5. The Seventh (3)

Round 32

1. Whispers (15)
2. Death Wish (14)
3. The Communicator (8)
4. Who Mourns For Adonais / A Matter of Honor (4)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 75 finished fights and 33 rematches.

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): TNG DataLore (R)
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): ENT Shadows of P`Jem (R)
Round 014 (Ep. #016): TOS The Menagerie Part 1 (R)
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): TOS/DS9 Errand of Mercy/Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): TOS Operation Annihilate (R)
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): VGR Meld (R)
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): DS9 Whispers (R)
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell, Part I

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish


All-win Championship Ranking (# of fights won) (% of fights won) (all rounds)

1. DS9 26 won 34.6%
2. TOS 21 won 28.0%
3. TNG 15 won 20.0%
4. ENT 8 won 10.7%
5. VGR 5 won 6.6%

All-ranks Championship Ranking (Rounds 000-032 ; 059-074)

1. DS9 1278 points (26.08% average)
2. TOS 1118 points (22.81% average)
3. ENT 914 points (18.65% average)
4. TNG 892 points (18.20% average)
5. VGR 539 points (11.00% average)

The Episode Clash! takes a break until mid to late October, when new ENT episodes begin to air. Starting then, we'll have one brand new Clash each week, along with two or three of the remaining Rematches.

So, make sure to be back when classics Amok Time and The Measure of a Man fight it out once again, and it's Requiem for Methuselah vs. Brothers vs. Indiscretion vs. Year of Hell, Part II vs. Storm Front, Part I

Until then, have a great rest of the summer. Thanks again for the mighty participation last season!

 

[Eddie Roth]

New season coming soon...

Just to bring you up to speed on past results, a little bump for the thread. Since ENT has returned with new shows, The Episode Clash will return soon as well.

 

[Naraht]

Re: New season coming soon...

Fantastic! I can't wait.

 

[Corwwyn]

Re: New season coming soon...

Woohoo!

 

[Montresor]

Re: New season coming soon...

I've been wondering when the Clash would start up again! Coolness!

 

[Danny99]

Re: New season coming soon...

Can't wait!

 

[Eddie Roth]

Re: New season coming soon...

^^^Don't have to! Round 75 is now open.

 

[Computer Voice]

Re: New season coming soon...

Nice to see The Clash back! I always look forward to it.

 

[Eddie Roth]

October 27 Results (Round 75)

VGR's best 'Year'

Year of Hell, Part II takes the prize in the return edition of the Clash! Out of 73 votes, 27 (36%) chose the episode as the best Episode #77. On the ranks:

2. Brothers (18)
3. Indiscretion (15)
4. Storm Front (8)
5. Requiem for Methuselah (7)

The Round 26 tiebreaker was won (as before) by Necessary Evil (35) vs. Errand of Mercy's 30 votes.

The Round 33 rematch was won by TNG's The Measure of a Man, with a surprisingly high 32 votes. Runner-up, another classic, Amok Time, only got 22 votes. On the ranks:

3. Singularity (9)
4. Paradise (7)
5. Lifesigns (4)

Standings in The Battle of the Shows! after 76 finished fights and 34 rematches.

