I'm going with not as much.
Spoilers The Ships of Lower Decks
- Thread starter Tuskin38
- Start date
It wouldn't've made sense for Clancy to be leading the fleet anyway, because she's a f***ing Fleet Admiral and the Commander-in-Chief of all Starfleet. She probably has ten trillion employees to look after and the safety of ten thousand worlds to consider. Sure, she can be consulted orwhatnot, but she belongs behind a desk in San Fran, or making public appearances on Altair VI.
Send in a lower-level Admiral or, in this case, a reactivated old Captain to command your clone fleet.
Send in a lower-level Admiral or, in this case, a reactivated old Captain to command your clone fleet.
I just realized we didn't have one of these, we do in the PIC and DSC Subforumd so here we go.
What did you guys think of the ships of Season 1? New and old.
The Titan being a Luna-Class like in the novels really surprised me. Like I know CBS owns the rights to the design, but it just didn't feel likely to me.
I also loved 'Vindicta's Klingon looking ship that was kinda cool, the Packleds hybrid ship was also neat.
What did you guys think of the ships of Season 1? New and old.
The Titan being a Luna-Class like in the novels really surprised me. Like I know CBS owns the rights to the design, but it just didn't feel likely to me.
I also loved 'Vindicta's Klingon looking ship that was kinda cool, the Packleds hybrid ship was also neat.
The Titan being Luna class has been done elsewhere, STO and Brannon Braga's Hive comic series from IDW. Honestly, it would actually seem weirder to me if it hadn't been a Luna class in the show. This isn't exactly unprecedented, the TOSR version of The Ultimate Computer did use Vanguard's design for the starbase.
Had I been in charge of CBS's marketing department, I would have made the Titan a different class of ship from the formerly non-canon Sean Torangeau design, as a new ship would have provided more revenue with new accompanying merchandise. Also, I was never a fan of the design in the first place, thinking it an unoriginal meshing of an Akira and a Sovereign class. But like it or not, it's canon now.
I'm also not a huge fan of the California class in general (and don't get me started on the ridiculously huge range of registry numbers the ships have.) The early descriptions for Lower Decks had me thinking that the ship was going to be very utilitarian in nature, sort of a tow-truck version of a starship or a supply vessel with lots of cargo containers, etc. Just a very workhorse-like design, extremely different from the usual Galaxy class or other streamlined vessels. And by the very nature of the show's title, I figured the cast would be located at the very bottom of a secondary hull with literally nothing underneath them. Instead, we got a somewhat simple design that's not all that different from the BoBW kitbashes. It's just a simple saucer with two underslung nacelles and a deflector pod between them which is in and of itself an awkward and illogical design, and it hardly screams 'workhorse' to me. But that was my preconceived notion, and probably won't be popular with the LDS lovers.
I'm not sure why the Osler looks so unlike a Starfleet vessel, unless they gave a reason in the episode that I don't know about. It looks more like a generic alien design.
And chalk me up with the rest of the crowd who likes the Vancouver class, as I'm a fan of the Galaxy class style of design. The only gripe I have (and this has more to do with the California class than the Vancouver) is that the saucer and bridge resemble the California class, but the latter class is implied to be much older (unless all the Califonia class ships were physically refit to look more contemporary to the newer Vancouver class, but that's not really implied in the show.)
I'm also not a huge fan of the California class in general (and don't get me started on the ridiculously huge range of registry numbers the ships have.) The early descriptions for Lower Decks had me thinking that the ship was going to be very utilitarian in nature, sort of a tow-truck version of a starship or a supply vessel with lots of cargo containers, etc. Just a very workhorse-like design, extremely different from the usual Galaxy class or other streamlined vessels. And by the very nature of the show's title, I figured the cast would be located at the very bottom of a secondary hull with literally nothing underneath them. Instead, we got a somewhat simple design that's not all that different from the BoBW kitbashes. It's just a simple saucer with two underslung nacelles and a deflector pod between them which is in and of itself an awkward and illogical design, and it hardly screams 'workhorse' to me. But that was my preconceived notion, and probably won't be popular with the LDS lovers.
I'm not sure why the Osler looks so unlike a Starfleet vessel, unless they gave a reason in the episode that I don't know about. It looks more like a generic alien design.
And chalk me up with the rest of the crowd who likes the Vancouver class, as I'm a fan of the Galaxy class style of design. The only gripe I have (and this has more to do with the California class than the Vancouver) is that the saucer and bridge resemble the California class, but the latter class is implied to be much older (unless all the Califonia class ships were physically refit to look more contemporary to the newer Vancouver class, but that's not really implied in the show.)
Would have it? Most Trek fans have probably never seen the Luna before it appeared in Lower Decks, or maybe didn't care about it before now because it was only from the books.
Novel readers do make a small portion of the audience.
The California class isn't my favorite, but as far workhorses go it fits as well as something like the other types I've seen.
Eaglemoss had already made a model of it way before it appeared in LDS. Since they also make non-canon Trek ships, it would have been an opportunity to sell another (better?) Titan design and relegate Torangeau's back to non-canon status.
Yeah, but now they can sell more, and make even more merch of it.
So I really don't see how it makes them that much less money.
The people who already bought the Titan before are not going to buy the exact same model again. However, if there was a new design for the ship, they would potentially buy it and then have two Titans in their collection, one canon and one not. Sure, there may be some people who didn't originally buy the model before who might buy it now because it's now canon, but I think there would be far more people who would buy a completely different version of the Titan than a design that's already ten years old.
The LDS design is tweaked from the Eaglemoss look slightly in shape. STO has already released a T6 Zen Store version of the LDS design and folk are buying that, despite the Luna being available free as a T4 design and upgradeable to a Fleet version.
Look at Transformers if you think folk won't buy multiple slightly different versions of the same model.
STO’s is based on the original design, or Tobias Richter’s take on it at least (he’s even the one who modelled it for them), not the LDS version.
It doesn’t have any of the changes seen in the LDS version, no inverted blue glowing phaser strips for example.
Last edited:
Apologies, I hadn't looked at it too closely - they released the T6 Science Destroyer version because STO gave them the excuse (it includes the "It's Another Enterprise!" trait) but it isn't actually modelled on the LDS version, though it is significantly different to the base Luna:
https://www.arcgames.com/en/games/star-trek-online/news/detail/11480803-it's-the-titan!
Luna class is all right. California class not much.
While the Cali class isnt a looker, I like it.
Love the Vancouver
And I'm happy as a bear in honey that Sean's design is now cannon.
Hoping they'll do the other book one with Ezri dax commanding the Aventine
Love the Vancouver
And I'm happy as a bear in honey that Sean's design is now cannon.
Hoping they'll do the other book one with Ezri dax commanding the Aventine
It has grown on me. Far more than I thought it would with the way the saucer is.
Similar threads