The winners

Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): DS9 Emissary (R)
Round 001 (Ep. #003): TOS The Corbomite Maneuver
Round 002 (Ep. #004): ENT Strange New World
Round 003 (Ep. #005): TOS The Enemy Within
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TOS The Man Trap (R)
Round 005 (Ep. #007): ENT The Andorian Incident
Round 006 (Ep. #008): DS9 Dax
Round 007 (Ep. #009): TOS Balance of Terror
Round 008 (Ep. #010): TNG Hide & Q (R)
Round 009 (Ep. #011): ENT Cold Front
Round 010 (Ep. #012): TNG The Big Goodbye
Round 011 (Ep. #013): TNG DataLore (R)
Round 012 (Ep. #014): TOS The Galileo Seven
Round 013 (Ep. #015): ENT Shadows of P`Jem (R)
Round 014 (Ep. #016): TOS The Menagerie Part 1 (R)
Round 015 (Ep. #017): TOS The Menagerie Part 2
Round 016 (Ep. #018): TOS Shore Leave
Round 017 (Ep. #019): DS9 Duet
Round 018 (Ep. #020): DS9 In the Hands of the Prophets
Round 019 (Ep. #021): DS9 The Homecoming
Round 020 (Ep. #022): DS9 The Circle
Round 021 (Ep. #023): DS9 The Siege
Round 022 (Ep. #024): TOS A Taste of Armageddon
Round 023 (Ep. #025): TOS Space Seed
Round 024 (Ep. #026): TNG The Neutral Zone
Round 025 (Ep. #027): TOS The Devil in the Dark
Round 026 (Ep. #028): DS9 Necessary Evil
Round 027 (Ep. #029): TOS The City on the Edge of Forever
Round 028 (Ep. #030): TOS Operation Annihilate (R)
Round 029 (Ep. #031): DS9 Rivals
Round 030 (Ep. #032): VGR Meld (R)
Round 031 (Ep. #033): DS9 Armageddon Game
Round 032 (Ep. #034): DS9 Whispers (R)
Round 033 (Ep. #035): TNG The Measure of a Man
Round 034 (Ep. #036): TOS The Doomsday Machine
Round 035 (Ep. #037): TNG Contagion
Round 036 (Ep. #038): ENT The Catwalk
Round 037 (Ep. #039): TNG Time Squared
Round 038 (Ep. #040): TOS Mirror, Mirror
Round 039 (Ep. #041): DS9 The Maquis, Part II
Round 040 (Ep. #042): TNG Q Who?
Round 041 (Ep. #043): TOS The Trouble With Tribbles
Round 042 (Ep. #044): TOS Bread and Circuses
Round 043 (Ep. #045): TOS Journey To Babel
Round 044 (Ep. #046): DS9 The Jem`Hadar
Round 045 (Ep. #047): TNG Peak Performance
Round 046 (Ep. #048): ENT Cogenitor
Round 047 (Ep. #049): DS9 The House of Quark
Round 048 (Ep. #050): VGR Future`s End, Part I
Round 049 (Ep. #051): TNG The Survivors
Round 050 (Ep. #052): TNG Who Watches The Watchers
Round 051 (Ep. #053): DS9 Civil Defense
Round 052 (Ep. #054): TOS The Ultimate Computer
Round 053 (Ep. #055): DS9 Defiant
Round 054 (Ep. #056): TOS Assignment: Earth
Round 055 (Ep. #057): DS9 Past Tense, Part I
Round 056 (Ep. #058): DS9 Past Tense, Part II
Round 057 (Ep. #059): DS9 Life Support
Round 058 (Ep. #060): TOS The Enterprise Incident
Round 059 (Ep. #061): DS9 Destiny
Round 060 (Ep. #062): ENT Similitude
Round 061 (Ep. #063): TNG Yesterday`s Enterprise
Round 062 (Ep. #064): TNG The Offspring
Round 063 (Ep. #065): DS9 Through The Looking Glass
Round 064 (Ep. #066): DS9 Improbable Cause
Round 065 (Ep. #067): DS9 The Die Is Cast
Round 066 (Ep. #068): VGR Scorpion
Round 067 (Ep. #069): VGR Scorpion, Part II
Round 068 (Ep. #070): ENT Azati Prime
Round 069 (Ep. #071): TNG Sarek
Round 070 (Ep. #072): DS9 The Adversary
Round 071 (Ep. #073): DS9 The Way of the Warrior, Part I
Round 072 (Ep. #074): TNG The Best of Both Worlds
Round 073 (Ep. #075): DS9 The Visitor
Round 074 (Ep. #076): VGR Year of Hell
Round 075 (Ep. #077): VGR Year of Hell, Part II

Original Winners
Round 000 (Ep. #PIL): ENT Broken Bow
Round 004 (Ep. #006): TNG Where No One Has Gone Before
Round 008 (Ep. #010): VGR Prime Factors
Round 011 (Ep. #013): ENT Dear Doctor
Round 013 (Ep. #015): TNG 11001001
Round 014 (Ep. #016): ENT Shuttlepod One
Round 028 (Ep. #030): ENT Dead Stop
Round 030 (Ep. #032): TOS Metamorphosis
Round 032 (Ep. #034): VGR Death Wish


All-win Championship Ranking (# of fights won) (% of fights won) (all rounds)

1. DS9 26 won 34.2%
2. TOS 21 won 27.6%
3. TNG 15 won 19.7%
4. ENT 8 won 10.5%
5. VGR 6 won 7.9%

All-ranks Championship Ranking (Rounds 000-033 ; 059-075)

1. DS9 1307 points (25.62% average)
2. TOS 1155 points (22.65% average)
3. TNG 959 points (18.80% average)
4. ENT 935 points (18.33% average)
5. VGR 580 points (11.37% average)

Round 76, which comes with two more rematches, opens soon.

 

[joe40001]

Re: October 27 Results (Round 75)

It's funny, DS9 is the only series that has not lost a single point due to the rematches... I wonder if these forums aren't a wee bit biased.